Sunday, November 22, 2026
Commentary - By M B Naqvi
- Iran’s disclosure that Pakistani scientists and middlemen helped it acquire nuclear technology has more or less confirmed the persistent leaks by western intelligence agencies that some Pakistanis, if not their government, have been engaged in nuclear proliferation.
The Pakistan government also recently admitted that some rogue scientists may have done so for personal profit.
A probe is underway into 13 top nuclear scientists, engineers and administrators to see what their participation in this export of nuclear technology, and results are expected in a week.
The U.S. Central Intelligence Agency had earlier inspired stories about a nuclear technology-for-missiles deal with North Korea. It also mentioned that Dr Abdul Qadeer Khan, acclaimed father of the Pakistani Bomb, had visited Pyongyang 17 times over a fairly short period and that U.S. satellites had photographed Pakistani aircraft being loaded with missile components.
There was also a mysterious disclaimer recently by Col Muammar Khadafy’s son about his having earlier accused Pakistanis helping his country’s nuclear programme. Other stories linked Pakistanis to Iraq and Syria’s putative programmes.
The Iranian revelation has been a direct hit at Pakistan’s security establishment that is led by, and works under the supervision of, the Pakistan Army. It has been panic-stricken ever since.
Not that Iran was the first to link Pakistan with proliferation. The U.S. government was the first to link two senior Pakistani scientists of Pakistan’s Atomic Energy Commission with trying to teach Taliban officials about nuclear weapons, probably how to fabricate crude or dirty nuclear explosive devices.
Apparently the U.S. war and victory in Afghanistan were too swift for both the teachers and pupils.
But U.S. officials did query the Pakistan government at least in 2002, if not earlier. Pakistan investigators visited Iran and Libya late last year to investigate allegations that Pakistan scientists sold nuclear secrets to the so-called "rogue states," Information Minister Sheikh Rashid Ahmad was quoted as saying Thursday.
The Pakistan government arrested two scientists who had to undergo interrogation over several months. Their interrogators were mainly U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigaton and CIA agents, though Pakistani intelligence provided for the affair as theirs.
Despite grounds for suspicion, their claim of being associated only with social welfare work in Afghanistan apparently satisfied the questioners.
Or perhaps the U.S. government did not wish to take the matter to its logical conclusion because the Pakistan government was playing a satisfactorily active role in the U.S. ‘war on terror’.
There is a disturbing circumstance for Pakistanis: whenever and wherever a suspected Islamic terrorist is arrested, Pakistan’s name is apt to come up: he has either been trained by Pakistanis in Afghanistan or was in Pakistan or had some links with Pakistan.
The Pakistan government takes pride in having arrested hundreds of al-Qaeda activists. The U.S. officials are pleased and do not tire of praising the cooperation they are receiving from Gen Pervez Musharraf and his regime.
But Pakistan itself is crowded with the supporters and protectors of al-Qaeda. At the grassroots, Pakistan is the most anti-U.S. country.
Until Sep. 11, the Musharraf-led army was the main protector of the Taliban regime, which had hosted Osama bin Laden and his al-Qaeda.
The Pakistan army, the United States is known to believe, has many Islamic extremists – supporters of the Taliban and their allies, the al-Qaeda. They fear that there may be factions among them that may still be sponsoring or inspiring nuclear proliferation activities by Islamists in the nuclear research community.
But all that had remained conjectural or partly known phenomenon. Islamabad has denied all claims of Pakistan having a link with nuclear proliferation activities.
In most cases, that was the end of the matter. Not so after Iran’s official claim. The Pakistani security establishment quickly rounded up eight – the number is actually uncertain – persons working in the famous A Q Khan Laboratories at Kahuta on the outskirts of Islamabad for investigation.
This time round Islamabad is using a more sophisticated term for the arrests: it says they have been picked up for "debriefing".
Iranian officials cleared the Pakistani government the other day and emphasised that Iran received help from certain individuals and middlemen. The government’s anxiety to clear its own name quickly by blaming some individual scientists is understandable.
But that has shocked many more people than merely the relatives and supporters of the arrested scientists. The noisy pro-Bomb lobby is furious.
Many have written in the press that the idea of some rogue scientists doing this is hard to believe: each of such scientists or engineers had layers of military security. It is inconceivable that the authorities would not know of their goings and comings.
For any government to deal with a foreign individual on so sensitive an issue should normally require credible identifiers and all-round guarantees of secrecy.
Not unnaturally, the Musharraf regime has come under attack. A former Cabinet minister, Ishaq Dar, has accused ex-army chief Gen Mirza Aslam Beg of having proposed a 12 billion dollar deal with Iran for helping its nuclear programme.
The innuendo was that Beg, as the sole controller of Pakistan’s nuclear programme, might have actually authorised the "rogue" scientists to do the needful.
One circumstance supports conspiracy theories: Anti-nuclear activist Rahat Saeed, the editor of a prestigious Urdu literary magazine, pointed out that during the 30 or more active years of Pakistan’s atomic programme, Pakistan has not officially – mentioned in the budget – spent a penny on what is now a proper nuclear deterrent with a modern command and control system.
It must have cost a lot of money to develop it. Despite Dr A Q Khan’s theft of the drawings of a centrifuge, its manufacture in required numbers – or purchase from international black market – for a poor underdeveloped country must have required billions of dollars. Where did they come from?
Anyhow, the Musharraf regime is now wading through a storm of criticism.
Official propaganda had held up Pakistani nuclear scientists and engineers to be first rate and have done Pakistan proud. The Pakistani Bomb has come to be a symbol of national achievement and guarantee its greatness, at least in the Islamic world.
Pakistan’s right wing, including religious extremists, have venerated these scientists, especially Dr Khan. Now the rulers, in fear of eventually earning the ire of U.S. administration, are treating these national heroes like common criminals.
A backlash is building up in circles that are historically pro-military and have supported all authoritarian regimes. But those who never found the nuclear weapons to be appropriate or acceptable for Pakistan are merely bemused.