Europe, Headlines, Middle East & North Africa, North America

MIDEAST: EU Reluctant and Divided on Hamas Crackdown

Stefania Bianchi

BRUSSELS, Jun 26 2003 (IPS) - The U.S. appeal to the EU to cut off funding to the Palestinian militant group Hamas is unlikely to find an unequivocal echo within the European Union, which is divided on the issue.

At this week’s summit meeting between the U.S. and European leaders, aimed at improving relations, President George Bush said that the dismantling of groups such as Hamas would be the "true test" of the roadmap to peace in the Middle East.

"I urge the leaders in Europe and around the world to take swift, decisive action against terrorist groups such as Hamas, to cut off their funding and support, as the U.S. has done," he told the EU delegation headed by Commission President Romano Prodi and Greek Prime Minister Constantine Simitis, whose country holds the union’s rotating presidency.

The delegation included Javier Solana, High Representative for the EU’s Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP) and Trade Commissioner Pascal Lamy.

The meeting in Washington Wednesday was the first formal EU-U.S. summit since the Iraq war, which bitterly divided Washington and its European allies as France and Germany, two of the EU’s most powerful members, refused to back the U.S.-led invasion.

Although an extradition deal between the EU and the U.S. was signed at the summit, authorising the sharing of information and broadening the scope of crimes to which extradition would apply, continuing differences were apparent as President Bush pressed the EU to crack down on Hamas.

Hamas is the largest Palestinian militant Islamist organisation, formed fifteen years ago at the beginning of the first intifada, or Palestinian uprising against Israel’s occupation in the West Bank and Gaza.

Between 1994 and 2001, the EU gave 1.446 billion euros in aid to the Palestinians. EU member states supported the Palestinian Authority with an additional one billion euros.

The outlawing of Hamas would not only entail an assets-freeze and other measures to make life difficult for the organisation, but would also be a political blow, limiting their ability to take a formal role in further negotiations.

The U.S. has listed Hamas on the whole as a "foreign terrorist organisation" for many years, but the EU continues to distinguish between its military activities and its political and social role in the Palestinian territories.

The fissures within the 15-nation EU have been surfacing even before the EU-U.S. summit. Britain, for example, has already indicated that it supports Washington’s stance over Hamas, but faces strong opposition from France.

At a meeting in Luxembourg on June 17, British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw pressed his EU colleagues to outlaw the political wing if their attacks do not cease. However, French Foreign Minister Dominique de Villepin insisted that Hamas was a necessary player in the peace process.

Asked about differences within the European Union, a spokesperson for the EU, refused to indicate which member states were against the outlawing of Hamas and which were in favour.

"It is not up to the Commission to say anything. It is a Council list. All I will say is that there is a difference of opinion between the member states but I’m not going to give you a list. Most of the member states are in favour of adding Hamas to the terrorist list, but there is at least one large member state that isn’t," the spokesperson said. But refused to name the state.

Michael Emmerson, expert in EU foreign policy and Senior Research Fellow at the Centre for European Policy Studies, told IPS that the EU faces a "difficult decision". But it might be just the right one.

Emmerson said: "The EU is looking for ways to find areas of convergence with the U.S. to mend relations after the war in Iraq and so the outlawing of Hamas could provide it with a good opportunity to improve these relations. It also wants to show the world that the EU is not just a soft power and that it is hardening up at the edges."

A spokesperson for the European Commission insisted that the EU would not be railroaded into making a decision over Hamas.

"The EU has its own position on the situation in the Middle East and it is deeply engaged in the region. We condemn all forms of terrorism, including the killings in Israel. We share the U.S. condemnation of all forms of terrorism and firmly support the roadmap. We will work to put pressure on those who prevent it," the spokesperson told IPS.

"There is an active debate within Europe about the most useful way of applying pressure. All tactics will be considered and we will decide according to what is happening on the ground. Although there have been tense moments between the EU and U.S. over the war in Iraq there is still a good relationship between the two. The test is not if you disagree but whether you can resolve problems;" the spokesperson said.

The EU-U.S. Summit Wednesday came on the heels of a meeting between EU leaders in Thessaloniki, Greece June 19-20, where the EU made its position clear on Hamas’ activities.

A statement by European leaders there urged Hamas and other groups to "declare a ceasefire and halt all terrorist activity". It also indicated that the European Council, made up of leaders from member states, is urgently examining the case for wider action against Hamas fund raising.

This view was also supported when Solana and Chris Patten, EU Commissioner for External Relations, addressed members of the European Parliament on June 18.

Both said that the EU could not afford losing the opportunity for peace created by the international peace agreement and urged the European Union to step up its efforts to bring peace and stability to the region.

"First we ought to continue supporting Palestinian institution-building and reform, as we have already done with a successful record in the past," Patten said.

"Secondly, we should contribute to the roadmap’s monitoring process, put pressure on Arab States to help dry up funds to extremist groups, and to close their offices, put pressure on Israel to moderate its responses to the atrocious suicide bombings which many Arab leaders have themselves condemned," he continued.

Solana insisted that U.S. involvement in the roadmap to peace was essential. "Without this (U.S. participation), our hopes of peace would have been more limited like they have been before. Together we can achieve a lot more and these must be our efforts in the coming days," he said.

The roadmap, drafted by the U.S., the EU, Russia, and the United Nations envisions the creation of a Palestinian state and security guarantees for Israel by 2005.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags