Saturday, November 21, 2026
Bob Burton
- The Australian government’s plans to abolish the elected Aboriginal peak body, called the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission (ATSIC), has angered the indigenous community and revived accusations about Australia’s insensitivity to its concerns.
Since November, Prime Minister John Howard and Minister for Aboriginal Affairs Sen Amanda Vanstone have been pondering how to respond to a major review of the commission, which was first established in 1990 as a form of Aboriginal self-government.
The review, while critical of ATSIC, stressed the need to retain a representative body.
On late Thursday, Howard strode to a lectern in a parliamentary courtyard set up for one of his rare media conferences, and announced he had decided to go further than the review’s recommendation.
“We can announce that when Parliament resumes in May, we will introduce legislation to abolish ATSIC,” Howard said.
Howard bluntly pronounced that the experiment with democratic representation for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders was over.
“We believe very strongly that the experiment in separate representation, elected representation, for indigenous people has been a failure. We will not replace ATSIC with an alternative body. We will appoint a group of distinguished indigenous people to advise the government on a purely advisory basis in relation to aboriginal affairs,” he said.
Howard said the employment and other programmes that ATSIC makes funding and policy decisions for would be handed to existing departments.
While Howard argues that funding and delivering programmes though existing government departments termed ‘mainstreaming’ will be more effective, ATSIC’s acting chairman Lionel Quartermaine disagrees: “I don’t see how mainstreaming indigenous programmes (will work). Where mainstreaming (has occurred it) has failed.”
“I mean, we’ve still got health issues in this country on Third World par. … we make up two percent of our population, yet we’ve got 20 percent in jail. We’ve got our education failing indigenous people, so you see, mainstreaming programmes won’t work,” he said at a media conference outside Parliament House.
In truth, since Howard stripped ATSIC of responsibility of health and education responsibilities in 1996 and ‘mainstreamed’ them, conditions have got worse, says Phil Glendenning, president of the Australians for Native Title and Aboriginal Reconciliation.
“An indigenous person born today in Australia in a place like Brewarrina is going to have a life expectancy lower than children born in Bangladesh,” he said. ”That is what mainstreaming has bought us. So does more of that look like a solution? No it doesn’t.”
Howard’s proposal that ATSIC will be replaced by a handpicked advisory body prompted a derisory response from within the Aboriginal community. “To even think about establishing an advisory body, just to advise government, that means a government can either take their word or ignore their word,” Quartermaine said.
Quartermaine also had a word of advice for anyone asked to act as a member of a new advisory body. “Look, I’d encourage anyone who’s on that list to actually don’t be a party to it because what they are doing is selling out indigenous self-determination,” he said.
Asked why he had decided to abolish ATSIC, Howard dismissed its advocacy of Aboriginal rights and the need for a treaty between indigenous and non-indigenous Australia as a preoccupation with symbolism.
“I do believe that it has become too preoccupied with what might loosely be called symbolic issues and too little concern with delivering real outcomes for indigenous people,” he said.
Howard’s proposed legislation, set to be introduced in the next sitting of parliament, is likely to win the support of the opposition Labor Party, which two weeks ago promised that it would abolish ATSIC though with the caveat that a new representative body would be created.
Minor parties in the Senate, the Australian Democrats and the Australian Greens, have both condemned the government decision.
While Howard has long opposed outspoken Aboriginal organisations, the opportunity to attack ATSIC head on emerged only recently.
The commission’s current chairman, Geoff Clark, was stood aside by the government last year after being convicted of obstructing police when he intervened in a bar room fracas. ATSIC angered the government when, arguing that Clark was being victimised because of his position, it agreed to fund a legal appeal by Clark.
Mike Lynskey, chief executive of The Fred Hollows Foundation, a health care charity that works extensively with Aboriginal communities, believes the government’s decision is a major setback for attempts to foster better relations with Aboriginal Australia.
“It leaves it open for people in the community to infer that indigenous people can’t run things on their own and that indigenous organisations are riddled with corruption,” he said.
“It smacks of the attitude that we have to come in a patronising way, like the missionary activity of 30 years ago, and do it all for them. I think one would hope that we can be a more sophisticated society,” he said. “It also sends a message to indigenous people that we are not prepared to recognise their special needs.”
While Howard is confident that the death knell for ATSIC will gain broad support in the Australian community, Quartermaine insists that Aboriginal issues will not fade away.
“I guarantee you this, the sun will still shine tomorrow and I’ll still be black, and the black issues will still exist,” he said. ”Black people in this country will not go away, the black issue will not go away. The advisory committee will not solve the problems. When will these people understand that?”
*****
+Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission (http://www.atsic.gov.au)
(END/IPS/AP/IP/HD/CR/BB/JS/04)