Asia-Pacific, Headlines

NEPAL-TOURISM: Preserving Culture On Empty Stomachs

Gehendra Gurung

LO MANTHANG, Nepal, Apr 23 1998 (IPS) - As tourists flock to Mustang, an exotic finger of Nepal jutting into the Tibetan plateau, the local people are discovering the difficulties of reconciling tourism with preserving its delicate culture and ecology.

Here, at 3,500 metres above sea level, ringed by cold arid mountains, the walled city that was the capital of ancient Kingdom of Mustang is home to a culture and tradition more ancient than that of Tibet.

For, Mustang is the one of the last outposts of the animistic Bon Po religion which existed in Tibet before Indian monks brought Buddhism to the plateau in the fourth century A.D.

This unique heritage preserved by the remoteness of Mustang is now turning it the hottest new tourist attraction in Nepal, which has already suffered environmental damage from mass tourism.

Little wonder then that the government in Kathmandu has strictly limited tourist access to the area and charges a premium for tourists visiting the yet, roadless plateau.

Since 1992, the trickle of tourists trekking or riding to Mustang has grown steadily, bringing income and exposure to the local people. Most trekkers have to walk from Jomson to Lo Manthang, a journey that takes about five days.

The walk in the thin air of the Himalayas is strains and by mid-afternoon hurricane force winds blow up the Kali Gandki valley every day making the air thick with dust and even pebbles.

But the view of the Tibetan plateau and the summits of the Himalayan peaks to the south are stunning in their stark beauty and make the trip worthwhile.

For this unparalleled view, tourists pay USD 70 a day extra for the special permit which allows them to visit Mustang. Not more than a thousand tourists are allowed the permits each year.

The tourism ministry in Kathmandu says the restrictions are meant to protect the delicate local culture and ecology and says it plans to give back 60 per cent of the revenue to the development and conservation of the Mustand district.

But there are critics. “It sounds very good in theory,” says one Nepali travel agent who takes conservation-minded tourists to Mustang.

“When this policy was made in 1992, the local people of Mustang had great hopes for the development of their remote and neglected region,” he said.

Six years later, it is evident that not everything has been up to expectations. The local people of Mustang say the money goes to Kathmandu rather than into schools, hospitals or the badly needed bridges.

“We make a little money working as porters for the tourists and renting our our mules – but other than that I don’t think the Mustangis have benefited,” says Chewang Bista of the Charang village near Lo Manthang as he harnesses up his mule with trekking gear.

In fact, Mustangis like Bista says Kathmandu should open up the area to unlimited tourism and say fears of cultural or ecological ruin are exaggerated.

But officials at the Annapurna Area Conservation Project (ACAP) which administers tourism revenue in Mustang say the dollars are going into the restoration of ancient pre-Buddhist sites and monasteries.

According to them there are just too many religious sites to restore and so many of Mustang’s priceless wall paintings to protect that it is hard to enough determining where to begin.

“It will need much more than just tourism revenue to restore the monasteries and the paintings,” explained on ACAP conservationist. He conceded, on condition of anonymity, that the government in Kathmandu was not repatriating 60 per cent of the tourism income from permit fees to Mustang as planned.

Even more vulnerable than the crumbling monasteries are the priceless religious objects inside. There has never been much security in these parts but the rate at which artifacts are being stolen have increased after the opening up of Mustang to tourism.

Ghiling monastery in Mustan lost most its Buddhist and Bon Po idols for its altars in 1993. Although local monks do not put a price tag on these items,they could fetch hundreds of thousands of dollars in the international art bazaar.

A year later, Luri monastery lost several invaluable traditional Tibetan ‘thangka’ paintings that were at least 500

years old.

“Our culture survived for thousands of years because of honesty and faith. Tourism brings new influences, and it is impossible to lock up the religious objects in a safe because they are used in daily worship,” said a monk at Luri.

There is increasing realisation in ACAP that unless the local community takes an interest, tourism and culture are not going to survive each other. Said one ACAP official: “It is extremely difficult to preserve culture on an empty stomach,”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags