Sunday, November 22, 2026
Akhilesh Upadhyay
- Nepalis have been getting an unpleasant reminder about the plight of Nepalis in the British Army, the famed Gurkhas, given the anger here over ‘insulting’ comments by the British envoy recently.
In the last few weeks, activists and media in this Himalayan kingdom have been expressing solidarity and support for the Gurkhas, who say British officials have once again dismissed their claims to pension parity with disdain – an act vilified here as a rude slap to the troops’ unwavering service for Britain.
British Ambassador to Nepal Keith Bloomfield kicked up a huge controversy here this month when he compared the British Gurkhas’ earnings to that of the Nepalese prime minister, as he defended the Oct. 8 court ruling in London against the Gurkhas’ pension demand.
Nepal’s head of government makes 13,000 rupees less than a retired Gurkha captain, Bloomsfield pointed out. The row that followed was pure mayhem.
On average, a British soldier makes seven times more than the Gurkhas upon retirement – 625 pounds against 91 pounds, according to retired Gurkhas here.
Gurkha veterans and civil society leaders have lambasted the British envoy for his "undiplomatic remarks," calling his comments high-handed and humiliating, not to mention an affront to Nepalese self-esteem and sovereignty.
A World War II veteran, Maj Trilok Thapa, said it was the most humiliating experience, worse than how he ever felt, in his 33 years of service for the British Army. "The British are taking advantage of our poverty and political instability and are using derogatory language against us," he says.
"British envoy’s comments unbecoming of his diplomatic office" said a front-page headline in Nepal’s most widely read newspaper, ‘Kantipur’, which also editorialised the controversy.
"We cannot deny the fact that the money earned by Nepali citizens employed in the Indian and British armies helps Nepali economy," the paper wrote. "But we are paying a heavy price for the ‘help’ in term of its cost on our national dignity and integrity."
Argued the English-language daily ‘Kathmandu Post’, "àno one buys the self-serving British argument for pension disparity based on cost of living and nationality”.
The paper pointed out that foreign nationals serving in the U.S. military are entitled to the same pension and pay package as their U.S. counterparts.
"The United Nations does not pay less pension to its Nepali employees simply because cost of living is lower in Nepal than in New York. Nor would (Secretary General) Kofi Annan accept his pension based on (native) Ghana’s living standard,” it continued. In truth, say retired Gurkhas here, Britain is dodging the core issue – that it has a discriminatory two-tier pay structure in the army.
The Gurkha recruitment started in the early 19th century, peaking during the First and Second World Wars, when tens of thousands of poor and mostly illiterate Nepalis who had never been outside their mountain homes fought under British generals in faraway battlefields.
By the late 1940s, the legend of the Gurkhas had been firmly anchored in western minds. The short and sturdy mountain people were widely known for their unique battlefield exploits – they were indefatigable, tough, and above all, extremely loyal to their commanders.
Decades later, the loyal soldiers are asking their paymasters that they might just as well pay them well, and on par with other troops, for their sterling service. There are currently more than 3,000 Nepalis in the British Army, but tens and thousands more are in the pension roll.
In quashing the claims by seven Gurkhas that they be paid pension and other facilities at par with their British counterparts, the Court of Appeals in London said that the retired Gurkhas are well covered by their pension package given Nepal’s low cost of living.
"The Court found that the Gurkhas were not in an analogous position to British soldiers and therefore it was not discrimination to pay less to the Gurkhas," the court’s verdict said.
The Gurkha Army Ex-Servicemen Organisation (GAESO), which has led the campaign for pension parity, says the court ruling was "unfair”. "We will pursue a fresh trial all over again," says Krishna Kumar Rai, GAESO vice president. "We didn’t have a strong case due to the lack of related documents, which have now been provided to us by (British) Ministry of Defence. The trial was more of a test case for us."
Still, GAESO lawyer Gopal Siwakoti Chintan considers the recent revision of the Gurkha case by the Defence Ministry an achievement in itself, though he was obviously looking for a lot more.
"But the discriminatory provisions in the British army have hardly ended,” he said. ”We are going to file new cases demanding clarification on whether it would be fair to adopt two separate pension schemes within a service." While the Gurkhas lost the case primarily on two grounds – that they were recruited in Nepal and retired only upon their arrival in Nepal – officials with GAESO argue such "technical" claims hardly mask the underlying philosophy behind their years-long movement in the demand for fair play.
"The British Ambassador’s arguments are extremely humiliating," says GAESO’s Rai. "Why does a simple ambassador cite a sovereign nation’s prime minister’s earnings to make his point? We are poor. That’s why? It’s just ridiculous, and I hope our Foreign Ministry officials rebuke the British ambassador officially. "