Friday, November 20, 2026
Mitu Varma
- Nearly a decade ago, Richard Attenborough’s ‘Gandhi’ won worldwide critical and popular acclaim as one of the best biographical films ever made. Now another remarkable film on the same man has been made, this time by an Indian director.
The difference is that the latter film ends where Attenborough’s film effectively begins.
Directed by Shyam Benegal, a renowned proponent of the Indian ‘New Wave’ or realistic cinema, ‘The Making of the Mahatma’ traces Gandhi’s evolution from a run-of-the-mill bar-at-law to a man of unusual spiritual and moral fibre.
While Attenborough’s film glossed over 21 years that Gandhi spent in South Africa to jump to when he arrived in India to lead its struggle for independence from British colonial rule, Benegal’s film deals only with those crucial years as they laid the foundation for the evolution of Gandhi’s political and personal philosophy.
The film has been produced in collaboration with the South African Broadcasting Corporation and has won three prestigious national awards in India this year. Not only was it declared the best English language feature film of the year, but it also won the coveted best actor award for the young and relatively unknown Rajit Kapur, who essayed the role of the Mahatma.
A special jury award was given to Shyam Benegal for “recreating the formative years of the Mahatma” and “giving an insight into a future Mahatma”.
The film begins with Gandhi’s arrival in South Africa as a barrister and the utter humiliation he faces in the highly segregated racist society. Thrown out of a first class compartment, made to sit outside a stage coach and pushed rudely off a pavement, Gandhi begins to realise the injustice and inhumanity inherent in the apartheid system. He also slowly begins to understand the ills of colonialism.
Each new injustice steels his resolve to battle the system and each new challenge thrown up finds a different and innovative response from the young Indian. Initially, Gandhi is shown to be a believer in the system who feels raising their problems will lead to their effective resolution by the powers that be. This belief even leads him to organise a stretcher brigade to assist the British war effort, first against the Boers and then against the Zulus.
It is during the war against the Zulus that Gandhi finds not war wounded, but Africans who have been flogged and left to die by white doctors who refuse to treat them. The incident shakes up the man and launches him on his path of peaceful non-cooperation.
His fight begins with a protest against finger printing of Indians, leads to his being jailed for refusing to carry a ‘dog- pass’ compulsory for coloured citizens and finally results in mass mobilisation against an unreasonable tax levied on indentured labour combined with protest against other discriminatory legislation against coloured people.
Slowly, but surely, the weapon of ‘satyagraha’ or peaceful resistance is honed and fine-tuned as an instrument of effective protest. Evolved and tested in the crucible of racist South Africa, ‘satyagraha’ was what made Gandhi bring one of the most powerful of the world’s empires to its knees later in India.
Benegal does dwell on the genesis of Gandhi’s brand of politics, but not as effectively as he handles the struggle and evolution of the man. Gandhi’s political ideas don’t really come alive for the viewer, maybe because at that point of time they were still in an embryonic stage, but what blazes forth from the screen is the integrity and personal battles of the man to determine and live by principles he felt were correct.
This brings him into repeated conflict with his family, often displaying his human frailties. When Gandhi determines that there should be dignity of labour, he insists that his pregnant wife empty a clerk’s chamberpot, and when she refuses to do that, he threatens to throw her out in a fit of anger.
Gandhi’s wife, Kasturba, played by the elfin Pallavi Joshi is no walkover. She stands up to her husband in some matters, but loving him, reconciles and supports his struggles. A stormy marriage, but a loving one nevertheless which comes across very effectively on celluloid. Gandhi’s eldest, however, cannot reconcile himself to his father’s principles and brands him an ego maniac who uses his family to further his own ideas.
Rajit Kapur effectively portrays the anguish of the father as his son leaves home in a huff after accusing him of not caring for his family.
What is amazing about the man and what comes across effectively in the film is his total lack of duality. He does what he believes — there is no gap between thought and action. He truly lives his faith even if it means giving up all material possessions and luxuries and living in a simple self-sufficient village community.
It cannot but serve as a telling comment on modern day India, where an ex-prime minister of Gandhi’s own Congress party is in the dock for cases of fraud and cheating, while his other colleagues face serious corruption charges. Perhaps it is symbolic that the film is currently playing in Delhi to near-empty theatres.