Asia-Pacific, Headlines, Human Rights | Analysis

RIGHTS: Would a Global Criminal Court Have Mattered for Cambodia?

Analysis - Satya Sivaraman

BANGKOK, Jun 5 1998 (IPS) - When the world’s media reported the death in April of the much-reviled Khmer Rouge leader Pol Pot, there was no shortage of hand-wringing around the globe.

Western governments fumed at the death of a villain unpunished. Cambodia scholars lamented that with the failure to arrest and try Pol Pot, the world had lost an opportunity to give his victims “a sense of closure”.

But given the history of big-power meddling in Cambodia, as well as domestic political realities, few Cambodians believe that an international tribunal could have made much of a difference in bringing Pol Pot to justice — even if he had been caught alive.

This may well be significant in the light of negotiations at the United Nations, which will start June 15 in Rome, to create an International Criminal Court (ICC) with jurisdiction over crimes like Khmer Rouge-style genocide.

While the court cannot deal with past offenses, the case of Cambodia — and the murky mix of geopolitical concerns there by regional and western countries over the decades — show what kind of political complications the ICC could run into.

During his reign from 1975 to 1979, Pol Pot as the head of the Khmer Rouge government is held responsible for the death of 2 million Cambodians through executions, torture, persecution and famine.

In recent years, western governments, led by the United States, have been talking about setting up an international tribunal to prosecute Pol Pot.

Even then, many Cambodians felt that no court could have successfully organised Pol Pot’s apprehension in the guerrilla- infested jungles of north-west Cambodia, taken him alive to another country, marshalled sufficient evidence and tried him for the alleged crime of genocide committed two decades ago.

Worse, many Cambodians believe that there was no will at all on the part of either the international community or the Phnom Penh government to seriously try Pol Pot and reveal the political skeletons in the cupboards of the accusers themselves.

“Countries like China and Thailand must be relieved at Pol Pot’s death because he cannot disclose now how much they helped his movement,” said Youk Chhang, director of the Documentation Center of Cambodia, a Phnom Penh-based NGO.

While Pol Pot and other Khmer Rouge leaders should take the blame for most of these deaths of Cambodian victims, some historians argue that the issue is not so simple. There are several other countries which also played a part.

For example, the U.S. bombing of the Cambodian countryside during the Vietnam war in the early seventies — killing several hundred thousand innocent people and what was genocide as well — — was what set the stage for the Khmer Rouge’s rise to power.

“Pol Pot killed in the name of agrarian revolution while the U.S. and other governments involved in the Vietnam war killed in the name of capitalism,” said Pairote Pholphet, a Bangkok-based civil rights activist.

While in power, Pol Pot was ardently backed with material and political support by the Chinese government.

And after being overthrown by a Vietnam-backed rebellion, the Khmer Rouge leader often found shelter for more than two decades in neighbouring Thailand, where businessmen and politicians made millions of dollars trading gems and timber with the guerrillas.

Last year, when the Cambodian government formally asked the United Nations to set up a tribunal to try Pol Pot, China expressed doubts about “internationalising” the issue and said the Khmer Rouge’s excess were an “internal affair” of Cambodia.

In May, after Pol Pot’s death, the U.S. asked the UN Security Council to set up an international tribunal “on the lines of those set up in Bosnia and Rwanda to try the remaining members of the Khmer Rouge leadership”.

But apart from geo-political obstacles, there are also enough domestic political compulsions in the way of any international tribunal for trying Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge leadership.

Though Cambodian People’s Party (CPP) leader and the country’s co-premier Hun Sen did send a letter to the UN backing the international tribunal, there remain serious doubts about how much he would cooperate with such a body.

The CPP, made up of former Khmer Rouge cadres like Hun Sen himself, overthrew Pol Pot with the backing of the Vietnamese army in 1979 in recent years. But they too have joined hands with defecting Khmer Rouge leaders.

Last year, Pol Pot’s brother-in-law Ieng Sary was granted amnesty in return for bringing defecting guerrilla troops over to the government side.

CPP leaders — though vowing to capture and prosecute the hardcore faction of the Khmer Rouge which continues to oppose the government — said they had to accept the defectors in the interest of peace in Cambodia.

There remain fears that once a tribunal is set up, questions may be asked about the role of Hun Sen and other CPP leaders themselves in perpetrating Cambodia’s ‘killing fields’.

The international NGO Human Rights Watch has already demanded that any tribunal set up to try Khmer Rouge leaders should include the leading cadre of the group’s central security apparatus, such as those who ran the notorious Tuol Sleng torture center, as well as military officers who ordered massacres.

Diplomats in the region feel that the complexity of carrying out any prosecution of Khmer Rouge leaders is a good indication of what is in store for attempts to set up an ICC to try those responsible for genocide and other crimes against humanity.

“Cambodia illustrates that those governments which have the military might to implement justice are ironically among those who share the guilt,” says an Asian diplomat in Phnom Penh. “It will be very difficult for them to allow the ICC to be an effective and truly credible organisation.”

Predictably enough, four permanent members of the Security Council — China, France, Russia and the U.S. — have voiced strong reservations on aspects of a future ICC. This has raised fears that the result could be a very weak court, with no authority of its own and paralysed by political pressures.

This is why the results of forthcoming negotiations on key issues, including the relationship of the ICC to national jurisdictions, will be crucial. Other issues include who should trigger a court hearing — member states, the Security Council or the court prosecutor — and types of crimes the ICC will cover.

Some analysts say that if Cambodia is any indication of how difficult it is to arrive at a consensus on these issues, those debating the ICC’s formation might as well ponder if it may not be more productive to encourage individual societies to sort out methods of obtaining justice against such crimes.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags