Europe, Headlines

DISASTER-TURKEY: Wrath of Nature or State Crime?

Nadire Mater

ISTANBUL, Aug 18 1999 (IPS) - As the death toll of Tuesday’s earthquake grows by the minute, Turkish specialists angrily assailed the local and central governments for allowing greedy building companies to ignore virtually all technical construction standards.

“The local governments as well as the central government , bypassing the existing legislation, allow settlements on river beds and (geological) fault zones. The construction companies produce low-quality buildings, free of any control,” charged Yusuf Tek, secretary general of Turkey’s Architects and Engineers Union.

“The engineers guilds and specialised bodies are barred from the process. The cities grow like mushrooms, without any planning,” he told IPS. “And, as always, the losers are the poor.”

“Local and central authorities, by neglecting scientific advice, have led to these results. After the earthquake in Adana (southern Turkey) last year, we had warned the government that an even more destructive shock in the northwest was predictable,” professor Atilla Ansal, a civil engineering specialist from Istanbul said.

Afife Batur, chair of the Turkish Architects Chamber believes that the earthquake is a belated quality test for the sector. “This test should have started at the planning level,” she said.

“Yet, the local governments are the least willing to cooperate with the specialists and ignore the existing legislation, which indeed provides very high construction standards,” she stressed.

“MURDERERS” was Hurriyet’s – the country’s major mainstream daily – huge headline Wednesday. The paper directly accused the the construction sector of theft and corrupt officials of turning a blind eye to criminal actions in the housing business.

Hurriyet also ironically pointed at a recent government initiative to grant an amnesty to construction firms’ owners sentenced for their responsibilities in the death of hundreds of people in last year’s earthquake in Adana.

“The number of physically damaged buildings in the Izmit province are around 1,000,” says Izmit’s governor Memduh Oguz. “Actually the number of rescue teams required should have been equal to the number of the demolished buildings, yet we have only 50 teams at hand.”

The generally slow and inefficient rescue efforts led to angry reactions at all levels. At a parliamentary emergency session Wednesday, a ruling-coalition deputy, Turan Imamoglu, said that the government was “simply folding its arms and watching as people die under the rubble.”

There is “no visible rescue efforts and no organised aid,” says Mehmet Yildiz, from Istanbul’s Avcilar district, who anxiously expects his wife and three children to be still alive beneath their home’s wreckage.

“I wonder why one of two adjacent buildings falls down as the other one remains intact,” asks Yildiz. “The construction firms steal iron, cement and other material. They sell these cheap houses to low- income families like ours. We die, they fill their pockets and bribe the government. It’s so simple,” he says.

According to a recent report by the Architects Chamber in the last 40 years, 90 percent of the buildings in Istanbul have been built with substandard material.

The earthquake is the heaviest experienced in Turkey in three decades. More than 3,000 deaths had been accounted for by Wednesday evening, but the authorities believe the toll will grow to 6,000, while thousands more are estimated to be alive under the rubble.

Conflicting reports put the earthquake intensity between 6,8 and 7.4 points in the Richter scale. The epicentre was in the country’s industrial region of northwest Izmit, a province 100 kilometres east of Istanbul, where a major refinery has caught fire.

The fire at the Tüpras oil refinery has spread over a gas and oil tank-field and is also threatening two neighbouring oil refineries as well as other major industries in the area.

Some 200,000 residents in the adjacent areas have been forced to leave their homes. Several villages of the Yalova province on the southern side of Izmit Bay are being evacuated due to a dangerous gas-pipeline crossing the area.

“Our city is under a most serious threat. Our domestic facilities have proved incapable of putting the fire out. We need international aid, or the whole town will explode,” Izmit’s mayor Sefa Sirmen told journalists.

Specialists here relate the high number of casualties to the poorly organised rescue efforts. Rescue teams had reached just a small part of the demolished settlements and most survivors there are expected to die within hours.

The situation has worsened as access to the area through two major highways on both sides of the Izmit Bay – where nearly one fifth of Turkey’s 62 million population live- has been blocked by panicked local residents or their relatives.

Prime minister Bulent Ecevit has blamed the collapse of the region’s telecommunications facilities for the slow official reaction and poor coordination.

The earthquake hit the Turkish military as well. In Golcuk, a huge naval base near Izmit, at least 250 soldiers and officers are estimated to have remained under the demolished dormitory blocks, while 16 of the first 80 soldiers rescued have died in the Istanbul’s hospitals they have been transferred to.

The Turkish authorities were forced to appeal for international aid through the United Nations. The United States, Israel, Greece, Germany, Switzerland, Russia, Japan, France, Georgia, Syria, Egypt and Great Britain quickly reacted by sending emergency aid and rescue teams.

The most desperately needed are the Swiss, Japanese and Russian teams, with experience in earthquake-related operations. The Russian teams are already operating in the Izmit province but have reportedly been dispatched to the naval base, where they will set up a field hospital.

The Japanese government has offered to fund long-term projects to assist the Turkish government in establishing earthquake-proof construction standards and providing operational know-how.

“The spontaneous and unprincipled work of Turkey’s socioeconomic fabric has resulted in establishing 45 percent of the country’s industry in a single area, sitting on a first-degree earthquake zone, where 36 percent of the country’s gross national product is generated,” says economics analyst Celal Pir of Istanbul.

Izmit , the epicentre of the earthquake is distinguished for its relatively high income level of 7,000 US dollars per capita, 2,5 times higher than the national average.

“The region also has Turkey’s best educated, specialised and experienced work force. Alongside human losses, the earthquake strikes a major blow on the Turkish economy,” Pir said.

Improvement in construction techniques and standards alone might not provide the remedy for Turkey’s chronic deficiencies in settlement policies, specialists believe.

“Whatever techniques you apply, concentrating the country’s industry in the heart of the most dangerous earthquake zone is a great risk, apart from the hazardous effects in its immediate environment and the impact on regional inequalities,” says Akin Atauz, a regional planning analyst from Ankara.

“The earthquake has revealed all deficiencies of the present system, exposing that the major responsibility goes not to nature but to the rulers of the country,” he says.

However, prime minister Ecevit, is not as pessimistic: “the Turkish nation is a big nation and we will overcome this disaster as we have done during all past difficulties,” he told Parliament Wednesday.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags