Saturday, November 21, 2026
Marites Sison
- The just-ended Fourth World Meeting of Families, organised by the Vatican here, highlighted deep differences between the Catholic Church’s notions of society and what Filipino activists say are today’s realities – starting with the shape of today’s families.
These differences led to divided views over what today constitutes a family in this country, more than 80 percent of whom are Catholics, as well as debate over issues like domestic violence and a woman’s role at home, single-parent families and homosexuals for instance.
The Catholic hierarchy, which views the Fourth World Meeting of Families that ended Sunday as a way to shield the institution from social and immoral ills, stands behind the traditional definition of a family as one constituting a father, mother, and child.
Anything outside this structure is "immoral” in its view, in keeping with the Church’s position that it has brought to international fora such as the U.N. summits on population and women, where its stand also created much controversy.
The Church, according to women’s groups and other independent opinions expressed in columns of daily newspapers in the last few days, is sadly out of step with the reality of the times.
"Continuously clinging to, romanticising and idealising such narrow and traditional family concepts have, over time, resulted in problematic situations especially for the women family members," the Reproductive Health Alliance Network (RHAN), a coalition of NGOs said in a statement.
It called on the church and society to veer away from attitudes and practices that "put a premium on the structure and composition, rather than the quality of relationships within families."
Many women have suffered from abuses and violence from their husbands and partners "in the name of keeping the family together," it added.
Women’s groups took issue with the Church’s silence not just on issues like domestic violence but the ostracism and abuse suffered by gays and lesbians within their families, as well as its condemnation of homosexual unions and those that do not fall under the "nuclear family ideal."
Others questioned the Church’s lack of advocacy for single-parent households and families left behind by the country’s 7 million Overseas Filipino Workers (OFWs), although there are some campaigns to counsel families before the mothers or fathers work overseas and the families while they are apart.
"We challenge the participants and organisers (of the congress) to also tackle the family issues of acceptance and understanding, and basic respect, especially for lesbian family members," the NGO Lesbian Advocates Philippines (LEAP) said in a statement. Bishops, nuns, priests and religious lay people from different parts of the world who attended the meeting have reiterated that divorce, abortion, euthanasia and homosexual unions constitute the major threats to the Christian family.
While discussions in the three-day meeting touched on reconciliation and understanding between family members who have converted to other religions, the issue of gay and lesbian family members was not.
"It is so sad that for many lesbians, the family is one big, living closet. It is tragic that many lesbians are invisible within the families they were born into. It is cruel that lesbians who declare their identity suffer at the hands of their own families," the NGO Womyn Supporting Womyn (WSW) said in a statement. "Lesbians do not destroy families. Hate does."
It challenged the Church’s definition of what constitutes a family. "Despite the variations of the contemporary family, many still have an image of the ideal family as two biological parents with children, forgetting that what makes a family ideal is not its composition but its function,” the group argued.
An ideal family, WSW said, is one which provides "mutual love, compassion, responsibility, integrity, self-reliance, accountability, and respect."
Bishop Socrates Villegas, former spokesman of Manila Archbishop Jaime Cardinal Sin and head of a key parish in the Philippine capital, stated, however, that the Church has been and will be firm in its position that "two persons of the same sex marrying each other is immoral and contrary to the teachings of God."
Villegas said the Church reaches out to gays and lesbians by offering them pastoral care. But gays and lesbians pointed out that the pastoral care provided by the Church strives not to understand but make them renounce their sexual orientation.
In calling for more support for non-traditional families, RHAN cited statistics from the government’s National Statistics Office that showed that in 2000, almost 2.4 million heads of households in this country of 80 million people were widowed and 560,000 either divorced or separated.
Another 2.4 million belong to the category of "others," and 622,300 "unknown."
"The ideal two-parent nuclear family is fast becoming a myth," it said. "Whether brought about by death, temporary or permanent break-ups, single-headed families exist in big numbers and cannot be ignored."
Still, there is little Church and government support for solo parents, RHAN added.
But this sector could also grow in years, going by recent surveys that show that support for divorce – long opposed by the Catholic Church and still banned in the Philippines- is growing among Filipinos.
A nationwide survey conducted by the independent pollster Social Weather Stations (SWS) showed that while 86 percent of 1,200 adult respondents said they were satisfied with family life, 36 percent agreed with the statement that "Divorce is usually the best solution when a couple can’t seem to work out their marriage problems."
The English-language daily ‘Philippine Daily Inquirer’ noted: "This is an increase from the 29 percent who agreed with the statement in 2001, considering the strong lobby of the Catholic Church against any divorce bill in Congress."
The poll is one more example of how the views of an apparently growing groups of people are going against Church positions, many say. ”I think the Church is really so far away from what people think these days and should think about it,” commented an employee for a private company here.