Saturday, November 21, 2026
Alecia McKenzie
- Beauty contests — oh what fun! There have been incidents in which winners were pelted with eggs and soft fruit by the disgruntled relatives of the less beautiful.
There have been cases where the winner’s lack of knowledge of the country she was representing led to hit songs that mocked her selection.
There have been protests against the very staging of such contests, as in Bangalore, India, where earlier this month police temporarily detained 21 people demonstrating against plans to stage the Miss World contest there.
There has been the famous case of a Miss America being forced to give up her title because nude pictures of her appeared in the soft-porn magazine Penthouse. And more recently it seemed that the current Miss Universe would have to withdraw from the beauty queen’s tour trail because she gained a whopping five kilos, or eleven pounds, to take her to a deemed “unacceptable” 56 kilos.
Still, all of these incidents seem insignificant when compared with the passions aroused by the selection this month of a black, Caribbean-born 18-year-old as Miss Italy, and the continuing reactions to the reactions.
The winner, Denny Mendez, was born in the Dominican Republic but became an Italian citizen after her mother married an Italian.
Her very participation in the contest led to a national and media debate over whether a black woman could represent Italian beauty, and the controversy resulted in one member of the jury being dismissed and another being temporarily ousted.
Amid all the hoopla, Mendez was finally chosen by the judges as well as by nine million of the 13 million viewers who were watching the contest live and who phoned in their choice.
But her reign promises to be a difficult one. Many Italians both at home and abroad seem unable or unwilling to accept Mendez as a representative of her adopted country.
“How can she represent Italian beauty,” asked one young Italian based in Brussels. “Could a white woman go to Africa and win a beauty contest?”
His questions reflect the feelings of many who, while declaring that they are “not in the least racist”, suddenly find themselves filled with strong nationalist feelings.
Their reaction have caused anger, resentment and, in some instances, humour among black people living in Europe.
“I am not at surprised at the way many Italians are carrying on over a black woman being elected Miss Italy,” said one Brussels- based black diplomat who lived for 15 years in Italy.
“Although they are a warm and friendly people in general, they feel they are of pure Caucasian stock. And it is very ironic because many Europeans used to consider Italians as the negroes of Europe.”
Another commentator, a former journalist from the Caribbean who now lives here, commented, “Aren’t the Italians of Moorish ancestry? This might be the best representative they’ve ever had. They are feisty and out of order.”
The sentiments perhaps overlook the complexity of the issue. As Luca Tomasi, an Italian translator in Brussels, points out, Mendez’s selection had an element of political correctness about it; Many Italians did not want to be seen as racist.
On the other hand, Tomasi and others find the backlash disturbing. “I don’t think you can argue that a black girl can’t stand for Miss Italy,” he says. “No one objects to Fiona May, a black athlete, winning a medal for Italy at the Olympics. So why not a Miss Italy?”
The continuing controversy serves, if anything to highlight the issue of race and colour in relation to beauty. In many predominantly black countries beauty-contest winners tend to be lighter in skin shade than the majority of their compatriots.
In Jamaica, a country which reveres beauty pageants, the first woman to win the Miss Jamaica title after the country’s independence in 1962 was of North European stock.
Carol Joan Crawford, brown-haired and light-eyed, went on to win Miss World and is still fondly thought of by many Jamaicans who hung her picture on their walls. In contrast, she was seen overseas as a coloured woman and her win elicited international comment.
Since Crawford’s reign, most of the other winners of Miss Jamaica have been light-skinned and long-haired. One was even raised in the United States and knew very little about the island’s history and culture. Her selection led to hit songs about what a Miss Jamaica ought to know.
In other countries, where the population is predominantly white, the selection of a dark-skinned contestant can lead to controversy and intense media scrutiny.
When Vanessa Williams, now a successful actress and singer, became the first black Miss America in 1984, her win angered some racist whites as well as some black people who did not consider her black enough.
Williams eventually had to give up the title when pictures of her nude and in compromising positions with another woman were published in Penthouse magazine, amid loud whispers of conspiracy.
Race and colour, always an issue in South Africa, extended into the beauty arena there as well, with protests during the apartheid era against white Miss South Africas. The government finally tried to solve things by having two winners simultaneously for the title, one black and one white. But that only led to further outrage.
The situation is Italy is thus not exceptional. Indeed the country’s opinion may have been similar divided if the winner had come from the south because Italy is currently in the throes of separation fever.
Some in the north would dearly like to be split from their compatriots in the south whom they consider as inferior in many ways — and who just happen to be generally darker in skin shade.
If Mendez weathers the storm and goes on to win the Miss World contest, she may become a unifying factor after all. If, however, Italians just cannot bear the thought of her continuing her reign, they could always do what Jamaica’s Socialist government did in the Seventies — ban beauty contests.