Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

RELIGION-PAKISTAN: Veiling Women in Punjab

Zafar Malik

ISLAMABAD, Dec 21 1997 (IPS) - The veil has once again come between Muslim fundamentalists and groups fighting for women’s rights in Pakistan.

A recent ban on cultural activities in schools and colleges in the Punjab province demands that all girl students and their lady teachers wear the burqa (black shroud) or face punishment. “Teachers who did not observe veil would face official inquiry while students will face punishment,” a notification said.

But simmering opposition is evident in a ‘Letter to the Editor’ of an English-language daily in which a teacher writes that she prefers losing her job to wearing the burqa.

The writer said she was prepared to wear a veil if Punjabi Chief Minister Shabaz Sharif first put the burqa on the wife of his brother and Prime Minister, Nawaz Sharif. “Bhabi Sahiba,” charged the writer, “was recently seen roaming unveiled among the infidels of Edinburgh.”

Another edict in Punjab last month, banned the entry of males in schools and colleges run exclusively for females and checks the playing of popular Indian film tunes at fairs arranged in school premises.

Opposition to the veil has come from the Human Rights Society of Pakistan whose Secretary General, prominent lady lawyer, Naheeda Mahboob Elahi told IPS “I am surprised that our government is behaving like the Taliban.”

Elahi thought the order ran against constitutional provisions and opined that orders of this nature needed the concurrence of the federal government. “It seems that in the eyes of the provincial government, women are not equal citizens. Are we heading towards the Stone Age?”

The author of two books on women’s rights in Islamic society, Anees Ahmed placed it nearer than that. “Islamic culture means life as lived in the 15th century. Different sects and schools of thought in Islam are hundred per cent agreed on this issue.”

Ahmed who is also director-general of the Dahwa Academy, International Islamic University, Islamabad, defended the order as one meant “only to instruct female teachers and students to abide by the principles of ‘Hijab’. As far as I understand, Hijab (veil) does not mean that you cover your face but it is only to cover the body carefully except face and hands.”

Women’s rights groups, however, see the issue as one concerning gender rather than religion. In a statement the Joint Action Committee for Women’s Rights said the ban went against the spirit of a nation celebrating the 50th anniversary of its creation on the basis of liberty, justice and equality for all.

Pakistan, the statement said, was bound by international human rights commitments. Moreover, the present government was not elected to power on a “theocratic platform”, it said. The Committee also invoked the Koran to say that “there is no compulsion in religion.”

But former Member of Parliament and functionary of the Tehreek-e-Islami (Islamic Movement) Aamera Ehsan thinks that the Joint Action Committee has no authority to explain the Koran and they are “ill-informed” on educational matters.

According to her, the veil is a symbol of a woman’s faith (eeman) in Islam. Moreover, the veil, she said, would help check rising crime against women which is result of exposure of women in society. Ehsan was confident that, should the issue be put to a referendum, the majority of women in the country would favour the veil because “it symbolised a woman’s ‘eeman’.”

Besides, according to her the veil would help check rising crime against women which, she said, resulted from “the exposure of women in society.”

The Joint Action Committee is not buying. There has been no consensus for over 14 centuries of debate among scholars of Islam on concepts such as Islamic culture, vulgarity, obscenity and immorality and they remain subjective value judgements, it said.

In fact, the Committee wanted to know whose definition of Islam is being sought to be imposed. “Ambiguity has always been used by the orthodoxy to curb women’s rights rather than enhance them.”

Ahmed, however, denied that there was any ambiguity. Condemning the Committee’s attitude he said, “mini skirts are not our culture.”

Pakistan’s Constitution while emphasising that it is a religious rather than a secular state makes it clear that “all citizens are equal before law and are entitled to equal protection of law.” During a period of Martial Law imposed by the late president Zia-ul-Haq orders were issued that women appearing on Pakistan television must veiled, prompting one popular compere to quit.

The present federal government has preferred to sit this one out. Asked for her comments on the Punjab notification, Federal Minister for Women Development and Social Welfare, Begum Tahmeena Daultana said “I think we should discuss this issue some other time.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags