Saturday, November 21, 2026
Jim Lobe
- As the administration of President George W. Bush pressures the U.N. Security Council to endorse military force against Iraq, a blue-ribbon task force of prominent U.S. citizens has called on Washington to take the United Nations much more seriously.
In a report released here Thursday, the task force, whose members span much of the ideological spectrum of the policymaking elite, also called on the administration to help forge a ”democratic caucus” of member states at the United Nations to push a common agenda, particularly on promoting human rights and fighting terrorism.
The task force, which was co-sponsored by the mainstream Council on Foreign Relations (CFR) and Freedom House, a neo-conservative think tank, also urged the administration and Congress to pay all U.S. arrears to the world body.
The money has been withheld periodically over the last decade to force various political, budgetary, and administrative reforms.
While such a tactic ”may have had a positive impact in the past,” the 71-page report concluded, it ”now only serves to diminish leverage”.
Last month, Congress approved a payment of 244 million dollars owed to the United Nations, the last in a three-part legislative package to pay almost one billion dollars in arrears that had accumulated during the 1990s.
The report was issued at a moment when Washington is especially focused on the world body. It has been pressing other states on the 15-member Security Council for the past month to approve a resolution that will authorise the U.S. to use force against Iraq if Baghdad fails to co-operate with proposed new and more stringent U.N. inspections of its alleged weapons of mass destruction (WMD).
The Bush administration was deeply divided on the wisdom of asking the Security Council for such a resolution. Right-wing hawks have long discounted the effectiveness of both the United Nations and its inspectors, favouring instead a direct attack on Iraq, which they say has systematically defied a series of Security Council resolutions dating back to Iraq’s 1990 invasion of Kuwait.
Others in the administration, notably Secretary of State Colin Powell, have argued that Washington should seek a new resolution that would give Baghdad one last chance to co-operate with U.N. inspectors and authorise military action by member-states if it fails to do so.
For now, Bush has decided to follow Powell’s advice, but he has suggested that Washington will reconsider its relationship to the United Nations if the Security Council fails to go along.
”We are at a key juncture in the relationship (that may decide) whether the U.S. will diverge from or engage with the U.N.,” said Lee Hamilton, a former chairman of the House of Representatives foreign affairs committee who co-chaired the task force.
The report, he said, ”comes down solidly on the side of the U.S. engaging with the U.N.,” he said, particularly with respect to promoting what he described as key U.S. aims and values, including ”freedom, human rights, and counter-terrorism”.
Among the members of the task force, whose conclusions were virtually unanimous, were former U.S. ambassadors to the world body, including Jeane Kirkpatrick, who served under former president Ronald Reagan; Thomas Pickering, under George Bush Sr.; and Madeleine Albright, who served under Bill Clinton and also as his secretary of state.
The range of views represented on the task force was even broader than those represented by the three former ambassadors. As a result, no consensus could be reached on substantive issues facing the United States and the United Nations, such as the Bush administration’s opposition to the International Criminal Court (ICC).
Agreement of the entire task force therefore was confined to the basic proposition that Washington should engage the world body more fully and to a number of tactical issues to further U.S. interests and values at the United Nations.
Task force members also agreed that Washington is ”routinely outmatched and outsmarted in the U.N. by a small but skilful group of repressive regimes,” among them, China, Libya, Iraq, Iran, Sudan, and Cuba.
To reduce their influence, it recommends a series of initiatives, beginning with the creation of a ”democracy caucus” that would work within regional blocs and the world body as a whole to advance common objectives. Such an initiative has been tabled before, notably in the so-called Community of Democracies, a U.S.-convened group of about 120 countries that met in Warsaw two years ago and will meet later this month again in Seoul.
Some of the Community countries have been strongly criticised by the United States and other countries for undemocratic practices, including, for example, Algeria, Burkina Faso, Egypt, Indonesia, Kenya, and Tunisia.
The report also called for closer U.S. cooperation with the European Union (EU) at the United Nations and attacked the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM), a caucus of 64 developing countries, as ”an outdated obstacle to effective cooperation within the U.N.”.
That comment drew a partial dissent from task force member Jeffrey Laurenti of the United Nations Association of the USA and Sarah Sewall of the Kennedy School at Harvard University, who noted that NAM’s ”solidarity remains crucial for the weak to gain the attention of the strong to issues the latter might otherwise ignore”.
Washington itself could do much more to increase its effectiveness at the world body, the report says, beginning with, in Hamilton’s words, some ”old-time politics” of lobbying in the ”corridors and back rooms” for U.S. positions.
It should also ensure that the political section of the U.S. mission at the United Nations is adequately staffed and given greater importance within the foreign service.
In addition, Washington should end the practice of withholding or threatening to withhold treaty-obligated dues and make sure that U.S. positions on key U.N. initiatives, such as the rejection of the ICC and other human rights-related initiatives, are adequately explained at the United Nations.
In a partial dissent to the last recommendation, Joanna Weschler of Human Rights Watch stressed that Washington needed to do more than to explain these positions.
”It is well past time for the U.S. government to review its policies on these issues,” she noted, adding, ”If nothing else, from a purely tactical point of view, they alienate nearly every important U.S. ally, and position Washington as a fellow traveller with countries such as Iran, China, Cuba, Libya, and Sudan.”
Jim Lobe
- As the administration of President George W. Bush pressures the U.N. Security Council to endorse military force against Iraq, a blue-ribbon task force of prominent U.S. citizens has called on Washington to take the United Nations much more seriously.
(more…)