Sunday, November 22, 2026
Ferry Biedermann
- Both Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon and Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat have their eyes on a major Middle East initiative from the U.S. Administration expected this week.
“We must build the institutions necessary for the evolution of a Palestinian state which can live peacefully in the region and provide hope for the suffering Palestinian people,” President Bush said after a meeting with Saudi foreign minister Prince Saud al-Faisal last week.
Al-Faisal said after the meeting with Bush that he was pleased with what he had heard from the President.
The Saudi minister was the latest in a string of visitors who met President Bush to discuss the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Earlier Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak left Washington without getting much support for his views.
The talks so far indicate to some extent the way the Bush Administration is thinking. Bush particularly rejected Mubarak’s proposal for a timeline for establishing a Palestinian state. Sharon had vehemently opposed such a schedule, saying it had led in the past to unrealistic expectations.
The stakes are so high that Sharon left some of his aides in Washington after his visit in order to counter the influence of the Saudi foreign minister’s visit.
The plan that seems to be emerging from Washington includes a commitment to working towards a Palestinian state in a schedule tied to conditions rather than dates. These conditions would include reform of the Palestinian Authority in three areas: good governance, financial regulation, and security services.
Increasingly, the U.S. is said to be leaning towards taking on the role of arbiter in these reforms, rather than the Israeli government.
Once the U.S. judges that these conditions have been fulfilled, the reported proposal is to declare a ‘provisional’ Palestinian state without defined borders. Contentious issues could then be settled through direct negotiations between Israel and the State of Palestine.
White House spokesman Ari Fleischer said this is “one of the things the President is looking at.” But he said consultations are still continuing and that no plan has yet been drafted.
Israeli foreign minister Shimon Peres says what is known of the proposal makes it similar to a plan that he had negotiated with the speaker of the Palestinian Legislative Council, Abu Alaa.
Peres is reported to be holding talks with Palestinian officials on convening an international peace conference where these proposals would be discussed.
But Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat has raised doubts about the emerging U.S. proposal. The Palestinians, like the Egyptians, want a well-defined timetable for the establishment of a Palestinian state.
“What is needed from the U.S. administration is to specify a mechanism and to specify a timeline that will end the Israeli occupation,” says Erekat. “This must continue in parallel with the building of Palestinian institutions and parallel with ending the Israeli aggression and attacks.”
Palestinian minister for planning Nabil Shaath is visiting Washington this week to present the Palestinian position. Some senior Palestinian leaders are inclined to accept the formula of a provisional state so long as it is tied to a firm commitment to total Israeli withdrawal from the Gaza strip and the West Bank.
But there is considerable anger on the Palestinian side about some remarks made by Bush. President Bush had said during Sharon’s visit to Washington that “no one has confidence in the emerging Palestinian government.” Palestinian minister for information Yasser Abed Rabbo said the statement “shows that the U.S. cannot be trusted.”
The new Palestinian cabinet is being seen by some as the first step on the road to reform of the Palestinian authority. Arafat has promised elections “as soon as possible.”
But several Palestinian leaders are deeply sceptical about the new cabinet and of Arafat’s intentions to carry out real reforms. Arafat has asked the Legislative Council to vote on the new ministers. But members have asked for a vote of confidence in the whole of the cabinet. Several legislators say that ministers accused of mismanagement have been retained in the Cabinet.
Within Israel there is growing scepticism over the Israeli government’s demands for Palestinian reforms. A commentator with the daily Haaretz said Sharon’s demands were intended to block progress. “If Jordan and Egypt weren’t dictatorships, is there any way we could have made peace with them,” the commentator wrote. “When are we going to stop manufacturing excuses?”