Sunday, November 22, 2026
Supratim Mukherjee
- The discovery of a giant offshore gas field in north-west Burma’s Arakan state has generated tremendous excitement in the corridors of power in that country and in neighbouring India – but critics say there is little for residents to rejoice over.
The discovery of a giant offshore gas field in north-west Burma’s Arakan state has generated tremendous excitement in the corridors of power in that country and in neighbouring India – but critics say there is little for residents to rejoice over.
In fact, critics fear that they have nothing to gain from the discovery and oppose plans to export the gas to Burma’s neighbours, India to the west and Thailand to the east. In November, a consortium of Korean and Indian companies including Daewoo International Corp, Korea Gas Corp and the Indian public sector firms Oil and Natural Gas Commission Videsh Ltd and Gas Authority of India Ltd started exploring the offshore waters in the Arakan coast. Termed the Shwe Prospect (‘shwe’ means gold in Burma), the exploratory well successfully penetrated thick gas sand and produced gas at a rate of 32 million cubic feet per day by drill stem test.
But critics say that whether the deal being pursued by the Burmese military government, which calls itself the State Peace and Development Council, will improve the lives of locals is doubtful.
"This is the largest non-renewable natural resource of Burma but the junta has disregarded the rights of the local people,” Kyaw Han, a member of the Anti-Gas Export Committee, told IPS.
Neither at a state level nor at a national level has there been any debate over whether this gas should be sold for cash or utilised to generate electricity and develop local industries. ”This is blatant violation of human rights by the military dictatorship," he added.
Most Arakanese villages, like many other on the western frontiers of Burma, suffer from lack of electricity. Even Arakan’s capital city, Sittwe, is dependent on diesel generators for electricity, available only after the sun sets. This electricity is rationed by the SPDC.
South Korea’s Daewoo International Corp has a 60 percent stake in the business and Korea Gas Corp holds another 10 percent of the share. India’s ONGC and GAIL together own 30 percent. But Myanmar Oil and Gas Enterprise (MOGE), 100 percent owned by the junta, will have the rights to enjoy the proportionate share of the benefits.
MOGE has an August 2000 agreement with Daewoo to explore the Arakan coast under a production-sharing contract. According to ONGC sources, a large three-dimensional seismic survey in March and April this year will be followed by intensive appraisal drilling in November, after the monsoon season.
The estimated recoverable reserve of the gas find in question is in the range of four to six trillion cubic feet of gas – equivalent to seven hundred million to one thousand hundred million barrels of oil.
It has also been accompanied with a blueprint that suggests that the gas will be brought into India through a pipeline from Kyauktaw-Paltwa in northern Arakan, then going westward via India’s north-eastern state of Mizoram to Assam. Another possibility, which sources in ONGC say is being drawn up by Trans-Canadian Pipelines, is to lay an inter-country pipeline from Arakan via Chittagong in Bangladesh to West Bengal state.
Indian Petroleum secretary B K Chaturvedi said that GAIL will carry out a feasibility study of a pipeline. Both the options of an undersea link connecting the Burma gas fields to the east coast and an overland line through Bangladesh into north-east India or West Bengal will be studied. The feasibility report will be ready by June.
The Anti-Gas Export Committee believes that the benefits of the gas deal would go to the military government, not to ordinary citizens. "The hard cash that will come from this deal will be used to buy more weapons that will be used to suppress the pro-democracy supporters," says Kyaw Han. According to the International Institute for Strategic Studies, the junta’s military expenditures account for over 40 percent of national budget while Burma’s health and education spending is 0.4 percent and 0.5 percent respectively.
Dissidents like Ko Khaing Zaw of the All Arakan Students and Youths Congress say that the project might follow the footsteps of the "infamous Yadana/Yetagun natural gas project" – which began exporting gas to Thailand in 1998 from the Andaman Sea via Burma’s eastern Mon state. The Yadana/Yetagun project, mired in controversies that included the use of slave labour during the laying of the pipeline, is now in the midst of court cases examining the complicity in human rights abuses of the U.S. oil major UNOCAL.
"Communities were forcibly relocated, their lands confiscated, and they suffered rape, torture and extrajudicial killing at the hands of the junta’s soldiers to make the project a success," said Ko Khaing Zaw.
The director-general of energy planning department in Burma’s ministry of energy, Soe Myint, has indicated a price of around 4.5 per million dollars British Thermal Units for selling gas to India from its offshore fields.
Soe Myint clarified that this would not be the delivered price, but the price of gas at the landfall point, to which transportation costs would be added.
But Ko Khaing Zaw, also the convenor of the Anti-Gas Exports Committee, said the military has already started "forcibly relocating villages to create a pipeline corridor”.
"To start survey work, the military is already using forced labour in the construction of service roads and helipads, as well as their own camps and barracks," he added.
Though Indian companies have till now avoided any comments on the alleged human rights violations in the project, high-level sources in GAIL said that "the issue can create a lot of international outcry and that is why the conglomerate is taking steps very carefully”.
"We have already told the Burmese government that we will not tolerate any forced labour and will also speak to the locals if they have any complaints," the top official in New Delhi said in an interview.
But the Burmese dissidents say that Indian and Thai leaders are getting closer to the junta "just because of demands of natural gas”.
Burma exports gas to Thailand at around 4.26 per million British Thermal Units from the offshore fields – Yadana and Yetagung, located in the southern and south-eastern offshore areas. Despite the odd noises made by Defence Minister George Fernandes, about the junta in Rangoon, oil has kept the diplomatic wheel spinning smoothly between India and Burma.
As part of the negotiations to buy natural gas, the Burmese junta has been demanding political concessions from Thailand and India in the form of expulsion of Burmese refugees and crackdowns on opposition groups staying in these countries.
No contract details have been released, but the Arakan Gas Project is poised to generate between 800 million dollars to over 3 billion dollars in annual revenues for Burma’s government.
Supratim Mukherjee
- The discovery of a giant offshore gas field in north-west Burma’s Arakan state has generated tremendous excitement in the corridors of power in that country and in neighbouring India – but critics say there is little for residents to rejoice over.
(more…)