Saturday, November 21, 2026
Dionne Jackson Miller
- The Queen of England and Duke of Edinburgh arrive in Jamaica Monday on a three-day visit to mark the fiftieth anniversary of Elizabeth II’s accession to the throne. Government officials are upbeat but the royal visit has re- ignited an old debate here – the relevance of the monarchy.
Although Jamaica gained independence from Britain in 1962, it has retained the British monarch as its titular head of state with a local representative, the governor general. This sits uneasily with many here.
There is general tacit agreement that Jamaican government needs to evolve from constitutional monarchy to a republic but this has never amounted to more than talk. It is widely expected that the somewhat leisurely movement towards constitutional reform will eventually see the establishment of a republic but there is no time frame for this.
Critics of the constitutional monarchy point to countries like Trinidad and Tobago, which also gained political independence in 1962 but has a republican constitution that provides for a Trinidadian president as head of state.
At one end of the spectrum are people like Queens Counsel Headley Cunningham. Cunningham led a delegation from the Commonwealth Caribbean to Buckingham Palace ten years ago and has fond memories of meeting Elizabeth II. While not describing himself as a royalist, he insists retaining the Queen as head of state does the country no harm.
“The Queen is a symbol, but it is a symbol that binds the Commonwealth together and her presence here certainly has significance,” says Cunningham, who notes that 54 former colonial territories now belong to the Commonwealth. “Anything that is a cementing factor that can bring about cohesiveness and peace and goodwill among peoples of the earth is a good thing, and the Queen symbolises this.”
“My own view for the three days that she’ll be here, it brings about a calming effect on the nation, and it’s an ultimate recoginition of her constitutional role (as head of state, and) as head of the Commonwealth,” he adds.
Shakira Moore, a 17-year-old student, is among a younger generation that appears to share Cunningham’s views.
“I think it’s a good thing despite what others might say. Despite the fact that we have our independence, I think she should still be head of state, because she is a rich link to our history. Slavery was an unfortunate thing but it’s what made us who we are, so to completely ignore it is to completely ignore an aspect of our lives,” says Moore.
On the other hand, attorney at law and Rastafarian Michael Lorne says he believes the Queen symbolises oppression.
“She’s no symbol of peace and hope. She represents a legacy of blood, pain and violence that has been done to the African people,” he says. “She’s the cause of what we’ve inherited today with divisiveness and black people killing black people.”
Lorne’s views are shared throughout the Rastafarian community, a religious movement dating back to the 1930s that stresses black empowerment and self-help and denounces many aspects of white culture and the vestiges of colonialism. The Rastas were one of the few groups to openly protest against the last royal visit, and at that time staged small, peaceful demonstrations to press home their views.
“Why do we need a white symbol to be queen? Why can’t we have black people as kings and queens? That in itself is a defeatist mentality, for my children to think the only way you can be queen is if you’re white.” Lorne says.
Rastas have been prominent in calling for former colonial powers to make reparation for slavery and colonisation. Lorne says the Rasta community is considering filing a legal declaration to this effect during the royal visit.
“The past has affected us substantially (in terms of) the type of laws which were passed,” he says. “Laws which demeaned the African race, (were) passed by Britain, stating, for example, that a black man could not give evidence in court, that the black race could not participate in certain trades. People are going to say that these laws have been abolished. But those laws have (left) a permanent and indelible scar upon our people. I have always demanded that the monarchy owes us. Britain owes us compensation for the atrocities done to us. Legally, you can’t sue the monarchy but we were thinking of a declaration on behalf of the Rastafarian community that we have a right to be compensated for all the atrocities done during slavery.”
Treading the middle ground is talk show host June Hines, who says the monarchy is an anachronism that should have been dispensed with years ago but the issue is not a burning one for most Jamaicans.
“I don’t get as excited about it as many people do,” says Hines. “The queen is so remote, so far removed from the everyday lives and reality of the Jamaican people I think if you don’t hear that the queen is coming on a visit, most Jamaicans do not remember that Elizabeth is Queen of Jamaica.”
Jamaica, says Hines, has dithered in dispensing with the monarchy. She likens its retention to the current debate over whether the country should participate in a Caribbean Court of Justice and dispense with Britain’s Privy Council as the country’s final court of appeal.
“We are still holding on to vestiges of things which are long past or ought to be long past,” says Hines. “A queen ought to be long past in Jamaica not because she’s harmful. There are lots of things which are not harmful but are no longer useful. I think there is a level of ambivalence in the political arena about what it would mean if we had a Jamaican or a black president, and there are still people who hold on to the (belief) that somebody from outside will come in and have (a) calming influence.”
For other Jamaicans, the entire debate is academic and irrelevant.
Street vendor Barrington Kelly says his main concern is over the 300,000 dollars reportedly spent on preparations for the royal visit – that, and his own struggle to survive.
“Only when the queen is coming to Jamaica you see them looking about all this kind of thing, spending all kind of (money), but I don’t see any reason for the queen to come here, because nothing (is) going on. The queen (is) not doing anything to build up anything for us. I’m not excited about the visit because I don’t put my mind on any queen thing,” he says.