Sunday, November 22, 2026
Abid Aslam
- The U.S. government is on a propaganda offensive designed to blunt a presumed rush to anti-U.S. terrorism and to convince publics – especially in Arab and Muslim countries – that the land of the free is also the home of the tolerant.
The efforts evince a simultaneous dedication to the proposition that people abroad must not hate the United States and a determination to ignore the question that so vexed the nation after the terrorist attacks of Sep. 11, 2001: WHY do they hate us?
The job of putting a smiling face on Uncle Sam, the familiar personification of the U.S. government, has fallen to an advertising executive best known for making famous the beaming face of Uncle Ben, the African-American rice grower whose copyrighted name and visage grace a leading brand of quick-cooking rice.
Charlotte Beers, once known as the queen of Madison Avenue (the New York thoroughfare considered the advertising industry’s hub), has christened her government career with a 15-million-dollar ‘public diplomacy’ television ad campaign that, according to the State Department, has reached 300 million people.
Few of them have been in the Arab countries originally targeted as the audience. Egypt and Lebanon banned the "Shared Values" ads as paid foreign propaganda and focus groups in Jordan, assembled to give an indication of how wider audiences might react, said the spots left them cold.
One ad featured a Muslim paramedic with the New York fire department talking about the religious diversity of his workforce and another, a headscarf-wearing mother cheering her pre-teen sons as they played softball with apparently non-Muslim children.
Also taking up the call to charms, State Department official-cum-novelist Mark Jacobs has collected essays by 15 top authors, aimed at promoting U.S. values abroad. The anthology reportedly is being distributed free at U.S. embassies worldwide (an anti-propaganda law makes it illegal to disseminate the works in the United States, although they are available on a government Web site aimed at foreign audiences).
Participants in what the foreign ministry termed an experiment include Jacobs himself; author and performance artist Elmaz Abinader; poet-novelists Julia Alvarez and Naomi Shihab Nye; literary essayist Sven Birkerts; Pulitzer Prize-winning novelists and short-story writers Robert Olen Butler and Michael Chabon; poets Billy Collins and Robert Creeley; Civil War historian David Herbert Donald; novelists Richard Ford, Linda Hogan and National Book Award recipient Charles Johnson; fiction writer and English professor Bharati Mukherjee, and former poet laureate of the United States Robert Pinsky.
"If we were to ask a contemporary group of American poets, novelists, critics, and historians what it means to be an American writer, Jacobs proposed, the results could illuminate in an interesting way certain America (sic) values – freedom, diversity, democracy – that may not be well understood in all parts of the world," the volume’s introduction states.
Although Beers’ marketing targets mass audiences and Jacobs’ the lettered classes, the statement each makes – that the United States treats Muslims and Arabs well; that it is a pluralist place that greets, nay encourages, dissent with tolerance – inspire some degree of disbelief.
When the TV ads hit the airwaves in Africa, the Middle East and Central and South Asia, thousands of people from those regions living in the United States had been rounded up, detained without charges or evidence against them, or subjected to interrogation on the basis of their ethnicity or presumed religious affinity.
Citizens of 25 countries deemed suspect have been required to register with, and undergo additional screening by, immigration authorities. Thousands reportedly have found themselves subject to immediate detention and deportation; others have fled to their home countries or across the border to Canada – in some cases by dead of mid-winter night with their children and what few possessions they could manage to carry – even as their governments protested Washington singling out their nationals.
In fairness, there have been countless stories of U.S. residents standing shoulder-to-shoulder with their Muslim and Arab neighbours in the face of communal discrimination since the attacks on the World Trade Centre and the Pentagon.
However, while the U.S. government touts its record of benevolence, its TV ads are being contradicted by news of the latest injustices and insults – a good deal of it from neighbours and relatives who have fallen victim to the latest U.S. "homeland security" reflex or who know people who have.
Even if some TV viewers in these countries end up believing the U.S. line, will this help or hinder Washington’s cause? Will people whose U.S. visa applications have been rejected feel bitter at having their noses rubbed in images of the ‘good life’ they have been denied?
Likewise, Jacobs’ experiment in plugging pluralism comes as the Bush administration expands its repressive USA Patriot Act and proposes to supplement it with a Domestic Security Enhancement Act, apparently modelled on the internal security laws of countries that Washington is accustomed to lecturing on human rights.
It follows countless attempts – some successful, others not – to censor creative expression: comedian and political commentator Bill Maher’s TV show was pulled from leading markets – including Washington, D.C. – for statements considered unpatriotic; musician Steve Earle received demands to ban his ‘John Walker’s Blues’, a song exploring the psyche of the man who came to be known as "the American Taliban". Leading U.S. radio chain Clear Channel issued a list of hundreds of songs and artists not to be aired by their 1,000-plus stations.
Given the emergence of an impulse, if not a programme quite yet, described as the "new McCarthyism" for its similarities to the anti-communist smears and purges of Hollywood and the cultural establishment in the 1950s, contributors to the State Department literary anthology could be construed as making a cautious investment in career security – but for their solid reputations.
U.S. residents have long taken for granted many freedoms others only dream of. This has never been at issue and even the most jaundiced observer must acknowledge that a relatively thoughtful Congress has tempered the Bush administration’s most stifling predilections and likely will trim the proposed security law.
However, what has irked so many people the world over is that the United States has installed or backed despots and dictators overseas while hoarding the fruits of democracy at home. This contradiction, long lamented overseas as hypocritical, is left untouched by the collection of essays touting pluralism as a defining U.S. value.
All the same, the writers underscore the notion that the United States comprise a nation of individualists – people with wills and voices who are free to stand apart from the pronouncements of government.
The implications of that position brim with promise. But celebrating the freedom to dissent is not the same thing as actually exercising it.