Friday, November 20, 2026
Analysis - Shahrzad Moshiri
- Has Iranian President Mohamad Khatami finally given up trying to loosen the nearly quarter century-old stranglehold of Islamic religious conservatives on social and political life in this country?
Even as many inside this nation and outside, are hoping this is not true, all available evidence suggests that this may indeed be the case.
Despite controlling the main institutions of parliamentary governance, the reformists are on the defensive, with key supporters in jail.
Perhaps the only reformer not in danger of being summoned by the powerful, conservative-controlled law courts, is the president himself.
Hamidreza Taraqqi, the secretary of one the most well-known conservative organisations — the Islamic Coalition Society — has even said that the Khatami presidency can only be tolerated for one term.
According to Mohammadreza Bahonar, another top conservative leader of the Islamic Society of Engineers, the reformers have reached a dead end and are trying to break out with the help of a psychological warfare campaign.
However, political analysts note that the reformists can draw hope from Iran’s predominantly young population.
Indeed, the conservative backlash to Khatami’s nearly four-year- old reformist presidency, is said to reflect awareness that modern tools of communication and the country’s increasingly young people, could weaken their grip on the levers of power.
Presently, 70 percent of the country’s population is under 30 years old. Four out of every 10 Iranians, are under 20 years old.
The young in Iran face growing unemployment, with a mix of recession and inflation creating conditions that threaten to undermine social and political stability, say political observers.
Moreover, Iranian society is no longer out of touch with the latest news about events in the country and outside, thanks to the new world of instant communication, based on satellite television and the Internet.
The situation was aptly summed up by the president himself in a mid-January speech. “Taking into account what the society is asking for and expecting, there are two ways to react to its demand,” Khatami told Iranian Parliament Jan. 14.
“One is to block and impede this request by the public and consequently drive the society toward tension, crisis and on its way to collapse…the second method is…try to adapt, adjust and accommodate this rightful demand with religious parameters…as well as our historic and cultural identity,” he added.
After Khatami’s landslide in the May 1997 presidential election, many people, including the reformers, believed that the only obstacle to real and concrete reforms in Iran was their control of the legislature.
But this wishful thinking stopped when one of the president’s closest advisers and the chief strategist of the reform movement, Saeed Hajarian was shot at, barely days after the impressive reformist win in the February 2000 ‘Majlis’ (parliamentary) polls.
The reformers interpreted the attempt on Hajarian’s life as an ‘assassination’ of the reform movement as a whole.
Right wing conservatives subsequently closed down more than 20 reformist publications. When the reform-minded legislature tried to change the Press Law to rescue the pro-reform dailies, a condemnatory letter by the supreme spiritual leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, stopped the free press movement in its tracks.
This confirmed for the reformers the hard fact that their control of the Majlis was not enough to bring about reform in the country.
In the latest offensive against the press, a number of leading journalists and intellectuals were jailed this month after they attended a conference in Germany, which was held to review the future of the reform movement in Iran.
Among them were famed investigative journalist, Akbar Ganji, and Ezzatollah Sahabi — a renowned nationalist-religious figure, who spent several years in jail during the pre-revolution Pahlavi regime of Iran.
Top reformist leaders admit that there is not much they can do.
“Even though the conservatives have lost 80 percent of the elective seats of the government, they still control 80 percent of the levers of power,” said Seyed Mohammadreza Khatami, the president’s brother and secretary-general of the main pro-Khatami movement in the country — the Islamic Iran Participation Front.
Any legislative bill ratified by the Majlis can be vetoed by the all-powerful, 12-member Guardian Council, on the ground that it is unconstitutional or violates religious law. The council exercised this power several times in the past year.
One of the latest to be rejected was a legislation passed by the Majlis concerning travel abroad by Iranian women to study in foreign educational institutions, without the permission of their fathers or husbands.
Moreover, the judiciary is still controlled largely by the conservatives, who head the Revolutionary Court, the Tehran Justice Department and the Special Court for the Clergy.
Above all, hard-line conservatives hold clout, in and around the inner circle of the supreme leader.
Political observers say that the present state of confrontation between the reformers and conservatives has given Iranian people a difficult choice — to go ahead with reforms or face chaos.
By ignoring and excluding many of the traditional cultural and religious values of Iran, the present conditions are creating an extensive and far-reaching economic and social crisis, which threatens calm and stability in Iran, they say.
Says Deputy Intelligence Minister for Cultural and Strategic Research, Jamal Shafiee: “…there is absolutely no other choice but to review and rethink our internal and external security priorities with due attention to the changes that have taken place in our society.”
According to Shafiee, these changes include the doubling of Iran’s population. “Within these changes there is a definite peaceful generation revolution that is currently taking place in our society. The generation gap is undeniable and quite wide and getting wider everyday,” he says.