Saturday, November 21, 2026
Commentary - N Janardhan
- Iraqi Deputy Prime Minister Tariq Aziz, Lebanese President Emile Lahoud, former U.N. secretary-general Boutros Boutros Ghali and Arab League spokesperson and Palestinian leader Hanan Ashrawi are some well-known names from the Middle East: Arab but not Muslim, Christian but not Western.
As the war against the Taliban, al-Qaeda and terrorism in Afghanistan was underway and at times portrayed as a clash the Christian and Islamic worlds, one community across the Middle East is facing an identity crisis.
These are Arab Christians, a community that exists in fairly large numbers across the region, but whose presence is not as obvious to many because of their Arab culture, which overrides their religious affiliation.
The world uses the terms Arab and Muslim interchangeably, and therein lies the root of the problems for Arab Christians in the post-Sep. 11 world.
Since the 19th century, Arab Christians have played a vital role in defining a secular Arab cultural identity. It is no coincidence that most of the founders of secular Arab nationalism were Christians — Michel Aflaq, who founded the Baath Party, and George Antonius, who wrote ‘The Arab Awakening’.
Ghassan Al Toweiny, an Arab Christian and owner-publisher of Lebanon’s ‘Al Nahar’ newspaper, argues that Arab identity is not contingent on religion: “All Arab Christians have an Islamic aspect to their identity, just as every Arab Muslim has a Christian one.”
Toweiny vehemently rejects the idea that Christians may be “less Arab” than Muslims. “We are not vestiges of the Crusades. We existed long before. We were Arabs before Islam, Arabs with Islam and Arabs after Islam.”
Toweiny is not far from the truth. Deducing religion from people’s names is as difficult as identifying them from their attire, language or habits because they are far too similar and common.
Susan Mubarak could easily be mistaken for a Christian going by her maiden name, but Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak’s wife is Muslim. To make things more difficult, women from both communities wear headscarves as part of their attire.
Perhaps what gives away a woman’s religious identity without doubt is if she has a cross visibly on her neck or she is eating in a restaurant during the holy month of Ramadan, when Muslims fast from sunrise to sundown.
Since all speak Arabic, differentiating the Muslims from the Christians among the men is impossible. Knowledge of French could sometimes give away the identity of a few in Egypt, Lebanon, Morocco and Algeria.
Ironically, the presumed birthplace of Jesus Christ is the Church of Nativity in Bethlehem in the West Bank, a part of the Palestinian territories.
About 14 million people, who did not convert to Islam, are Christian in the Arab world. Most of the Arab-Christians are in Lebanon (35 to 45 percent of the population), Palestine (5 to 10 percent), Jordan (6 to12 percent), Syria (10 percent), Sudan (10 percent), Egypt (6 to 12 per cent) and Iraq (3 percent). In all, about 5 to 6 percent of the population in the Arab countries are Christian.
“Our inspiration as Arabs is rooted in the renaissance of Arab nationalism of the 19th century, that thrived in Lebanon, Iraq and Egypt,” Toweiny adds.
The war against Taliban and al-Qaeda did heighten tension between the two communities in the region, but did not break the unity chord bound by nationalism.
Rafiq Habib, a Coptic Protestant intellectual and an avid observer of Egyptian sectarian relations, explains: “People felt an inherent tension communal tension after the attack on the United States.”
“While the Christians felt insecure because they were afraid of incitement against them as the war continued, Muslims felt that it had all the makings of a religious conflict. But the fear remained within rather than boil and spill over into action,” he adds.
Bishop Marcos of Shubra Al Kheima assails the media for inflaming much of the tension: “The Egyptian press, by focusing only on the negative treatment of Muslims in the West and the potential for a Christian versus Muslim war, could have made matters terrible in the region.”
While Osama bin Laden, the man the United States says is behind the Sep. 11 terror attacks, tried forcing the believers versus non- believers wedge in the Islamic world — and many in the Western media fell prey to it — modern Arab history beats that reductionism.
The Arabness of the Christians in the region is best explained in the Palestinians’ fight against Israeli occupation. George Habash, a Christian, established the Arab Nationalist Movement (Haraqet Al Qawmeyoun Al Arab) in 1952 and the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) — a left-leaning resistance organisation — in 1967.
The PFLP fought the occupation of Lebanon in 1982 alongside the Lebanese communist and socialist progressive parties, and is an active force in the ongoing ‘intifadah’ (uprising) against Israel.
Arab history is full of such examples. According to Mariz Tadros of the ‘Al Ahram Weekly’ published from Egypt, Christians were involved from the start of the nationalist movement.
Along with Muslims Rifaa Al Tahtawi of Egypt and Khayr Al Din of Tunisia was Lebanese Maronite Christian Butrus Al Bustani. Under Ottoman rule, Bustani worked hard to raise the people’s awareness of their Arab heritage through his writings and journals, which he later moved from Beirut to Cairo. In 1860, Christians also printed several periodicals that served to revive Arabic language and literature – well before the independence project from the Ottoman empire was born.
In 1875, the first organised effort of the Arab national movement came into being in the form of a secret society in Lebanon comprising of both Christians and Muslims.
But the Arab Christians’ numbers are shrinking annually through emigration.
In the past 20 years, at least two million have left the Middle East to make new lives in Europe, Australia and America. Often, being part of the educated elite in their countries, occupying influential offices in the government and being better off than their fellow Muslim citizens, made them a tribe to envy.
The Lebanese civil war between the Maronite Christians and Muslims in the 1970s brought that tension to the fore, as does the frequent and irreconcilable standoffs between the Copts and Muslims in Egypt
“It is a very serious matter,” Lebanese Christian historian Kamal Salibi says of the Christians’ departure. “Each time a Christian goes, no other Christian comes to fill his place and that is a very bad thing for the Arab world. It is the Christian Arabs who keep the Arab World ‘Arab’ rather than ‘Muslim’.”
And there lies the implicit understanding that not all Arabs are Muslim. Not all Arabs — Muslim or Christian — see the world as the West sees it or as bin Laden would have wanted them to.