Friday, March 29, 2024
Ann Ninan
The former United States president heaped lavish praise on the prompt and efficient management in the aftermath of one of the world’s worst natural disasters. “I want to figure out how we can take this model to other places in the world for speedy implementation and make it part of the U.N. strategy for disaster management,” he said.
The Cuddalore model could have suited the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, about 1,200 km from the east coast of mainland India, where even two years later tsunami survivors still live in temporary shelters, frustrated by official indifference to their plight..
On Nov. 16, 2,000 women and men in Little Andaman, the fourth largest of the 38-island group, peacefully protesting the slow pace of rehabilitation and livelihood restoration and demanding they should be consulted, were beaten up by the police.
Unlike on the mainland where the government devised a policy framework, defined the objectives, provided a direction for structuring the response and outlined broad delivery mechanisms for achieving the same, this does not seem to have happened in the Andamans, said Anupama Muhuri of ActionAid India who is working there.
Tired of simply waiting for officials to keep their promises, tsunami survivors of Netaji Nagar and Hut Bay, the main town which was completely destroyed, held separate meetings at the end of October to voice their concerns, and submitted a memorandum to the district administration.
When the government did not respond, a public meeting was held in front of the revenue office. More than 1,000 people participated. And a second memorandum was given to top officials, with a warning that if no action was taken in the next five days, people would go on hunger strike from Nov. 15.
Again the government failed to take notice: some 2,500 people gathered in front of the administrative office for a hunger strike. People wanted government officials to dialogue with them, but they responded by declaring the protest illegal, and began arresting the participants.
Soon there was complete chaos, with the police baton-charging the crowd on the claim that someone had hurled a bottle inside the police station. Nearly 200 people were injured, and several had to be hospitalised. Late that night, the police entered the hospital, and further abused the injured protestors.
“People’s voices were quashed in a brutal manner,” ActionAid said in a statement. “But when all the voices unite, it just cannot be ignored and silenced, however mighty the people on the other side are,” the activist group warned.
A fact-finding mission to the tsunami-affected areas of the archipelago in February 2006 reported the survivors are “frustrated, depressed and angry.” “There is a pervading sense of neglect and betrayal, and a feeling of fatigue as patience and endurance levels are repeatedly tested and tried,” according to their report.
A strong indictment of the humanitarian organisations, experts in disaster management, an administration with sufficient resources, the report by the Housing and Land Rights Network’s South Asia Regional Programme (HLRN-SARP) and HAQ-Centre for Child Rights said there are serious issues that need urgent attention.
People have been forced into box-like tin structures – unbearable in the tropical heat. There is an acute drinking water shortage, abysmal sanitation, no privacy for women and girls, particularly. Worse, even information regarding rehabilitation and permanent housing is not easily available.
Survivors have not been consulted and have been forced to settle in areas predetermined by the administration. Their right to humanitarian relief and rehabilitation has been ignored.
Residents of Padauk Tikree, Little Andaman, have repeatedly demanded a road to the shelter. In February, it was still incomplete and difficult to navigate. The nearest bus stop was half a km away. People had to walk up a steep incline to the camp, especially difficult when they were carrying heavy loads.
Lack of planning was evident in everything from the poor location of toilets to the inappropriate position of drains – not directly under the tin-roofs, so the rain water had no avenue to drain off, and would still collect in front of homes.
S. Narayanamma, a woman in her sixties at the Padauk Tikree shelter, was quoted in the report: “The toilets are very far. It is extremely difficult for us women to access and use them. It’s a long walk away. The path is rocky and steep. There is no water. At night, especially, it is very difficult.” Lack of privacy has forced some families to send their grown up daughters to distant relatives in the capital, Port Blair.
For these victims of the tsunami, still waiting for relief in the Andaman and Nicobar islands, just 150 km from the epicentre of the earthquake, the trauma of Dec. 24, 2004, continues.