Asia-Pacific, Headlines

CULTURE-CHINA: Angry Debates Swirl around Theatre Project

Antoaneta Bezlova

BEIJING, Aug 15 2000 (IPS) - A French architect’s futuristic design for a national theatre here has become a theatre of war between the clashing interests of traditional and modern, idealistic and pragmatic, and cosmopolitan and nationalistic.

After 40 years of setbacks and the embarrassing cancellation of a groundbreaking ceremony on Apr. 1, the project is finally scheduled to start this fall.

But this is unlikely to silence the project’s many passionate critics throughout the social spectrum. The furore is not just a battle over what the National Grand Theatre of China should look like, but whether it should even be built in the first place.

Architects deride the project, which is in the shape of huge bubble made of titanium and glass, as a “duck egg”. Others say its 360 million U.S. dollar cost is ridiculous for a country still struggling to shed poverty and backwardness.

Traditionalists argue that its avant-garde design does not suit the heart of Chinese capital, which is full of landmark sites such as the Forbidden City and Tiananmen Square.

Among the strong chorus of objections, the least heard voices are those of Beijing’s people who remember that the empty pit slotted for theatre construction was once designated to be a building to host representatives to the National People’s Congress.

Until today the members of the National People’s Congress, China’s Parliament, do not have any premises to work, meet their electorate or discuss with fellow representatives.

The Congress meets only once a year in a well-rehearsed, 10-day session which takes place at the Great Hall of the People. Despite its lofty name, the hall is just a ceremonial site and not a centre where any genuine civic activities take place.

Decisions voted at Parliament sessions are made by the Communist Party leadership behind closed doors ahead of the event, and voices of dissent are almost never heard.

“For the Communist Party leaders to have an office building for the NPC representatives, it is a waste of money,” charges one Beijing intellectual.

“They need the NPC voting, not their deliberations. They (the party) shortened even the annual session of Parliament. In the 1980s, the Parliament used to gather for half-a-month. Now it is only ten days,” he adds.

Few outside the critics of the project, designed by France’s Paul Andreu, know about the row between the National People’s Congress and the proponents of a theatre in the late 1970s.

What is often mentioned in relation to the theater’s history is the name of late Prime Minister Zhou Enlai. In 1958, Zhou ordered the site west of the Great Hall of the People to be cleared of houses, to make way for a national theatre there.

The construction never took off. Famine befell the country during the Great Leap Forward (1958-1960) in the wake of Chairman Mao Zedong’s unrealistic appeal for fast industrialisation, and all spending on arts was put on hold.

In the next 10 years of the Cultural Revolution (1966-76), young Red Guards under the guidance of the ultra-left Gang of Four set out to destroy everything of traditional cultural value. Universities and academies were closed, and all artistic creativity discouraged.

It was not until after former paramount leader Deng Xiaoping’s policy of opening China’s doors dawned in the late 1970s, that plans on building a national theatre were resumed.

Yet in the liberal atmosphere immediately after the Cultural Revolution, a working site for the NPC delegates was deemed more important than building a theatre.

The site remained an empty hole, while members of the Parliament and of the cultural ministry fought over what to do with it.

“It is indicative that in the 1990s, Chinese leaders decided in favour of building a theatre, and a grand one,” says one foreign observer. “It shows how their priorities shifted from redressing the mistakes of the past to projecting an image of a modern and cultured country.”

Paul Andreu’s theatre project is certainly an ambitious one. Famed for his airports in Paris, Jakarta and Seoul, Andreu has designed a 55-metre high transparent bubble that will house four halls and seat 6,000 people — all on an artificial lake.

“The project indeed resembles an egg by its simple outer shape. But this shape contains all the complexity of life in gestation and harbours a promise,” Andreu said in a recent commentary defending his design.

“When the European countries built their operas in the 18th and 19th centuries, none of them had resolved the problem of poverty,” he argued, addressing the issue of the project’s high cost.

“Nevertheless, these buildings became monuments that were a source of pride for everyone,” he added.

But to some Chinese architects and engineers, the project just off Tiananmen Square simply seems too expensive, wrongly conceived and not suitable for the site.

“It is out of tune with our national tradition and local character,” says the prominent Hong Kong architect, Pan Zuyao.

In June, 49 members of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and China Engineering Academy and 108 architects sent petitions to the government opposing the project.

In the petitions, scientists warned that such a translucent bubble is ill-suited for a city like Beijing, notorious for its sandstorms and dirty air. In the end, they cautioned that if built, the theatre would become an elitist facility, reserved just for the rich.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags