Headlines

ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT – BOOKS: The Ancestral Home

Patricia Gosling

AMSTERDAM, Jun 15 1999 (IPS) - Memory, that most fragile and elastic of the mind’s capacities, can be likened to an old house, the rooms of which, opening one upon the other, can be selectively entered or sealed off.

In his book ‘My Father’s House’, Matthew Carr recounts his exploration into the elusive nature of memory and character. Part memoir, part biography, part cultural travelogue, Carr’s book is a journey of discovery into the life of the enigmatic man whose violent character overshadowed his childhood.

While there seems to be no end to the current appetite for memoirs and no shortage of writers willing to supply them, Carr’s book covers unusual ground in that it is set in the turbulent days of post-colonial Guyana, a former British colony about which little is known to the outside world, where Carr phre spent the last twenty-five years of his life.

William Ian Carr, feeling that England has nothing left to offer him, takes his family to live in the British West Indies. A left- wing intellectual, he joins the teaching staff at the Mona campus of the University of the West Indies in Jamaica and proceeds to become a popular figure in education and liberal discourse.

It is in Jamaica, however, that Bill Carr begins the long descent into the alcoholism that fueled his rage and eventually destroyed him and his family.

While Matthew has some fond memories of his seven years in Jamaica–boyhood games played in the garden, excursions to the beach–he recalls that “the way I remembered my childhood in the Caribbean had always oscillated between two extremes, between my mother’s misery and my father’s explosive rages, between the fantasy landscape that we lived in outside the house and the claustrophobic, pressure-cooker atmosphere inside it. . .”

When the Carr family move to Guyana so Bill can take up a teaching post at the newly established university, the family dynamics spiral freakishly out of control. Once the family is settled in Georgetown, Bill’s violent and abusive behavior reaches a fever pitch.

After a two week drunken tirade, nine months into their stay in Guyana, Bill ejects his family from his life. Handing his wife a hundred pounds, he tells her to return to England with the children.

That was the last that Matthew Carr was to see of his father for twenty years. Although they kept up a sporadic correspondence, in which no mention is made of his father’s abuse and reason for rejecting his family, Matthew ceased, over time, to think of the man as his father.

It isn’t until four years after his father died under somewhat vague circumstances (was it cirrhosis of the liver, cancer, or a broken heart?), that Matthew decides to return to Guyana to fill in the missing pieces and to heal the wounds he carries from his lost childhood.

For Matthew the trip to Guyana is a bewildering journey into the life of a man who bears no resemblance to the father he knew. He meets former students and university colleagues who relate tales of the wonderful lectures his father gave, keeping students on the edge of their seats as he acted out Shakespeare’s plays, making language and characters come alive.

Political cronies are equally enthusiastic, remembering the risks Bill Carr took as a vocal and active member of Cheddi Jagan’s opposition party.

As a white man so vocally sympathetic to the black cause Bill elicited something akin to awe from his admirers, all the while managing to stay on in a country eager to evict whites and other vestiges of colonial rule.

Bill, however, managed to hold his ground, hanging out in rum shops, writing a column for the local opposition newspaper, working for the opposition party. He even married again, an Afro- Guyanese woman with two daughters of her own, both of whom remember their step-father with fondness.

As Matthew delves deeper into his father’s character and past, he develops the theory that his father rejected his first wife and children because they were white, that he felt the need to atone for the wrongs perpetrated by the British empire.

“The idea that my father might have offered up his family as a symbolic act of atonement for the crimes of the white race…..did not seem all far-fetched to me.” Matthew uses this theory to explain many of his father’s actions toward his first family and his milder treatment of his second (black) family, but in the end these explanations fall somewhat flat.

Because, ultimately, how much can one person truly know another, and to what extent is it possible to view with a dispassionate eye the behavior and motivations of the parent who rejected us. How much of Bill Carr’s personal behavior can really be attributed to his political views, to his rejection of whiteness?

At the end of Matthew’s stay in Guyana, these are the questions that linger. “Even if I had spoken to everyone who had ever known him throughout his life, the blank spaces would still remain, and it is doubtful whether my father would have been able to fill them himself.”

His physical search over, but with the psychological journey just begun, Matthew finds some comfort in imagining his father as a type of tragic character, Shakespearean in scope and forever unfathomable, a man who was both many things to different people and a mystery to his own son.

And while memory may be one way of understanding our lives and the people we knew, it is at best a poor tool for filling in the complex mystery of an individual life.

 
Republish | | Print |