Asia-Pacific, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS-PAKISTAN: Religious Rule on Women a ‘Moralistic Maneuver’

Muddassir Rizvi

ISLAMABAD, Aug 21 2001 (IPS) - Pakistan’s highest Islamic advisory body has found itself the target of ire of rights groups after it issued a pronouncement that seeks to ban women from seeing male doctors and having their clothes sewn by men.

The rule, published earlier this month in the Urdu-language press, has so infuriated rights advocates that some are now questioning the wisdom of having such an institution as the Council of Islamic Ideology (CII) at all.

“We call upon the government to ensure that the CII refrains from formulating moral frameworks for women of Pakistan,” reads a press statement signed by dozens of rights groups in the country.

“In fact,” it continues, “we urge the government to re- examine the rationale and raison d’etre of having the CII at all, and its advisory role.”

Many rights advocates have even gone further by calling on the military government to do away with institutions that they have have been retarding development by propagating conservative views that have nothing to do with Islam — but only reflect male chauvinism.

But some observers are advising activist groups to calm down, finding some relief in the fact that the CII’s decree is not binding on the government.

Says Hafiz Azizur Rehman, who specialises in Islamic law: “The CII cannot issue a decree (‘fatwa’). Whenever somebody approaches it with an issue, it gives its opinion. The case in point is also an opinion and not decree (‘fatwa’).”

Others argue, though, that since the CII is a constitutional body, whatever it says has considerable weight.

Many were also upset to note that the publication of the ‘opinion’ coincided with the meeting of the National Commission on the Status of Women convened by two rights groups, Aurat (Women’s) Foundation and Shirkat Gah, in Islamabad.

The commission had been formed by the military government, headed by President Pervez Musharraf, to ensure that the voices of women are heard in policymaking and their rights protected.

Interestingly enough, among the Commission’s members is CII chairman S M Zaman, who boycotted the meeting.

An official at the Ministry of the Women’s Development who declines to be named confirms, “We have been contacted by some rights groups asking for the removal of the chairperson from the commission. This is a sensitive issue as it may bring the clergy head on with the rights groups.”

The CII declaration came as surprise to many, since it follows several decisions by the military government that were aimed at promoting women’s role in governance and emancipation in all spheres of life.

The government has already inducted women ministers in federal and provincial governments. Local polls held on Aug. 2 also yielded thousands of women councillors and at least three women who were re-elected as district ‘nazim’ (governors).

Now, many women see the CII declaration as a reminder to all elected women of the odds they have to work against.

“This is typical way of thinking of men to control women, sometimes in the name of traditions and morality and others in the name of religion,” says Rukhsana Faiz, who was elected councillor of the Punjab town of Sargodha. “But the only objective is to keep women subservient to their desires.”

Seconds Kaneez Zehra, an Islamabad-based consumer rights activist: “The decree is nothing but the reinforcement of the typical mindset of the religious right and the reiteration of their position on the role they perceive for women.”

Zehra believes the CII’s issuance is a direct attack on the women’s right to choose services and service providers.

She argues, “Women have the right to be treated by a male gynaecologist, just as men can go for treatment to female doctors. In this case the gender is not important, but expertise and competence.”

The CII ruling has also irked the medical community, which believes that it has put into question the sacred patient-doctor relationship.

Dr Ahmed Sohail, who has a private clinic here, says, “When a doctor sees a patient, all he cares about is the suffering of the person, disregarding the caste, creed, sex or economic group.”

He also says that in the first place, the lack of female doctors in suburban and rural areas could pose problems for those trying to comply with the CII’s pronouncement.

“Not many female doctors go and work in rural areas,” says Sohail. “Even in cities, a majority of female doctors do not opt for night shifts because of cultural obligations.”

“The other area is the specialisation,” he adds. “Not many female doctors are specialists in fields other than gynaecology.”

Those, however, are not the only concerns covered by the CII pronouncement. According to the Council, women should not work in the advertising industry and as airport protocol personnel. While the CII allows women to work as flight attendants and in many other professions, they have to do so wearing veils.

A press report about the decree also says, “Women should not be forced to give photographs for their job or other identification cards if they don’t want to.”

Aurat Foundation, the most vocal of the women’s rights groups in the country, says that such conservatism has done nothing but slow down, if not stop, Pakistani women from achieving their maximum potential.

“Women’s development in our country has already been crippled because of regular onslaught of moralistic maneuvering by the state and a number of retrogressive forces,” comments Shahnaz Ahmed of the foundation. “As a result, the development of Pakistan (itself) has been badly affected.”

According to official figures, 29 percent of Pakistani women have no real access to healthcare while an alarming 72 percent — as against 47 percent of males – are deprived of educational opportunities.

These only mean that many Pakistani women are either too weak or lacking in skills to make significant contributions to the country’s economy.

Struggling for the repeal of discriminatory Islamic laws introduced by the military dictator Zia ul- Haq 20 years ago, rights groups maintain that spirituality and morality cannot be enforced through legislation and policing, in the manner of Afghanistan’s ruling Taliban.

“If the military government is serious in empowering women and protecting their rights,” says Kaneez Zehra, “it will have to do away with all laws that are discriminatory to women.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags