Active Citizens, Civil Society, Environment, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT: Large Amounts of Chemical Weapons Dumped and Buried

Andrei Ivanov

MOSCOW, Nov 21 1996 (IPS) - Chemical weapons stockpiles in the former Soviet Union were far greater than official sources have admitted, claims professor Lev Fyodorov, president of the non-governmental group The Union for Chemical Safety (Russia).

Large quantities of aged chemical weapons have been dumped at sea and buried on land to ensure that stocks declared in accordance with the Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC) were similar to those held by the United States, he told IPS in an interview this week.

He warns that the hasty dumping of these weapons poses a serious environmental and health threat to the Russian people.

In the years before World War II five chemical weapons were produced on an industrial scale — mustard gas, lewisite, hydrogen cyanide, phosgene, and adamsite. Production carried on throughout the war. Second generation weapons (nerve gases) were produced on a large scale after the defeat of Nazi Germany and the start of the Cold War. In the 1960s there was also large-scale production of herbicidal weapons, similar to the agents used by the U.S. in Vietnam to strip jungle cover from tactically significant areas.

Based on extensive research, Fyodorov says that in the prewar years, the army received from industry roughly 6,000-8,000 tonnes of mustard gas agents.

During the war approximately 120,000 tonnes of these first generation weapons — of World War I vintage — were produced including 77,400 tonnes of mustard, 20,600 tonnes of lewisite, 11,100 tonnes of hydrogen cyanide, 8,300 tonnes of phosgene, and 6,100 tonnes of adamsite.

Roughly a third of the mustard and lewisite was injected into artillery shells, the rest stored in tanks.

The development of chemical weapons turned to new and better nerve gases after World War II. Between 1958 and 1987 some 33,000 tonnes of nerve agents were produced, including at least 12,000 tonnes of sarin, 5,000 tonnes of soman, and 15,500 tonnes of V-gas. In 1990- 1992, in anticipation of the CWC, Russia declared stocks totalling 40,000 tonnes, including 7,700 tonnes of persistent mustard, lewisite and mustard-lewisite mix and 32,300 tonnes of nerve agent.

“Simple arithmetic shows that at least 112,300 tonnes of first generation weapons must have somehow been disposed of,” he says. This issue is, is how, and where.

He explains that his researches in various archives have shown that up to half of these agents (in particular those already filled into munitions) were dumped in the sea while the rest was buried on land.

The situation was complicated in the post-war years, however by large stocks of captured German chemical weapons which also had to be dumped.

Fyodorov says the first, the most intense, wave of chemical weapons disposal occurred in the 1946-1948 period and involved the sea dumping of both German and Soviet weapons. The Soviet weapons disposed of included roughly 60,000- 65,000 tonnes of mustard and approximately 14,000 tons of lewisite.

The second wave of disposal dates occurred between 1956 and 1962, the period of conversion from first-generation to second- generation chemical weapons systems.

Approximately 10,000-12,000 tonnes of mustard were liquidated. Then between 1987 and 1989 the Soviet Army carried out large-scale transfers of CW from the bases where they had been stored to the seven bases which then were announced for the purposes of the CWC. At the same time the arsenals were reduced to acceptable levels. “Several methods of CW disposal were used,” says Fyodorov:

“Incineration and/or burial of large amounts not charged into munitions (in shells or missile warheads) in the vicinities of storage bases and testing grounds; incineration and burial of chemicals including those charged into munitions, in the vicinities of CW production plants in Chapaevsk, Dzerzhinsk, etc; underwater disposal (dumping) of chemical munitions and containers filled with Russian and German CW in seas; and there are also indications that some chemical munitions were dumped in rivers and swamps.”

He says there is little official information on the sites of the sea dumping activities. However according to the research undertaken by the Ministry of the Environment to which he had access they include the Baltic Sea, White Sea, Barents and Black Sea and the seas of Okhotsk and Japan over the period of more than 50 years.

His research has shown that the weapons were loaded onto ships at Liinakhamari port in Murmansk Oblast, having arrived by road from Pechenga station for subsequent dumping in the Barents and Kara Seas. Loading also took place in Severodvinsk for dumping in the White Sea, at Posyet and Nakhodka in the Far Eastern Russian Primorskiy region for dumping in the Sea of Japan, and at Paldiski and Tallinn in Estonia for subsequent dumping in the Baltic.

He has also identified some specific dumping sites from navigation maps and from talking to eye-witnesses. These include two sites in the White Sea; a site in the Kara Sea, near the northern part of Novaya Zemlya, and a site near Povorotnyy Cape in the Sea of Japan. In total at least 12 large sea areas are involved which comprise hundreds of specific sites.

A recently declassified top secret document reveals that problems arising from dumping were already evident in the 1940s. A letter to Stalin from his Interior Ministry in July 1946 reports several incidents of chemical munitions being caught in fishing nets.

“In June this year nine fishermen from fishing boat ZMR-93 ‘Bauska’ were brought to a city hospital of Liepaja of Latvian SSR with signs of poisoning by yperite (mustard),” it says.

It also notes that in 1945, “our troops captured 35,000 metric tons of chemical weapons, including chemical aircraft bombs, which were brought and dumped by the trophy groups into the sea between the coasts of the Soviet Union and Sweden.”

“The methods used in the pre-convention elimination of CW were ecologically hazardous,” says Fyodorov. The consequences of such disposal will be felt for a long time. All CW that were produced and liquidated have been transformed from combat weapons into ecological ones.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags