Development & Aid, Headlines, Health, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

LATIN AMERICA: Psychiatric Facilities Improving, but Abuses Continue

Diego Cevallos

MEXICO CITY, Dec 17 2004 (IPS) - Officially there are no more "lunatic asylums" in Latin America – a term that brings to mind dark, foul-smelling institutions where those who have gone "mad" were locked away, sometimes for life, and frequently mistreated.

But although mental hospitals in the region have been given modern names and a whitewash, the transformation has not always put an end to the abuse.

Testimony and documents studied by IPS indicate that significant changes have occurred in Latin America in favour of the mentally ill over the past few years, including a gradual departure from the old model of locking up patients and a move towards out-patient treatment that allows them to stay in close contact with their families and communities.

However, not everything is rosy.

In some psychiatric hospitals in the region, patients can still be seen eating their own excrement, rolling around naked on the floor, hitting themselves in plain sight of the doctors, drinking dirty water from filthy drainage channels like dogs, or tied to chairs or rickety beds all day long.

Such images have been collected by the Washington-based Mental Disability Rights International (MDRI), which has produced reports since the mid-1990s on conditions in psychiatric hospitals and wards in Mexico, Peru, Paraguay and Uruguay.


The organisation has also sent a team to Argentina this month to study conditions there.

"We have seen progress in some countries of Latin America, but there are still many problems that will take a long time to change, before we can finally say that the rights of the mentally ill are respected," Alison A. Hillman, director of MDRI’s Americas Advocacy Initiative, told IPS by telephone from Argentina.

Hillman and a team of experts are carrying out investigations in Argentina. "We have found that a large proportion of patients are shut away in psychiatric hospitals here, and have documented several cases of mistreatment."

She added that all of the information compiled will be presented in a report to be released next year.

Created in 1993, the MDRI "documents conditions, publishes reports on human rights enforcement, and promotes international oversight of the rights of people with mental disabilities."

A number of international conventions have been signed over the past 20 years, aimed at protecting the rights of the mentally ill and mentally disabled.

An estimated 400 million people around the world suffer from mental and neurological disorders. Some 288 million are affected by alcohol-related problems, and there are 60 million cases of mental retardation, according to the World Health Organisation.

There are some 22 million cases of dementia, 45 million cases of schizophrenia, between 10 and 20 million suicide attempts a year, and one million suicides.

Modern psychiatry shows that people with mental disabilities can be integrated in society if they receive the appropriate medical support and services. But these are not always available.

It is true that mistreatment continues to occur in some psychiatric hospitals, "but things are not like they used to be," César Bañuelos, the director of the Cuauhtémoc Mental Health Community Centre in the Mexican capital, remarked to IPS.

The Cuauhtémoc Centre, which receives 35,000 outpatient visits a year, operates out of an old house with austere but clean and well-maintained installations.

The Centre provides treatment to people with all kinds of mental disorders, and the primary goal is to keep them from being admitted to hospitals and isolated from their family and society at large.

Bañuelos said the changes that have benefited the mentally ill were prompted by complaints, denunciations and campaigns by human rights groups (like the MDRI), advances made in the field of psychiatry, and efforts on the part of governments to live up to international conventions they have signed.

However, in countries like Mexico there are still "sinister conditions and gloom to varying degrees," he acknowledged.

MDRI activists documented numerous human rights violations in visits to several psychiatric wards and hospitals in Mexico between 1996 and 1999.

In the psychiatric facility in Jalisco in central Mexico, the conditions in the children’s ward were dismal, says an MDRI report, which describes "children left lying on mats on the floor, some covered with urine and feces…flies were everywhere and the smell was overwhelming. Self-abuse was common and basic medical care was lacking."

"Children and adults were left in physical restraints for long periods of time. One child was observed tied from head to foot to a wheelchair, where he remained most of the day. Other children were observed tied to beds…," the report adds.

Four months ago, Brazil’s bar association denounced that conditions in that country’s psychiatric institutions were appalling, "with patients left half-naked" and filthy, with no medical care, rehabilitation or community reinsertion programmes.

"I was shocked. It is one thing to hear about this, and another to see it. And what you see in these places is very sad," said Edisio Simoes Souto, president of the bar association’s human rights commission.

Some 100 lawyers carried out simultaneous surprise visits to 38 randomly selected psychiatric facilities of the 200 in Brazil that house a total of around 50,000 patients.

"We couldn’t visit any more than that because of lack of resources and time," said Simoes Souto.

In a hospital in the southeastern Brazilian state of Minas, the delegates found that the patients were unusually silent and showed signs of abuse and neglect, like cuts, stitches and open sores. Many were unwashed, and some could be seen picking things up off the floor and eating them.

In neighbouring Paraguay, the MDRI found "grave human rights abuses" in the psychiatric hospital, which held 460 patients.

The group denounced "the detention of two adolescent boys in tiny isolation cells, naked and without access to bathrooms for years on end," and dozens of patients held in overcrowded wards, receiving no treatment.

After the group filed a petition before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR), the Paraguayan government sacked the director of the hospital, and a restructuring process was launched.

The MDRI also issued a harsh report in 2003 on conditions in Peru.

The group found "a number of serious human rights violations against people with mental disabilities, including: inhuman and degrading treatment in institutions; discrimination in the provision of health and social services; failure to ensure informed consent; and violations of the right to community integration," says the report.

Referring to the Víctor Larco Herrera Hospital, founded in 1918 in Lima, the MDRI reported that the bathrooms in certain wards were "filthy and the stench of raw sewage permeated the air. There was excrement and urine on the floor of the bathrooms".

Nevertheless, Hillman said that "Despite everything we have seen and reported in Latin America, attention for the mentally ill is changing for the better."

In several countries, like Mexico and Uruguay, the number of mentally ill people living in psychiatric hospitals has shrunk in the past few years. The majority of patients are now treated on an outpatient basis, and live with their families or other caretakers.

But cases of abuse still occur, like that of Mariana, a young woman who has been shut away for more than 10 years in a psychiatric institution in Mexico.

Her older brother, who asked not to be identified for fear of reprisals from the doctors, told IPS that Mariana, who was diagnosed with schizophrenia, has been raped and otherwise abused on a number of occasions.

"It’s as if my parents didn’t care anymore, that’s why they left her there. But I’ve visited her and she’s getting more and more lost in that depressing place.

"I hope I can get her out of there someday so she can discover that out here, on the streets, life is so different," he added.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags