Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Europe, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

DEVELOMENT: EU Farm Reform Unlikely to Benefit Poor Countries

Stefania Bianchi

BRUSSELS, Jun 27 2003 (IPS) - Civil society groups have rejected the European Union’s agreement to reform the 45-year old common agricultural policy, saying it will harm developing countries.

After more than 15 hours of negotiations in the third round of marathon talks in Luxembourg this week, EU farm ministers finally agreed on a compromise concerning a radical mid-term reform of the so-called CAP.

Launching the modified CAP Thursday, EU Farm Commissioner Franz Fischler said: "This decision marks the beginning of a new era. Our farm policy will fundamentally change. Today, Europe has given itself a new and effective farm policy."

The reform also sends a strong message to the world, said .Fischler. "Our new policy is trade friendly. We are saying goodbye to the old subsidy system which significantly distorts international trade and harms developing countries. Today’s decision will give Europe a strong hand in the negotiations on the Doha Development Agenda."

The reform had aimed to eliminate trade-distorting measures so that the EU will be in a stronger position for the World Trade Organisation (WTO) negotiations in Cancun, Mexico in September.

So far, the EU’s agriculture subsidies have been widely seen as a block to progress.

The main elements of the proposed review include decoupling direct payment to farmers from production and making these conditional on compliance with environmental, food safety, animal welfare and occupational safety standards.

The CAP was first introduced to increase farm productivity, ensure a fair standard of living for the agricultural population and to stabilise markets.

Although spending on CAP has been reduced in recent years, it still consumes almost half the EU budget. Farm subsidies cost up to 44 billion euros (some 50 billion dollars) a year. Poor countries say that this leaves them unable to compete in the global market as they do not have such privileges.

The link between subsidies and output is blamed for huge overproduction by the EU farm market, which has resulted in subsidised products being dumped in developing countries for less than normal market price.

Campaigners on development issues say that the new deal is a blow to developing countries and will not stop poor farmers going out of business.

Non-governmental organisations (NGOs) argue the European Commission’s failure to secure a deal to cut the controversial link between subsidies and agricultural production (de-coupling) will harm the poor. Instead, EU farm ministers agreed to water down proposals to a partial de-coupling of the system.

Much of Africa and the developing world, say it is unfair to ask them to open their markets while the EU is protecting its own agriculture business.

Tim Rice, trade analyst for the charity ActionAid, which aims to reduce world poverty, said the latest proposals were unlikely to curb over-production in Europe.

"They allow rich countries to continue dumping agricultural produce, such as sugar and dairy, on developing countries putting poor farmers out of business," he said.

Tsigereda Walelign, a member of the Green Party at the European Parliament and adviser on ACP-EU relations, said that the review will harm ACP countries.

In her view, the Review has no positive impact on ACP for two reasons: The price for agricultural products has not been reduced because of pressure from France. The instrument of export subsidies has not been done away with.

"In the long run the decoupling measure will give an incentive to European farmers not to produce more and then may be less to export on the ACP market. But in the short term there is no great change to the present situation," she told IPS.

Julian Edwards Director-General of Consumer International, which supports, links and represents consumer groups and agencies all over the world, went a step further by saying that the review contradicts the EU commitment to development issues.

"The deal excludes agricultural products of specific interest to poor developing countries, many of whose farmers depend on these products for their livelihood," said Edwards.

"Discussions of reforms to cotton, where EU subsidies are already the highest in the world, and tobacco have been delayed, and sugar is not even mentioned. Lack of immediate action on these commodities so close to the WTO Cancun ministerial meeting this September flies in the face of the EU’s claim to support the (Doha) development round," he said.

Speaking for Oxfam Belgium, which campaigns against world poverty, Thierry Kesteloot told IPS that the core of the reform will be a disaster for the poor.

"It is difficult to see what poor countries will get out of the world trade talks in Cancun this September. Europe had the opportunity to take global leadership on making trade work for the poor, instead it has chosen to stick its head in the sand," he said.

In spite of harsh criticism from a large number of NGOs, the review has been met with a reserved welcome in certain areas.

The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), comprising western donor nations dedicated to fostering good governance, stated that the reforms could reduce European food prices in the long term but would not offer relief to farmers in Africa and Latin America who cannot compete with Europe’s subsidised exports.

Luis Portugal, an agriculture expert at the OECD, said: "This is a step in the right direction, but it’s a very small step."

A spokesman for the ACP Secretariat in Brussels backed this view as he told IPS: "Although we don’t have the details of the review, we believe it is going in the right direction. The EU subsidies affect competition between ACP countries and member states, but we do believe that it could help our countries."

"Although the process has taken a long time, we are not as extreme as some other groups. We are pleased that the review includes a range of cultural aspects too, such as ecology and heritage in our countries," he said.

Of the 79 ACP states, 40 are considered to be least developed countries (LDC), with low incomes and weak human resources. They are economically vulnerable and dependent on aid from the EU.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags