Sunday, November 22, 2026
Analysis - Nasim Zehra
- Political observers in Pakistan have closely followed Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif’s visit this week to the United States where his government says he has won important concessions from U.S President Bill Clinton.
PTV, the state-owned TV network, has been replaying footage of Sharif with Clinton at their Dec. 2 meeting in Washington, and the prime minister fielding questions at a packed news conference on Thursday.
Pleased foreign ministry officials here say Pakistan-U.S relations are stronger than ever, but that may be for public consumption as the prime minister had left Islamabad promising to resolve several persisting problems with Washington during his three-day visit.
With the economic downturn biting deep, the prime minister who is a great believer in doing official business in a personalised style, had hoped candid talks with Clinton would persuade him to lift all embargoes slapped on Pakistan since 1990.
Clinton agreed on Wednesday to waive some of these and renewed a pledge to settle a dispute over Islamabad’s 658-million dollar purchase of 28 F-16 fighter planes, delivery of which was blocked in 1990 by U.S sanctions. The latest sanctions were imposed by Washington in May, on both India and Pakistan after the rivals’ tit-for-tat nuclear tests.
Sharif had hoped also to capitalise on what Islamabad believes has been a “substantial policy shift” in Washington on the Kashmir issue – a 50-year-long dispute over the northern Indian state which Pakistan claims. Washington, the government felt, was convinced that Kashmir’s future had to be decided by international mediation.
But belying hopes of a breakthrough, Clinton reiterated to the Pakistani premier that Washington would enter as a mediator only if “both parties wish the United States to be involved”. India has time and again stated it is against third-party intervention and has defended itself against charges of human rights abuses in Kashmir where security forces have clamped down on a separatist movement.
Ever since the rivalry between the two neighbours turned into an open nuclear race, Pakistan’s government has sought to turn the international uproar in its favour on Kashmir. Many believe the dispute could be the flashpoint for another war in the nuclearised region.
India and Pakistan have fought two wars over Kashmir in the last 50 years, the last in 1971, and regularly trade charges at international fora. A defensive India has also taken exception to comments by other countries, most recently by South Africa.
At the summit of non-aligned nations in South Africa last August, Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee registered a formal protest after President Nelson Mandela’s referred to Kashmir as a dispute that must be solved in his opening address to the meeting.
The Pakistan government was quick to seize the opportunity presented by what they believe was international censure. After the Palestinian-Israeli Wye River Accord was signed in late October, President Clinton received a letter from the Pakistani prime minister urging him to play a similar role on the Kashmir dispute.
Sharif told Clinton he was destined to play a historic role in resolving the Kashmir issue and that he was morally obliged to play an active role, but that was not enough to persuade Clinton.
Washington had its own concerns. Primarily Clinton wanted Sharif to fix a deadline for signing the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT). Both India and Pakistan have indicated willingness to sign, but haven’t gone beyond.
Since the Pakistani premier is the sole player in Pakistan’s political arena, having constitutionally neutralised the presidency, the military establishment and the judiciary – which engineered the exit of three governments between 1990 and 1996 – in well-publicised confrontations in the last two years, Sharif could push through his own agenda.
Some political commentators had thought that Sharif would redefine the country’s relationship with the United States and push for “partnership”.
“Instead of sounding like a Washington protege offering cooperation to Washington’s agenda of human rights of narcotics control, of anti terrorism etc Nawaz Sharif in Washington should offer partnership to Clinton in defining and promoting the agenda of human progress and global security,” a columnist said privately.
Sharif heads Pakistan’s strongest government. Politically he faces no threat from a deeply divided opposition, which has failed to capitalise on the economic mess he has landed the country in and his swing to the right which has appalled liberal opinion.
Sharif has failed to deliver on election promises and act on widening the tax net and calling in defaulters who owe banks billion in loans. Instead his government has introduced a controversial new legal system based on religion and clamped Governor’s rule in the southern province of Sindh where he introduced military courts last month to tackle “terrorism”.
The two-year-old government has few results to show.