Asia-Pacific, Headlines, Human Rights | Analysis

POLITICS-ASEAN: Regional Bloc Fumbles on Burma Again

Analysis - Mahesh Uniyal

BANGKOK, Sep 21 2000 (IPS) - Still unable to ‘pull up’ an errant neighbour for alleged rights abuse and crushing political freedom, South-east Asian governments are finding it hard to agree on how to tackle Rangoon.

The latest standoff between Burma’s military regime and pro- democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi, has shown that the ‘constructive engagement’ policy of the Association of South-east Asian Nations (ASEAN) has failed to persuade Rangoon to change its ways, say critics.

On the contrary, the rulers of Burma have scoffed at the half- hearted bids of some ASEAN nations to apply collective diplomatic pressure on Rangoon.

Indeed, the Burmese regime has been helped in its defiance by the fact that some ASEAN members have used the ‘legitimisation’ of the regime to push lucrative business deals in that country, say the critics.

For the second time in less than a month, Suu Kyi was Thursday prevented from travelling outside Rangoon by Burmese security forces, who blockaded the road in front of her house, newsreports from Rangoon said.

The opposition leader, who was forcibly taken back to her house after a nine-day roadside confrontation with authorities late last month, had declared her intention to defy the regime and travel outside the capital for political work.

The military regime, known as the State Peace and Development Council (SPDC), has refused to hand power to Suu Kyi’s National League for Democracy (NLD), despite the latter’s landslide win in a democratic election 10 years ago.

Suu Kyi was under house arrest for six years till 1995, but her movements have been severely restricted since then. The SPDC accuses Suu Kyi of acting on the behest of foreign powers and claims it is restricting her movements to save her from those who want to harm her.

The generals ruling Burma insist that Suu Kyi’s bids to bring international pressure will only slow the country’s move toward democracy. Burmese Foreign Minister Win Aung told the U.N. General Assembly this week that his government was under “unfair scrutiny”.

“(Burma) has chosen a path that is most suitable to the country, its people and its historical peculiarities,” he was quoted as saying.

News reports from the United Nations also spoke of Win Aung’s rejection of a reported proposal by U.N. Secretary General Kofi Annan that ASEAN act collectively to resolve the political deadlock in Burma.

“Before they come up with such a suggestion they need to think of the outcome they are going to get,” the Burmese foreign minister told the Bangkok newspaper ‘The Nation’ in New York.

The daily was told by unnamed diplomats at the U.N. General Assembly session that the U.N. Secretary General had advised Vietnamese President Tran Duc Luang, who is the current ASEAN chair, to activate the new ASEAN crisis management mechanism.

He was referring to the ASEAN ‘Troika’ of past, present and future chairs of the grouping. Set up at the July meeting of the 10 ASEAN foreign ministers in the Thai capital, the troika is visualised as a regional crisis intervention mechanism.

Although the troika’s mandate clearly says that it “shall refrain from addressing issues that constitute the internal affairs of ASEAN countries,” analysts have noted that the political crisis in Burma is no longer purely an internal affair of Burma.

Thailand has already indicated this with Foreign Minister Surin Pitsuwan expressing concern that the Burmese regime’s treatment of Suu Kyi could sully the “image of ASEAN as a whole”.

However, ASEAN chair Vietnam has firmly rejected any suggestion that the grouping deviate from the “traditional principle” of non- interference in the internal affairs of each other.

Statements from Hanoi and by senior Vietnamese political leaders have reiterated this stand.

Addressing a meeting of ASEAN lawmakers in Singapore earlier this month, Vietnamese National Assembly Chairman Nong Manh stressed the need to “safeguard the fundamental co-operation principles of respecting national independence and…non-interference in each other’s internal affairs.”

“History has shown that these principles have created the tradition of solidarity and unity in diversity within the regional body,” he said.

Thailand is the only ASEAN nation so far to speak out boldly on the latest standoff between Suu Kyi and the generals. “We wish to see national reconciliation taking place in Burma as fast as possible,” foreign minister Surin said.

However, Burma’s Win Aung has blasted Surin, saying his statement “could harm relations among the member countries of ASEAN, whose cardinal principle is not to interfere in others’ internal affairs.”

ASEAN’s inability to act again has been criticised by the Burmese opposition. “What happens in Burma is not exactly an internal problem of Burma,” says Burmese opposition leader Teddy Buri who was successful in the 1990 parliamentary election in that country.

“ASEAN has a responsibility to see and to assist a return to democracy in Burma,” he told IPS. Buri was among a group of members of the Burmese government-in-exile who were in the Philippines capital late August to persuade lawmakers to press Manila to act.

Some of the senators told the Burmese pro-democracy leaders that they favoured Burma’s expulsion from ASEAN.

However, the Burmese opposition is also aware of ASEAN’s compulsions. While Indonesia is too preoccupied with its own internal problems, the Malaysian government is not as sympathetic to Suu Kyi’s cause as the opposition in that country, say Burmese opposition leaders.

According to ASEAN diplomacy analyst Chayachoke Chulasiriwrongs of Bangkok’s Chulalongkorn University, ASEAN nations are unable to act on Burma because quite a few of them are in no position to criticise Burma.

“If you have to criticise others, you have to come out clean yourself,” he told IPS. Countries like Indonesia and Malaysia, which are facing worldwide criticism for their handling of domestic political problems, would find it difficult to point a finger at Burma, he said.

Thailand’s silence on Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamed’s alleged use of state machinery to victimise protege-turned-foe Anwar Ibrahim, has also put a question mark on the sincerity of Bangkok’s statements on the Suu Kyi affair, he said.

Thailand has spoken out on Suu Kyi’s stand-off with the military regime, but there was “not a sound” on the events in Malaysia, he pointed out.

“So the (Burmese regime) may be wondering, ‘is Thailand doing this on its own or someone else’s bidding?’,” he said.

Chayachoke also faulted ASEAN nations for trying to “exploit” Burma. Countries like Singapore and Malaysia have looked for business in Burma after its admission into ASEAN three years ago.

Malaysia played a key role in Rangoon’s admission into the grouping in the face of stiff pressure from the West, which accuses Burma of serious human rights abuse in the form of forced labour.

ASEAN nations then argued that engaging Burma diplomatically was a far better way of persuading it to accept international norms, than by isolating it with sanctions.

Critics say while constructive engagement is not wrong, Burma was allowed to come in without any agreement on a “benchmark”.

“Burma was allowed to enter ASEAN without any benchmark. When we invite people to come in, each one has to help ASEAN to grow,” said Chayachoke.

While Burma’s entry gave it a “chance to display itself to the world”, ASEAN nations did not insist on reciprocity.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags