Friday, November 20, 2026
Ihsan Bouabid
- The “dumbing down” of news coverage in the United Statesthat is short pithy comments rather than any deep analysisextends even to the media’s handling of the arts, according to Columbia University’s respected School of Journalism.
A comprehensive study on how the media covers the performing, visual and literary arts in this country reveals a narrowing of cultural boundaries with mass entertainment.
Most Americans receive cultural and arts news through reading metropolitan, regional and national newspapers, with additional coverage through alternative weeklies, news magazines, wire services, and radio and TV programs.
Columbia’s survey, “Reporting the Arts: News Coverage of Arts and Culture in America,” analyzes 15 dailies in ten cities across the country – Charlotte, Chicago, Cleveland, Denver, Houston, Miami, Philadelphia, Portland, Providence and the San Francisco Bay Area – the three national papers – the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal and USA Today – as well as Associated Press and the ABC, NBC and CBS TV networks.
The 127-page document reveals that many journalists writing as arts critics feel that their roles as interpreters, evaluators and public educators has been marginalized.
Today, critical reporting has become simply “thumbs up, thumbs down” and other sound-bite ways of trivializing the essence of criticism, the study noted.
From the perspective of the editors of the sections in which arts coverage appears, however, there is support for a robust commitment to arts coverage in the context of features – entertainment, recreational and leisure packages. Hence, the success of these sections with readers and advertisers has much to do with their populist and mass-entertainment tilt, according to the study.
The report, which is based on research and interviews made in October last year, finds that the truth involved a mixture of both views.
It shows that major expanded weekend supplements showcase arts and entertainment, and that features and reviews are more common than arts news. Meanwhile, the daily section frequently contains little more than television listings for that day.
The arts beat is bigger and more heterogeneous than expected by the authors of the report and there is clear evidence that newspapers like to mix high art with mass culture and lifestyle coverage – such as fashion and design.
On the other hand, listings constitute close to 50 percent of arts and entertainment coverage, while staffing and resources on newspapers has not been increased in the 1990s to match the explosion of arts activity.
Another finding is that newspapers adopt disparate policies for supplementing their staffer’s work with local freelancers and national syndicates.
Big city newspapers cover the arts in more detail and in greater diversity than those in smaller cities. Nevertheless, the study does not include a specific section related to the New York Times and the Los Angeles Times because, for those newspapers, “arguably, New York and Los Angeles constitute their arts and entertainment universe.”
The report also revealed that the visual arts, architecture, dance and radio get only cursory coverage. The visual arts are rarely covered by a full-time staffer while news about television, movies, music and books receives heavy coverage.
Also, each local newspaper has its own strengths and weaknesses, depending on the city’s interest and history. For example, the Cleveland Plain Dealer and the Philadelphia Inquirer provided the most extensive music coverage, classical music for the first and rock for the latter. Cleveland is home of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Museum.
In the newspapers surveyed, the daily Arts-and-Living section lags behind both sports and business as a priority on almost every newspaper, both in pages allotted and the number of staff writers employed.
Television networks concentrate arts and cultural news in their morning programmes rather than their nightly newscasts or their prime time “magazines.” Publishing is the most frequently covered medium on TV and interviews with the authors of latest best- sellers provide the dominant format.
NBC’s “Today” show invited a total of 22 non-fiction authors to discuss their latest publications and ABC’s Good Morning America hosted 14 during October 1998.
There are indications that public radio and local alternative weekly newspapers sometimes take the arts more seriously than metropolitan daily newspapers, states the report prepared by more than two dozen arts writers, reporters, editors and research assistants around the country.
In analyzing coverage provided by the Associated Press – the biggest of all wire services operating in the United States – the the report noted that it had a surprisingly small arts and entertainment staff. General news reporters occasionally assigned to write about an entertainment personality were “often dispatched to the courthouse instead of the concert hall,” the report said.
It added that the Associated Press tended to feature arts coverage out of just two cities – New York and Los Angeles – with the three primary areas being television, movies and celebrities.
While the news agency has 95 international bureaus in 72 countries, it failed to carry any arts or entertainment features from outside the United States, except from London, in the period studied.
Although the report found the AP’s coverage of television particularly “impressive and extensive”, it concluded that “what AP obviously lacks is depth, meaningful arts stories in the daily national news report and a consistent editorial voice – particularly in criticism.”
The report concluded that the future of arts coverage in the United States is “wide open” and the spread of opportunities for arts journalists to develop fresh dimensions for their work in the interactive news media still has to be developed.