Sunday, November 22, 2026
Gustavo Capdevila
- India officially imposed its veto on the draft Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty drawn up by the Disarmament Conference, Tuesday, though without preventing other nations from proposing its approval by the UN General Assembly.
The New Delhi representative at the Disarmament Conference, Arundhati Ghose, complained in the extraordinary session that the rejected project divided the world between “nuclear weapons haves and have nots.”
The future of the treaty will be decided in the plenary meeting Thursday when details of the Conference report to the UN General Assembly will be revealed.
India’s veto means the Disarmament Conference, which makes its decisions by consensus, will be unable to present the treaty to the General Assembly, so the report to the UN will only be able to relate to the negotiations held this year.
However, it is probable that a group of countries will use the meeting to suggest they take the project for approval and signing by the General Assembly.
Out of all the 61 member states of the Disarmament Conference, only India blocked the project from going to the UN, for other nations voiced their criticisms but accepted this would be the best possible agreement.
The United States, one of the nations most strongly behind the treaty, said New Delhi’s veto was in order to “conserve the nuclear option for India.”
India’s decision was classed as “very unfortunate,” by US ambassador Stephen Ledogar.
The protesting nation carried out its only nuclear test in 1974, and objected to the fact the treaty did not include commitments to the gradual elimination of the nuclear arsenal and the permanent suspension of the arms race.
The Non Aligned Movement countries also shared India’s objections, while the five nuclear powers – Britain, China, France, Russia and the United States – opposed them.
India also was at odds with the formula for bringing the treaty into effect, making this dependent on India formally ratifying the agreement.
In Tuesday’s Disarmament Conference plenary session Pakistan’s Ambassador Munir Akram harshly criticised India, saying Pakistan “knew of and stated its concern about the nuclear ambitions of its eastern neighbour from the outset.”
He accused “the nation which has blocked the treaty” for being “hypocritical.” Since 1948, when they shrugged off the yoke of the British empire, India and Pakistan have had three confrontations on the border.
Along with Israel, these two neighbours are considered to be “on the threshold” of becoming nuclear powers.
The test ban treaty was precisely designed to prevent more nations entering the “club of the nuclear powers.”
The environmental organisation Greenpeace said responsibility for the failure of the talks could be equally shared between those who rejected the document, especially India, and the nuclear powers, mostly Britain, China and Russia which were inflexible on its implementation.
Simon Carroll, Greenpeace representative in Geneva, criticised the nuclear powers for their obstinacy which “once again threw doubt on their commitment” to a complete test ban.
He said that to dispel the doubts these countries must lead the efforts to get the treaty signed this year in New York, and extend their commitment to measures working for the elimination of nuclear weapons.