Sunday, November 22, 2026
Analysis Jim Lobe
- With only a week left before the Nov. 7 elections, Green Party candidate Ralph Nader is causing major headaches for the campaign of Vice President Al Gore, as well as for left-leaning voters torn between Gore and an anti-corporate reformer with no hope of winning.
A surge in Nader’s strength in the upper Midwest and Pacific Northwest has forced Gore to return to states, which he thought he had safely wrapped up months ago. Instead of going after voters who are torn between him and Bush, Gore finds himself spending valuable time and money trying to woo back voters leaning toward Nader.
The latest polls in Oregon and Wisconsin, considered all but certain to go for Gore just a few weeks ago, showed Nader taking 10 percent of the vote in both states, and tipping the plurality in favour of Texas Gov. George W. Bush. Even California, long seen as a Gore bastion, is now considered up for grabs as Nader appears to be pulling votes away from the vice president.
While Gore and Bush are still running neck and neck in the national polls, the individual states are the true battleground for the presidency. That is because the president is not elected by direct popular vote, but rather by the “electoral college” of the states.
Depending on its total population, each state is accorded a certain number of electoral votes, all of which are cast on behalf of the presidential candidate who receives the most votes in that state. In other words, if Nader siphons off enough votes from Gore in California to give Bush a plurality, Bush will win all of California’s 54 electoral votes. It takes 270 electoral votes to win the election.
Most political pundits now believe that each major candidate can count on between 180 and 200 electoral votes, leaving about 10 states with a total of about 100 electoral votes still on the fence. In almost all of these, Nader is polling at five percent or more.
For most of the election, Gore, like the mainstream media, had ignored Nader, who first came to national attention in 1959 when, as a Harvard law student, he published ‘Unsafe at Any Speed,’ a devastating critique of a popular car manufactured by General Motors.
That launched his career as the US’ most prominent consumer champion, a base from which he built an empire of non-governmental organisations (NGOs), public-interest law firms, and research groups dedicated to making corporations accountable to the public welfare, the poor, and the environment.
In more recent years, Nader has become a leading voice against US- style globalisation. Supported by labour unions and environmentalists, he has opposed trade agreements and legislation that do not include safeguards for worker rights and the environment. He also has campaigned hard for a major overhaul of the way election campaigns are financed, arguing that a flood of corporate money has effectively taken over both parties.
Corporate money, according to Nader, has resulted in the “total Republicanisation of the (Democratic) Party.” “Both parties are selling our government to big-business paymasters,” Nader says in his standard stump speech in which he describes the choice between Gore and Bush as “tweedle-dee and tweedle-dum”.
Bush, according to Nader, is “nothing more than a corporation disguised as a human being”.
He is even more scathing about Gore, accusing him of selling out to corporate interests on the environment and the poor. “There’s no end to his betrayal,” Nader said of the vice president. “The only difference between Al Gore and George W. Bush is the velocity with which their knees hit the floor when corporations knock.”
Nader’s emergence as the only third-party candidate capable of determining the final result of the election was surprising to many analysts who expected that right-winger Pat Buchanan, who deserted the Republican Party earlier this year to run as the Reform Party’s candidate, would be at least as strong. It was thought that Buchanan would take as many votes away from Bush as Nader might siphon off from Gore.
But Buchanan’s high-handed take-over of the Reform Party, which under Perot took 19 and eight percent of the presidential vote in 1992 and 1996, respectively, backfired. Despite a 12-million-dollar infusion of federal funds, he is currently polling at less than one percent nationally, compared to Nader’s share of around five percent.
For Nader, who has no illusions about winning the presidency, five percent is the magic number. It would win the Green Party government financing in the next presidential election. Although Nader is not a party member, he believes meeting such a threshold could set the stage for real alternative to Democrats. In any case, he argues, if he denies Gore a victory, the Democratic Party will have to move leftward precisely to pre-empt desertions to the Greens.
That reasoning is strongly questioned by many on the left who see Nader as a spoiler and Gore as “the lesser of two evils”. While they agree that both Gore and Bush are responsive above all to corporate interests – particularly on such fundamental matters as globalisation and neo-liberalism, they also insist that there also are crucial differences between them on other key issues, notably civil and women’s rights, global warming and the environment, and labour.
The pro-Gore forces, for example, note the likelihood that several justices on the nine-member Supreme Court – whose power is co-equal with Congress and the presidency – will step down in the coming four years, and that whoever the incoming president appoints in their place will likely tip the balance on a number of these same issues.
They also cite Gore’s opposition to Bush’s plans to open the Arctic wilderness area in Alaska to oil exploration and drilling and to build an expensive national missile defence programme which experts warn could result in an arms race with China and Russia as evidence of serious substantive differences between the two men.
In addition to his own last-minute appearances in states with strong Nader support, Gore is dispatching prominent left-wing surrogates – many of whom have been Nader’s staunch allies on globalisation issues – to key districts in Oregon, Washington, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Ohio, Michigan, and Pennsylvania.
They include the Rev. Jesse Jackson, Jr., Senators Edward Kennedy and Paul Wellstone, feminist Gloria Steinem, Friends of the Earth president Brent Blackwelder, and top labour union officers like AFL-CIO president John Sweeney, as well as Hollywood personalities and rock stars designed to appeal to Nader’s most fervent constituency, university students.