Saturday, November 21, 2026
Néfer Muñoz
- Costa Rica will present the first initiative for a United Nations treaty intended to ban human cloning, coinciding with a move by the European Parliament Thursday to ban the creation of human embryos, including through cloning techniques, for medical research.
The document that the Costa Rican government sent this week to the UN headquarters in New York proposes the prohibition of genetic manipulation to reproduce identical humans or to cultivate human tissue for therapeutic ends.
The initiative from this Central American nation has the backing of 40 countries, including Italy, Spain, United States and most of Latin America, as well as from some African and Asian nations, said foreign minister Roberto Tovar.
"What we are seeking is a ban on human cloning in all its forms, to classify it as a crime, punish those who practice it and regulate experiments that use human genetic material," explained the Costa Rican official.
The 17-page Draft International Convention to Ban Human Cloning in All Its Forms was officially filed with the UN to be translated into the six official languages of the global forum. It will then be presented to the UN membership to initiate debate.
In making the public announcement Wednesday of the document intended for the UN General Assembly, Tovar said, "Human cloning in all its forms offends the universal conscience and leads to a loss of our freedom and individuality.."
The technique produced its first success in 1996 when a group of scientists at Scotland’s Roslin Institute achieved the birth of the lamb Dolly, the clone of an adult sheep.
However, the premature ageing of Dolly, which prompted the scientists to euthanise her in February, indicates that this method of artificial reproduction still involves many scientific challenges and unanswered questions.
The Costa Rican initiative to ban all types of human cloning is based on the Universal Declaration on the Human Genome and Human Rights, which the UN Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO) approved in 1997 and the UN General Assembly adopted in 1998.
The Declaration establishes limits for the intervention in an individual’s genetic makeup.
The UN text also clarifies the notion that the human genome is "heritage of humanity" and that "Everyone has a right to respect for their dignity and for their rights regardless of their genetic characteristics."
Article 11 of the Universal Declaration states: "Practices which are contrary to human dignity, such as reproductive cloning of human beings, shall not be permitted."
According to the Costa Rican initiative, meanwhile, a person commits a crime if he or she deliberately transfers a cell nucleus or divides embryos to create a living organism "in any state of its physical development, that is genetically virtually identical to an already existing human organism or one that has existed previously."
The text calls upon the states that ultimately are party to the agreement to establish the laws necessary to punish those guilty of such crimes. The extradition process, international cooperation and dispute settlement measures are also outlined.
"Cloning is something atrocious, but it wields great power over people’s imaginations," commented biologist Juan de Dios Vial, former president of the Catholic University of Chile.
It is a "despotic" procedure to control genetic reproduction, which makes it "instinctively repulsive," commented Vial, who accompanied minister Tovar in making the announcement of the Costa Rican initiative.
However, there are scientists who see cloning as a potential alternative for treating many types of health problems, such as heart disease or liver disease, because cultivation of genetic material would allow the production of identical healthy cells to replace damaged cells.
Cloning for medical purposes could also lead the way to finding cures for terminal illnesses or improve the quality of life of chronically ill individuals.
"I am against the reproductive cloning of human beings, but I am not against therapeutic cloning," Delia Rivas, a physician specialising in research in this scientific area, said in a conversation with IPS.
Rivas worked at the only laboratory in Costa Rica that carried out in vitro fertilisation, until the procedure that was declared unconstitutional and prohibited in that country in 2000.
"The problem is that those who are against cloning for therapeutic purposes consider the embryo to be a human being, and that isn’t necessarily so," she said.
An embryo cannot be considered a person, argues Rivas, because even inside the human womb there is the chance that it will not develop or that it will be spontaneously aborted.
But biologist Vial, who does see embryos as individuals, responded to arguments about the advantages of cloning for therapeutic purposes saying that the process requires creating many embryos that are never utilised.
"It is like manufacturing many human beings so that they die. If we let this procedure go forward we would be saying to humanity that a living organism is not always worthy of respect," said Vial.
For approval by the UN General Assembly, the Costa Rican-promoted draft Convention requires the votes of half-plus-one of the delegates present for the sessions.
"A text was needed that would serve as the basis for the initial negotiations," said Carlos Fernando Díaz, Costa Rican adviser at the UN and one of the authors of the proposal, which he considers quite flexible.
Díaz told IPS that a ban on all types of cloning would be a way to ensure human dignity because it would prevent genetic commercialisation that could exploit the poor people of the world.
He said that the countries opposed to a human cloning ban, such as China and Singapore, point to the need to promote genetic research and development. The two Asian countries encourage therapeutic cloning as a means to foment economic development.
Israel and Japan are among the countries that have prohibited human cloning. In Canada there are efforts underway to implement a ban.
The U.S. Congress, meanwhile, voted in 2001 to ban human cloning for reproductive purposes and for medical research, with violators of the law facing penalties of up to 10 years in prison.
Once the war in Iraq is over and tensions in the Persian Gulf have lessened, experts believe the proposed convention to ban all forms of human cloning could become one of the leading debates in the international arena.