Development & Aid, Europe, Headlines | Analysis

CONFLICT-EUROPE: German Involvement in Yogoslavia Criticised

Analysis - Yojana Sharma

Berlin, Mar 28 1999 (IPS) - German Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder triumphantly told a summit meeting of the European Union Friday that “Europe speaks with one voice on the Kosovo conflict”.

But the disunity, however mild, that greeted him within his own ruling coalition during a Bundestag debate on Kosovo the same day, is symbolic of the apprehension in Germany over its first direct involvement in a military offensive since World War II.

At least four German tornado Jets were involved in the NATO air strikes on Yugoslavia this week although Bonn has ruled out German participation in any campaign on the ground.

But even this limited participation would have been unheard of in Germany just a few years ago.

Military involvement has long been a taboo subject in Germany – which declined to take part in the Gulf war – a reluctance understood and respected by its NATO allies.

German Tornados flew reconnaissance missions over Bosnia in 1995, using electronic jamming equipment to protect other NATO aircraft. Some 3,000 German troops are stationed in Macedonia, just a few kilometres from the border with Kosovo and another 2,500 German troops are still in Bosnia.

“Hysterical” pacifism, as one Germany newspaper described it, was the order of the day in the 1980s, when Germans bitterly opposed the deployment of NATO missile deployments on German soil.

On Friday, the Bundestag backed further German participation in NATO air strikes against Yugoslavia over the bitter opposition of the former East German Communist Party – renamed the Party of Democratic Socialism (PDS) – and sections of the Green Party which has its roots in the pacifist movements of the 1960s.

Even members of the conservative Christian Democrats and Bavarian Christian Socialists, putting aside animosities with the ruling Social Democrats (SPD) in an acrimonious fight over dual nationality for immigrant workers, praised the government and backed defence minister Rudolf Scharping.

Green parliamentarian Christian Stroebele refused to join other members of the Greens who backed Schroeder – including foreign minister Joschka Fischer.

Stroebele called for an immediate halt to the bombardments and for negotiations with the Serbs to begin. In an emotional speech he said that because the West did too little to encourage peace efforts, it helped to contribute the escalation of the crisis in Yugoslovia over the future of Kosovo.

It was not an unusual statement but wahat was unusual that only six other Greens supported him. Fischer, even as foreign minister, had for weeks spoken of the sensitivities of deploying German forces in the Balkans where incidences of harsh treatment of the Serbs during the Nazi campaign in Yugoslavia are legion.

Seven years ago Fischer, then an opposition Green MP, opposed deployment of German forces in Bosnia. German forces finally joined peace-keeping troops in Bosnia at the end of the war, the first to do so since World War II.

Angelika Beer, Green Party spokeswoman on defence issues made it clear that the party was disconcerted, mentioning that many Green members, and strong pacifists felt “a certain helplessness” in backing military strikes.

“Those who would now accuse us of war-mongering must also ask themselves what are the alternatives,” Beer said, not without emotion.

Another Green politician said Germany was not only ruled by the first post-war generation, but had also entered a post-pacifist face.

“After what has happened this century, Germany above all has no right to drop bombs on Belgrade,” thundered Gregor Gysi, head of the PDS parliamentary faction. The PDS and other commentators pointed out that with no “exit strategy” in sight, Germany with its other NATO allies could be dragged indefinately into combat.

Earlier members of Germany’s pacifist movement, Andreas Buro of the Committee for Fundamental Rights and Manfred Stenner of the Network of Peace Co-operatives said in an open letter to Schroder “anyone wanting peace must prepare for peace.”

They estimated that even the initial combing of Serbia would cost Germany the equivalent of some 500 million dollars, and any extended campaign by NATO would cost in the billions more than a “Marschall Plan for the Balkans would cost.”

But the deep ideological splits which would normally have accompanied such a debate were tempered by the unusual coincidence of Germany being in the six-month revolving EU presidency seat, and intent on brokering compromise among member states rather than pushing its own national interests when the NATO decision to bomb Kosovo was made.

“Germany had a leading role in presenting an image of a unified Europe with regard to action action against Kosovo,” said one Bonn official. “If the EU leaders had not all been in Berlin it would have seemed as if Europe and Germany was being pushed around by the US, then the pacifists would have protested much more strongly.”

“In the past, German militarism was equated with patriotism and expansionism, now it is equated with unity with Europe.”

But there are still deep rooted misgivings. Although Germany’s leaders are the first post-war generation to take the helm, they are aware of great Serbian antipathy towards Gerrnans as a result of former Nazi expansionist policies in the Balkans.

Some German politicians fear direct reprisals against German troops in neighbouring countries.

Former Christian Democrat defence minister Volker Ruhe argued last week that German troops in Macedonia should be withdrawn as they had been sent as part of a peacekeeping force and not in order to make war.

German people deeply fear insecurity in their own country as a result of involvement in overseas conflicts. War in Kosovo could mean thousands of refugees at Germany’s door and, since the capture of Kurdish leader Abdullah Ocalan and Kurdish unrest around Europe, Germans fear the conflict could spill over on German soil.

According to the Federal Statistics office some 1.3 million citizens of the former Yugoslavia live in Germany, some 720,000 of them from Serbia, Kosovo and Montenegro. The FOPC estimates the number of Kosovo Albanians in Germany at 100,000.

Albanians in Germany and Switzerland are reportedly the main source of funds for arms purchases for Kosovo Albanaians.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags