Friday, November 20, 2026
Analysis Gustavo Gonzalez
- After the retirement from the army of former dictator and now Senator-for-life Augusto Pinochet, a new era in civic-military relations has opened in Chile, one which does not point to fundamental political changes in the short to medium-term.
Pinochet’s stormy investiture as Senator Wednesday amidst protests both within and outside of Congress overshadowed the fourth anniversary of the start of the six-year government of President Eduardo Frei.
“It is the past that divides us, not the future,” the president said at a ceremony which marked the anniversary, while reiterating his opposition to the campaign against Pinochet staged by leaders of the centre-left governing Coalition for Democracy.
Interior Minister Carlos Figueroa also criticised the split among Chileans over the former dictator’s continued political role, insisting that it was not of far-reaching significance for the country.
Figueroa stressed that when Pinochet handed over the army command to General Ricardo Izurieta Tuesday, the last step in the transition process outlined by the 1980 constitution was completed.
The country is thus setting out on a new phase, but with the constitution inherited from the 1973-90 dictatorship. Although a 1989 referendum made slight changes to the constitution, and Congress approved additional amendments during the governments of Patricio Aylwin (1990-94) and Frei, the main pillars of the institutional order imposed by the de facto regime remain firmly in place.
The clearest demonstration of that took place Wednesday, when the former dictator was sworn in as Senator-for-life along with nine other designated (non-elected) senators, four of whom represent the armed forces and the Carabineros militarised police.
The installation of the new Senate put an end to eight years of frustrated attempts by the governing coalition to reach political accords with the right in order to make the legislature completely democratic.
The existence of designated Senators and Senators-for-life, the arbitral powers of a controversial Constitutional Court, and the president’s inability to remove military chiefs of staff remain part of Chile’s institutional order.
The current system of legislative elections, in which only two lawmakers are elected in each voting district, guarantees the political right sufficient strength to block constitutional amendments in Congress.
In the current Senate, the ruling coalition holds 20 of the 38 directly elected seats, and the right holds the remaining 18.
Of the nine designated Senators, only three are openly identified with the government, while six are in favour, to varying degree, of maintaining the current system, as is – obviously – Pinochet.
And although the governing coalition holds 69 of 120 seats in the Chamber of Deputies, bills passed in the lower house can be overturned by the majority commanded by the right-wing forces in the Senate.
A pamphlet handed out this week by a radical left-wing group maintains that “Chile’s system is a democracy under military tutelage, a prisoner of the military.” Under photos of Frei and Pinochet, the leaflet reads “who’s in command?”
Frei and the more moderate sectors of his Christian Democratic Party depict Pinochet’s retirement from the army as a major advance in the transition process, because the former dictator will not wield the same power in the Senate as he did as army chief of staff.
Government officials hope the army will return to its purely professional role under the leadership of Izurieta, a 54-year-old Lieutenant General who has not been directly implicated in the human rights violations committed during the dictatorship.
The new army chief will remain in the post for only four years – compared to Pinochet’s 25 years – and he will not become a five star general, a rank reserved up to now for the former dictator.
But regardless of Izurieta’s record, he is expected to embark on only a discreet military transition, at the head of a body of officers formed in the long Pinochet era, who justify the 1973 coup that overthrew democratically elected socialist president Salvador Allende as a patriotic act.
It is thus inconceivable that Izurieta could make a gesture like the mea culpa issued by the commander in chief of the Argentine army, General Martin Balza, who asked forgiveness in 1996 for the human rights abuses committed by the army during Argentina’s 1976-83 dictatorship.
The conflictive start of the new phase of Chilean politics includes the planned filing of charges next Monday – based on two acts of army insubordination during the Aylwin administration – against Pinochet by ruling party Deputies in the lower house of Congress.
Frei and Figueroa failed in their attempts to push their Christian Democratic Party – the leading party in the ruling coalition – to block the accusation, which is condemned to failure in the Senate.
On Wednesday, meanwhile, Andres Zaldivar, a moderate veteran Christian Democratic Senator, was elected speaker of the Senate with 28 out of 48 votes, made possible by the support of right- wing and designated Senators. But although the election could be a good signal for future political accords, such agreements will almost certainly not undertake major changes to the current political system.