Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines | Analysis

ASIA-PACIFIC: APEC – A Community Built on Honour and Shame

Analysis - Johanna Son

MANILA, Nov 27 1996 (IPS) - Each November, Asia-Pacific leaders gather for an informal summit and then pose for pictures garbed in identical attire — a gesture meant to show a ‘sense of community’ around the Pacific Rim.

This year’s Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit was rich in symbol: Apart from donning the Filipino attire called ‘barong tagalog’, the leaders wrote down their messages for APEC citizens that were stored in a time capsule to be opened in 2010.

APEC documents are peppered with upbeat language lauding the ‘spirit of community’ in a forum that groups economies from the United States and Japan to Papua New Guinea, and which straddles vastly different cultures and ideologies.

But for all the talk about shared interests, APEC is very much an experiment in a novel form of cooperation: one where all actions are voluntary and non-binding, but whose gains are supposed to be greater than those made in formal negotiations.

The driving force behind APEC, formed in 1989, is supposed to be peer pressure. Said one Asian diplomat: “We shame them into action.”

Canadian Prime Minister Jean Chretien, host of the 1997 meetings in Vancouver, put it thus: “APEC is an honour system. It’s not a body that makes laws and takes people to court.”

But a look at ‘action’ at this year’s meetings shows the ‘APEC Way’ does not make for record speed in freeing up trade and investment — or even boosting economic cooperation, an aspect that has so far lagged behind the forum’s free-trade focus.

Businessmen in fact find APEC’s progress glacial, having perhaps done more than governments to integrate the Asia-Pacific into a ‘community’. While countries talk, companies have gone ahead and done business across the Pacific Ocean.

“Businesspeople discovered the Asia-Pacific long before it became politically fashionable,” said Timothy Ong, managing director of Brunei’s National Insurance Co. Bhd and a member of the APEC Business Advisory Council.

At the Philippine meeting that ended on Monday, APEC ministers agreed on the Manila Action Plan, which contains the 18 member economies’ schemes for cutting tariffs and other barriers to freer trade. It is meant to be the first concrete step to lifting trade and investment barriers by 2020.

The plans, to be carried out starting Jan 1, 1997, are a mix of modest and bolder steps. Majority reiterate liberalisation moves already underway in national schemes or the World Trade Organisation (WTO). Others spell out plans ranging from reviewing trade laws to lengthening business visas.

Indeed, diplomats at the Manila meetings found themselves constantly being asked what was new in their plans.

APEC is not an structured “organisation” but a “forum”, and it is not a negotiating arena, others point out.

“The IAPs (individual action plans) are not (trade) offers. APEC is not about that but about reporting by individual countries on what we have done in the multilateral trading system,” said Rafidah Aziz, Malaysia’s minister for international trade and industry.

“APEC is just a reporting mechanism,” she said, “we’re not negotiating anything here.”

All agree that APEC is not a negotiating club, but its still- evolving character means members tend to interpret it from their own vantage points.

While developed countries often speak about the momentum toward liberalisation, developing nations stress that the pace of that process must be determined by their interests.

These different thrusts emerged again at the debate over freeing up trade in information technology products.

Under intense lobbying by the United States, APEC leaders in their declaration sought the conclusion of an information technology accord that would “substantially eliminate tariffs by the year 2000, recognising the need for flexibility” as talks on the matter in the WTO proceed.

While U.S. officials hailed this as the first time APEC pronounced itself as a group on a WTO issue, developing countries were focusing on the explicit recognition of their leeway with regard to scope and product coverage in the proposed accord.

Some see the stress on flexibility as a weakened commitment, but Malaysian officials say those issues are as valid as that of any other member or bloc within APEC.

“There is too much emphasis on a level playing field, but nothing is said about the size of the contestants,” Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad said. “Opening up the market of the rich to the poor is meaningless, if the poor has nothing to sell.”

He warned against a brand of trade liberalisation that is invoked by industrialised countries when it suits them, as in information technology products that are key exports for nations like the United States.

Yet, Mahathir argued, developed nations restrict the entry of items like textiles exported by developing nations.

The pace of free trade, not to mention the difficulty of selling it to many citizens, is not only the subject of tension within APEC.

Mahathir urged APEC to give as much focus as helping poorer countries compete as to opening markets, and sought action plans not just in trade liberalisation but in development cooperation.

“If these plans could be effected in the same manner and with the same zeal as the action plans for market and investment liberalisation, we could create in the not too distant future an ‘APEC community’ that is not only prosperous but where the distribution of wealth is more equitable,” he said.

Developing countries can probably breathe a little easier now that APEC has pronounced itself on issues other than free trade, saying that humanising development and achieving equity is as important as trade liberalisation. The ties that bind a community, after all, must go beyond trade.

“Promoting rapid growth that ensures a healthy environment and improves the quality of life of our citizens is a fundamental challenge,” the leaders’ declaration said.

The rise of social concerns in the free-trade agenda gives developing countries the flexibility that they have long stressed in APEC — that market liberalisation be carried out at a pace compatible with their abilities and interests.

Federico Macaranas, the Filipino head of senior officials who did the spadework for the APEC meetings, said another gauge must be used in assessing APEC’s “very unique” brand of cooperation.

“Unlike negotiations where you expect everyone to start from the same point, APEC wants to see everyone at end-point,” he said. “That’s why APEC is misunderstood by many. We are trying to look at starting points. APEC wants to see an end point.”

This, he said, leaves room for “individual differences” on the way to the goal of free trade by 2010 for developed countries and 2020 for developing nations, a goal APEC set in 1993.

Officials say that the individual action plans are the first in a “progression” of steps toward liberalisation that will be improved upon in future meetings.

This means the plans are important not just for their content, but the fact APEC economies know that their trade status will be up for scrutiny and comparison every year. This, they say, puts pressure on countries so they would not want to be left behind.

A Japanese official adds it is important for APEC to prove that the culture of consensus, drawn from the success of consensual diplomacy at the Association of South-east Asian Nations, can work.

The larger aim to keep in mind, he says, is to make the point that there is another option beyond wielding the big stick of sanctions in trade talks.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags