Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS-AUSTRALIA: Anti-Terror Law Draconian – Former Chief Justice

Kalinga Seneviratne

MELBOURNE, Jul 11 2007 (IPS) - As a magistrate extended for the third time the period an India-born Muslim doctor could be held in custody over suspected links to the terror plot in Britain a former chief justice of the Australian High Court slammed the country’s anti-terrorism laws as draconian and threatening civil liberties.

Mohammed Haneef, 29, who was working in a hospital in Queensland state, where about a half of the doctors serving in government hospitals and rural health centres are from overseas, was held on suspicion of having had phone contact with one of the suspects held in Britain for last month’s failed terror attacks there.

A Brisbane magistrate on Monday allowed an application by the police to extend Haneef’s detention for a further 48 hours until Thursday evening. Meanwhile the Police Commissioner Mick Kelty said on Tuesday that the police will ask a magistrate for further extension of time if necessary.

A detective from Scotland Yard&#39s Counter-Terrorism Command, arrived in Australia on Thursday to question him about communications the suspects in Britain had with a source outside the UK. They are trying to find out whether Haneef is that source.

The media here reported, quoting family sources in Bangalore, India that Haneef has not been allowed to contact any of his family members since he was arrested last Wednesday. They believe that he is innocent and has no links to terrorists.

Haneef&#39s lawyer Peter Russo said in a media interview earlier this week that his client is being denied natural justice under the Anti-Terrorism Act. "Even people charged with serious offences have the right to make a bail application – there is no provision within the Act for similar applications to be made," Russo told ABC Radio.


"There&#39s no sort of safety net, there&#39s no way of the system being balanced for our client to be accorded any sort of rights or natural justice that we are all entitled to receive under our system," he said adding that neither he nor his client have been told by the police why they were detaining him or had sought extra detention time.

Speaking at a law conference in Sydney last week, Australia’s former top judge Gerard Brennan said that he is troubled by Australia&#39s anti-terrorism laws, because they impair the freedoms and immunities that common law protects, and that they may be seen as targeting Muslims.

"This threat (of terrorism) is facilitating intolerance towards and suspicion of peace-loving Muslim citizens, and some of the rhetoric surrounding the anti-terrorism legislation is fanning that intolerance and suspicion," noted Brennan, who was the Chief Justice from 1995-98.

He expressed concern about the key definition of a "terrorist act" in the anti-terrorism legislation. "It contains a curious element: a specific intention which is really a motive" he said, adding "an act is not a terrorist act unless it is engaged in with the intention of advancing a political, religious or ideological cause".

Brennan believes the motivational elements in the anti-terrorism law here opens itself to suspicion that the law is designed to target an entire group of people – those who wish to advance the religious cause of Islam. "A law which leaves itself open to such an interpretation fosters dissent," he warned.

The anti-terror legislation originally passed in 2002 allows a person to be kept in detention for up to a week and subjected to questioning for periods of eight hours or more at a time. There is an obligation to answer the questions.

Kelty, told ABC Radio last week, after Haneef’s arrest, that this questioning could continue for a 24 hour period which includes "dead time". In other words, they can question somebody for four hours and then have eight hours off and then come back. So they can stretch the 24 hours over several days.

"The questioning may be designed to obtain information that might be quite remote from any terrorism offence," observed Brennan. "ASIO (Australian Security Intelligence Organisation) can secure the detention and questioning of a person in the hope of obtaining that kind of assistance. This is a remarkable infringement on a person&#39s common law rights, especially when the person is not a suspect and may not be even a sympathiser of terrorism".

"Anti-terror legislation is a terror legislation. It will inevitably curtail the civil rights of Australians," John Tebbutt, a spokesperson for the Civil Rights Defence Committee told IPS.

Tebutt said that at the moment in a Melbourne detention centre there are 13 Muslim men held in shackles who have not faced any charges in courts. "But we know under terror legislation one of three charges will be having been in possession of a ‘thing’. It can mean anything associated with terrorist activity as deemed by the authorities such as a computer or a car. It’s very vague and open to abuse," added Tebbutt.

Under section 101.4 of the ‘Security Legislation Amendment Bill 2002’ which amended the Criminal Code 1995 to include certain terrorist acts, it is an offence to possess a "thing" that is "connected with preparation for, the engagement of a person in, or assistance in a terrorist act". The "thing" is not defined in the dictionary of the Act. Section 101.4(5) provides that no offence is committed if possession of the ‘thing’ was not ‘intended to facilitate preparation for, the engagement of a person in, or assistance in a terrorist act’. However the defendant bears an evidential burden in relation to proving his/her lack of intention.

Provisions in the anti-terror laws also disallow the media discussing the pros and cons of someone detained under the act.

"Anti-terror laws have a freezing effect on media generally," argues Tebbutt who is a senior lecturer in media studies here. "It is an offence to reveal or discuss charges laid against someone, unless the police announce it to the media.’’

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags