Europe, Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

POLITICS-TURKEY: Too Islamic for EU?

Hilmi Toros

ISTANBUL, Jan 19 2004 (IPS) - President of the European Commission Romano Prodi says Turkey is “closer than ever” to membership of the European Union. But it is not there yet, and it is not certain that it ever will be.

“Turkey will bring sunshine, not rain” to the European Union (EU), Prodi said on a visit to Turkey last week. This was the first high-profile visit to Turkey in relation to its position as candidate country. The European Commission (EC) is the executive arm of the EU.

Prodi said Turkish reforms to meet the so-called Copenhagen criteria for EU membership were “impressive” and their speed “remarkable”. But he said the criteria had not been met fully in the field of human rights, and in relation to the military.

The criteria are a broad set of measures all potential EU members must adopt on democracy, the rule of law and in human rights. Turkey says it has legislated on all these. The EU says they must also be implemented.

The military’s role in politics has been reduced on paper, and the National Security Council dominated by the military is now an advisory body. But the general staff of this once all-powerful body still expresses its views freely, even on matters such as education.

Differences between EU norms and Turkish traditions in the field of human rights surfaced during Prodi’s visit. A security court ruled that Leyla Zana, a Kurd and former member of parliament, and her three colleagues will remain behind bars during a re-trial. Turkey accepted a second trial after the European Court ruled that the accused had not received fair trial the first time.

Zana was sentenced to 15 years in prison ten years ago after she added words in Kurdish to the oath of office taken in Turkish. On EU prodding the Turkish parliament has adopted legislation allowing education and broadcast in languages other than Turkish, including Kurdish. This has yet to be implemented.

But Prodi acknowledged that obstacles to Turkey’s membership of the EU may lie more in the EU than in Turkey. He told the Turkish parliament that there was no consensus on Turkey’s membership among the European public, and that leaders on all sides should address this “political reality”.

Officially, Turkey only needs to meet the criteria. But far from joining the club, Turkey does not have even a date to begin accession talks.

Why, Turks often ask. Is the EU looking for reasons to exclude Turkey?

Doubts soared when the EU raised settlement of the Cyprus impasse as an “important” political consideration for Turkey to satisfy the EU. Cyprus has been divided between Greek and Turk residents since 1974 when Turkey took over a third of the island to the north following a Greek-inspired coup to unite the island with Greece.

From May 1 the internationally recognised Greek south will become a full EU member taken to represent the entire island. The status of the Turkish north will be in limbo unless the two parts can be united by then. But a resolution on Cyprus is no technical requirement for Turkey to qualify.

Turks point out also that if Turkey is not in Europe geographically, Cyprus is further east and closer to Beirut than the bustling Istanbul.

Some European leaders may consider Turkey too big for the EU to swallow. “It’s not Malta,” Prodi had remarked. Malta will be among the ten new EU members as of May this year.

Turkey has a population of 70 million and is set to overtake the most populous member Germany, currently with a population of about 82 million. If the Turkish labour force could move freely given EU membership, it could swamp countries with small populations such as Denmark. Turkey says its workers may be needed in an ageing EU population.

More than 75 percent of Turks say they want to be a part of EU. The one question they asked at the inauguration of the EU information centre at Istanbul’s main Taksim Square last week was whether they would get a job in the EU.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan says Turkey’s membership would enrich the EU if it is to become a global player rather than a “Christian club”. Inclusion of Turkey would knock the theory of the clash of civilisations and set an example of peaceful co-existence between Christianity and Islam in turbulent times, he said.

Commentator Mehmet Ali Birand says that if the EU turns down Turkey now despite the reforms it has undertaken, most people will believe this was because Turkey is a Muslim country. Fundamentalists within the ruling Justice and Development Party with its Islamic roots would be strengthened, he said.

But Turkey sees itself as a part of Europe, if not the EU. It signed a customs union agreement with the EU in 1995. As member of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) it was considered a Western – and European – bastion against communism and the Soviet Union during the Cold War.

Turkish soccer teams participate in European competitions. Turkish singer Sertab Erener won the Eurovision song contest last year for “Every way that I can”.

The ‘vision question’ for both EU and Turkey is likely come to a head at a summit this December. That meeting is likely to determine whether Turkey will eventually join the club, or like Istanbul’s meandering Bosphorus Straits continue a part of both East and West, not belonging fully to either.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags