Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Groups Seek U.N. Rights Probe of Colombian Fumigation

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Jan 17 2002 (IPS) - Environmentalists and indigenous peoples’ organisations in the Amazon river basin have asked the U.N. human rights commission to urge the United States and Colombia to stop fumigating illicit crops in the Latin American country.

The aerial fumigation is part of the Plan Colombia anti-narcotics strategy partly funded by Washington and launched in 2000 by Colombian President Andres Pastrana. The effort includes 7.5 billion dollars for social and economic development. The United States has pledged 1.3 billion dollars, mostly for military equipment and training, and aerial fumigation of illicit coca, marijuana, and poppy crops.

Earthjustice, a U.S.-based law firm, wrote the request to the Geneva-based U.N. commission on behalf of Amazon Alliance, a network of indigenous communities and environmental organisations.

According to the document, a mixture of herbicides sprayed from the air ‘drifts’ over vast expanses of the countryside in Colombia and neighbouring Ecuador. Thus, the petition states, deprives poor farmers and indigenous communities of their rights to a clean and healthy environment, health, life, sustenance, and property.

“The spray mixture and the manner in which it is applied have resulted in numerous health problems for residents, destruction of their food resources, contamination of their surface water, damage to surrounding wilderness areas, and tremendous deforestation,” it says.

The U.S. and Colombian governments have said the herbicide used in the fumigation – glyphosate, which is marketed by the U.S.- based Monsanto company under the trade name ‘Roundup’ – is as safe as salt. Critics have countered that directions on glyphosate labels warn users not to expose humans and water sources to the product.

Even more toxic than the herbicide itself are two additives, known as surfactants, that are added to enhance its effect on plants, according to the complaint.

Scott Pasternack, an associate attorney with Earthjustice’s international programme, said both governments have attempted to conceal this information by only asserting that glyphosate is harmless.

“The State Department has concealed information about the true toxicity of the spray mixture and has failed to conduct proper environmental and assessments,” said Pasternack.

State Department officials could not be reached for comment.

The complaint says that although Monsanto has recommended that aerial application not occur more than about three meters above the top of the largest plants, Colombian anti-narcotics police fly aircraft 10-15 meters above the tops of vegetation.

“This difference in altitude would be expected to greatly increase drift of the mixture to non-target areas and communities such as those in Ecuador,” it says.

The document is the latest in a series of efforts by environmentalists and indigenous organisations to stop the aerial spraying. In September 2001, U.S.-based attorneys filed a class action lawsuit on behalf of 10,000 Ecuadorean Indians who charged DynCorp, a U.S.-based company, of recklessly spraying their homes and farms, causing illness and deaths and destroying food crops.

That suit was brought under the Alien Tort Claims Act, which allows foreign citizens to sue U.S. companies in courts here over acts committed abroad.

“The spraying of a toxic herbicide over people and land is a stupid and reckless action,” said Terry Collingsworth of the International Labour Rights Fund here, one of the lead counsels in the case.

Last year, Colombian legislators and governors came to Washington to plead their case against fumigation. They told reporters that fumigation was not hurting the narcotics industry but was severely harming poor farming families.

Between August 2000 and May 2001, Colombia’s Public Ombudsman received 1,158 reports of damage to human health, the environment, and food crops allegedly caused by fumigation, they said. Planes spraying the crops, they added, blanket entire communities with the herbicide, causing sickness and skin problems.

Indigenous leaders in Colombia also have voiced opposition to the spraying.

Last year, Emperatriz Cahuache, president of the Organisation of Indigenous Peoples of the Colombian Amazon, came to Washington and showed reporters a map illustrating how indigenous territories overlap with and are affected by areas under coca and marijuana cultivation and targeted for fumigation.

“These fumigations are contaminating the Amazon and destroying the forest,” said Cahuache.

In response, several U.S. legislators have called for investigations into the impact of the spraying. In July 2001, Representative Steve Rothman, a Democrat, successfully added language to an appropriations bill that required the State Department to report to Congress on the health and environmental impacts of fumigation in Colombia.

The language also directed the State Department to establish guidelines and verification methods to ensure that future aerial fumigation efforts do not harm the health of Colombians, their water supply, or legal crops.

Two years ago, U.S. lawmakers on a diplomatic visit to Colombia gained first hand knowledge of the potential impacts of fumigation. In December 2000, Democratic Senator Paul Wellstone and several members of his staff were hit with a fine mist of glyphosate from a helicopter demonstrating aerial fumigation.

Police officials said it was an accident, blaming the wind for blowing the glyphosate from its intended path. Wellstone winced and rubbed his eyes later, but managed a joke, saying he could become a case study on possible dangers linked to the chemical.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags