Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, North America, Poverty & SDGs

POLITICS: U.N. Agency Breaks New Ground with Turkish Head

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, May 5 2005 (IPS) - The 191-nation U.N. General Assembly unanimously approved Thursday a Turkish national to head the U.N. Development Programme (UNDP), breaking a more than 50-year-old tradition of giving the job only to U.S. and British nationals.

The appointment of Kemal Dervis, a former Turkish finance minister and vice president of the World Bank, ”is a positive signal of change in the United Nations,” said Carmen Ambassador Maria Gallardo Hernandez of El Salvador, currently president of UNDP’s executive board.

”While we are actively involved in consultations towards a more democratic, transparent and accountable organisation, this event provides us great hopes for the future,” she added.

Dervis becomes the first UNDP head from a country that receives development assistance.

The customary tradition in the U.N. system is that most decision-making jobs in development agencies – specifically heads, deputy heads and directors – are earmarked for the United States, Britain, Japan, the Netherlands, Norway, Denmark and Sweden – the top seven donor nations.

The argument was that only nationals of donor countries could help raise money to sustain agencies such as UNDP, the U.N. Children’s Fund (UNICEF), and the World Food Programme (WFP), all of which depend exclusively on voluntary contributions for their survival.


Until recently, decisions on all donor-driven senior U.N. appointments were made mostly behind closed doors. But last month, U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan introduced a radical change, calling for applicants from member states for four senior appointments: the heads of UNDP, the U.N.’s Office of Internal Oversight Services (OIOS), Office of the High Commissioner for Refugees, and Office of the U.N. Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) for Palestine Refugees.

”The lack of transparency in U.N. appointments in the past covered up a variety of problems including the consequences of powerful countries insisting that one of their own citizens be appointed to various positions,” said Phyllis Bennis, senior fellow at the Washington-based think tank Institute for Policy Studies.

The United States, by arrogating unto itself the right to place its citizens as heads of UNICEF, the UN’s comptroller’s office, and the WFP, and in numerous powerful but less visible positions, has been ”the worst abuser,” she told IPS.

Since the creation of UNICEF in 1947, the post of executive director has been held only by U.S. nationals: Maurice Pate, Henry Labouisse, James Grant, Carol Bellamy and, as of Monday, Anne Veneman, the former U.S. agriculture secretary under President George W. Bush.

The job of UNDP Administrator has rotated among Britons and U.S. citizens since the New York-based agency was created in 1950: Paul Hoffman (U.S.), David Owen (Britain), Rudolph Petersen (U.S.), Bradford Morse (U.S.), William Draper (U.S.), Gus Speth (U.S.) and the outgoing chief, Mark Malloch Brown (Britain).

Bennis said that Annan’s efforts to impose a new transparent, more international process for selecting U.N. personnel are long overdue and indicate an important new direction.

”But it is unclear so far how real is the claimed commitment to such transparency. Specifically, asking member states to nominate candidates for senior positions is an important advance. But such an effort does not alone ensure breadth, honesty, and transparency in the appointment process,” she added.

Bennis said the recent request to member states to nominate candidates to replace Peter Hansen, longtime chief of UNRWA, does nothing to guarantee that a U.S.- or perhaps British- nominated candidate will not be automatically chosen.

”Further, it does nothing to prevent the kind of heavy-handed U.S.-imposed control over U.N. personnel issues that ensured that Hansen was not re-appointed in the first place,” she added.

Asked whether Hansen, a longtime critic of Israeli policies in the occupied territories of the West Bank and Gaza, was not being reappointed because of U.S. and Israeli pressure, U.N. associate spokesman Stephane Dujarric told reporters that since Hansen had served for nine years on the job, Annan felt ”it’s time for a change and he is looking for candidates.”

In an interview with a British newspaper, Hansen was quoted as saying: ”I was willing to stay. There are certain facts about the views of certain groups in the U.S. and Israel about how I have carried out my functions and those groups influenced the decision not to reappoint me.”

Don Kraus, executive vice president of the Washington-based advocacy group Citizens for Global Solutions, told IPS that the United Nations ”should be recruiting the best and brightest to fill very demanding positions that require U.N. officials to be sensitive to politics but also see beyond the specific interests of member states to develop solutions for the betterment of the world at large.”

However, member states too have a responsibility, he said. ”They cannot expect to pursue their own interests at the expense of the United Nations.”

Rather, he urged U.N. members to support Annan’s recent far-reaching proposals on restructuring the world body and to show their willingness to implement them, including those promoting transparency in U.N. appointments.

”This is a major first step towards substantial reform at the United Nations. If the opportunity is missed now, we may not have another for a further 50 years,” he added.

Joan Russow of the Canada-based Global Compliance Research Institute, which monitors the United Nations, says there are fundamental systemic constraints preventing the selection of the best candidates for appointments to the United Nations.

”These systemic constraints have to be overcome if appointments to the United Nations are to adhere to the principles of transparency and fairness,” she told IPS.

Russow said the term ”transparency” has been presented more in rhetoric than in action. Clear criteria for what constitutes transparency have to be in place both at the national and international levels, she added.

”The submissions of nominations for positions by member states often tend to reflect political expedience and state interests rather than a commitment to advancing the purposes of the United Nations,” she said.

Russow also said that the selection of candidates at the United Nations often results in the default process of the lowest common denominator.

”States ignore merit, qualification and relevant experience, and for political reasons, opt for the candidates they want less to prevent the ones they want least from being selected,” she said.

Also to be decided is the fate of a proposal to impose term limits on all senior U.N. appointments, including that of secretary-general.

Currently, most under-secretaries-general, the third ranking job in the U.N. system, serve only for two terms or 10 years, though their tenure depends on the pleasure of the secretary-general.

Bennis said identifying the world’s best women and men available for top U.N. positions, including that of secretary-general, is at best an enormous challenge.

”So far the methods for choosing the secretary-general, as well as other posts, have been made up of a combination of regional claims, diplomatic who-knows-who arrangements, blind luck, and a big dose of big-power oversight. But that has to change,” she said.

Imposing term limits may provide one small step in the long process of de-politicising U.N. secretariat appointments, Bennis added.

The General Assembly also confirmed the appointment of the new head of the Office for Internal Oversight Services (OIOS), Inga-Britt Ahlenius of Sweden, currently auditor-general of Kosovo and previously the auditor-general in her home country.

 
Republish | | Print |