Sunday, November 22, 2026
Patrick Smikle
- Thirteen years after a revolution ended with the death of Grenada’s Prime Minister, one key person fingered in those events is claiming some responsibility.
“There’s a very clear distinction between moral and political responsibility for the tragedy, the catastrophe, which took place, for which I personally accept responsibility, and criminal liability,” says Bernard Coard.
Coard was deputy Prime Minister in the 1979-1983 People’s Revolutionary Government (PRG).
The tragedy he refers to is the killing on Oct. 19, 1983 of Prime Minister Maurice Bishop, three cabinet ministers and several other people who sided with Bishop in a bitter internal party row which saw the two men leading opposing factions of the ruling New Jewel movement (NJM).
Coard’s statement coming on the eve of the day — Oct. 25 when Grenadians look back at the time the U.S. troops landed on the island — was his first public comment on the events of 1983, since being convicted in 1986 along with 16 other NJM and People’s Revolutionary Army functionaries, for the murder of Bishop and several others.
The occasion was an interview, in which for the first time journalists were allowed to speak openly to 11 of the 13 prisoners serving life sentences. The other three, all soldiers, are serving 20-year terms.
Coard says that 13 years of analysing the situation from his prison cell has brought him to the conclusion that destruction of the revolution was probably inevitable given the way the NJM had come to power. The NJM had overthrown the Eric Gairy-led Grenada United Labour Party government (GULP), and the timing of the event at the height to the Cold War.
He says however the NJM had been left with no choice. The Gairy regime, by rigging elections and through increasing brutality against its political opponents, had blocked the path to democratic change. Gairy’s party had dominated Grenadian politics for 12 years.
Coard admits that the NJM/PRG had itself committed human rights abuses against its opponents, such as detention without trial. But he blames this on the paranoia fostered by the Cold War and fear of Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) destabilisation of the revolution.
“Anyone who criticised or disagreed with what was being done during the revolution was genuinely seen as somebody in the pay of the CIA, in the pay of the Americans,” says Coard.
“Remember the Americans did overthrow the government of Mossadegh in Iran in 1953. They did overthrow the government of Arbenz in Guatemala in ’54. They did overthrow the government of Cheddi Jagan (in Guyana) with the help of the British. They did in fact play a very active role which they have acknowledged in overthrowing democratically elected Allende (in Chile) in ’73.”
Coard’s admission seems not to have won him any friends in a population that for the most part remains hostile to the 17 convicts, blaming them for the destruction of the country’s four and a half-year experiment with revolutionary politics.
The general consensus of the Grenadian people seems to be that 1979 to 1983 were the good years as under Bishop’s socialist policies the economy began to show signs of growth and his social policies resulted in a boost to education and the health sector.
With economic assistance from other socialist countries and the European Community he quickly transformed a fledgling economy into a model that political analysts said then was the envy of its neighbours.
At the height of world recession, with an economy heavily dependent on agricultural exports, namely nutmeg, bananas and cocoa and therefore vulnerable to fluctuating world commodity prices, gross domestic product (GDP) stood at 14 percent.
Government spending between 1980 and 1982 rose to 81.7 million dollars, dwarfing the three million U.S. dollars in Gairy’s 1978 budget.
The economy grew by approximately 5.5 percent in 1982, but in 1978 it had achieved negative growth.
The post-revolution days have not been good ones, many say. The tiny eastern Caribbean island, population 98,000, recently ended a self-inflicted structural adjustment programme which saw drastic reductions in state spending.
But the economy has barely responded to the austerity programme, failing to register more than a two percent growth in the past five years. Last year there was negative growth and according to a recent government survey, the number of Grenadians living below the poverty line has doubled over the last eight years. Unemployment now tops the 20 percent mark.
The Maurice Bishop Patriotic Movement (MBPM), a political party formed after the demise of the revolution, has denounced Coard’s comments and so has prominent local attorney, Lloyd Noel.
Noel who served briefly as the PRG’s first Attorney General, but who in post-revolutionary Grenada takes much more conservative positions, says Coard could not escape criminal liability.
But Coard’s comments did succeed in giving a fillip to the seemingly never-ending debate about the revolution, the events of Oct. 19 and the subsequent invasion.