Saturday, November 21, 2026
Rahul Bedi
- Moral guardians are on the march in India, calling for adherence to a gospel of denial and abstinence.
Prohibition has been introduced into the hard-drinking, northern state of Haryana and the government is threatening to implement a law shutting all bars in the city of Bombay at 8.30pm. This has caused bar hostesses and cabaret in Bombay, to issue counter threats that they would “raise their skirts” and solicit customers on city streets.
“All our customers come after 11-pm and it is only then that we can earn some money,” said Babita, the “empress” of Raj Mahal a bar in suburban Khar, at a demonstration organised against their closure in downtown Bombay.
She said the arbitrary decision to close down Bombay’s bars, a majority located in the suburbs and catering to industrial workers, would deprive many families of all income and, could lead the unemployed girls to take to take up prostitution.
Ever since it came to power two years ago, the Hindu fundamentalist coalition government of the Shiv Sena and the Bharatiya Janata Party, the BJP, has been trying to “purify” and morally re-arm Bombay, a vibrant city with a bustling red light area, lively bars and restaurants, open till the early hours.
Shiv Sena head Bal Thackeray, 72, the most powerful man in the state who counts Hitler amongst his role models, wants to introduce a state-wide ban on alcohol, invoke the four decade-old labour law which prohibits women from working in bars or restaurants after 8 pm and introduce compulsory military service.
He is ably supported by state cultural minister Pramod Navalkar, busy pursuing an anti-obscenity crusade which means trying to ban most activities which involve drinking and popular entertainment.
But the bar hostesses, supported by bar owners, are not going to take the proposed ban lying down.
They plan a series of demonstrations across Bombay, hoping to embarrass the government into revoking the order or at least allowing them to function till midnight.
Many women scoffed at the idea that the government was clamping down on the bars out of a sense of morality and safety for women. According to one, the police, more than their customers, harassed them the most and, at times, were impossible to control.
Alongside, a New Delhi judge has banned the telecast of adult movies on state-owned television even as most of India continues to be bombarded daily with steamy American soap operas and rock video programmes beamed by private cable operators.
The judge also made it compulsory for all programmes including serials and advertisements to obtain a “Universal” certificate from the censor board to stem the “cultural pollution” of India.
But most social commentators agree that such moves will hardly improve morals and “preserve” traditional cultural values as Indians had a notoriously ambivalent attitude towards matters sexual.
“On the one hand there is the cult of the Kama Sutra and erotic temple carvings and on the other prudery, hypocrisy and lip service to the ideal of chastity,” said Justice Kuldip Singh, an activist judge, recently dismissing a petition seeking to ban a book by one of India’s best known journalists on grounds of “permissiveness.”
Another social commentator said the average Indian, indeed even all South Asian, attitude to sex and related matters was hypocritical. Indians, he said, had “sex on their minds, lust in their eyes but fear in their hearts.”
Meanwhile, prohibition has not proved a great success in the southern state of Andhra Pradesh having deprived authorities of excise revenue.
Last month the state did not even have the money to pay the salaries of thousands of employees and the chief minister was seriously considering lifting prohibition.
“Enforced denial never works,” said a sociologist.
Most societies, particularly traditional ones like India, have to mature and work their way through problems like drinking and licentiousness and pornography. But given India’s libidinous past, it should face fewer problems, he said.