Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

COLOMBIA-MEDIA: Rumour and Gossip Staple Fare

Maria Isabel Garcia

BOGOTA, May 10 1996 (IPS) - Colombia’s Nobel prize-winner Gabriel Garcia Marquez was not exaggerating when he wrote that this was “the most gossipy country in the world.”

Rumours and tittle tattle abound on every facet of political life in Colombia, so much so that segments of the news concerning Colombia’s “narco-scandal” have been broadcast baldly as “lies from the palace.”

The 20-month investigation of “Case 8,000” – the official file on the narco-scandal – has led President Samper to the brink of impeachment due to alleged contributions to his 1994 election campaign by the Cali cartel. It also has turned up a seemingly endless stream of contradictory testimony.

In the more than 40,000 pages of case records gathered by the public prosecutor’s office, the same witnesses provide several versions of an event and journalists operate like alchemists in sifting fact from fiction in newspaper offices that have become rumour laboratories.

Garcia Marquez told the magazine ‘Cambio 16’ this week that “the State is falling apart, and society is divided between those who believe everything and those who don’t believe anything, without much basis for either position.”

“The Press and the Country’s Ethical Crisis”, published this week by journalist and communications analyst Javier Dario Restrepo, declares Colombia faces a “national crisis of truth.”

What in less important cases would be relatively unimportant contradictions have monumental repercussions in Case 8,000. The most outstanding example occurred in late January, when former Defence Minister Fernando Botero – Samper’s campaign manager in 1994 – gave a revised version of previous testimony.

After seven months of arguing that Samper had been unaware of campaign contributions of four to seven million dollars of drug money used to “oil” the electoral machinery of the Liberal Party in the second round of voting, Botero did an about-face and said the President had indeed known.

The new version offered by the prosecution’s number one witness against the President was immediately denied by Samper in a speech broadcast throughout the entire country.

According to Restrepo, “an ethical problem of enormous proportions” came to light on that occasion.

“Given that President Samper said his former minister was lying, while Botero insisted he was not, the only conclusion was that at the highest levels of power someone was lying…,” he said.

Restrepo pointed to the numerous protests by those involved in Case 8,000 alleging bias or the reporting of half-truths by the media. He cited cases of witnesses who could point to false statements published in newspapers, and of TV viewers who denounced false reports by highly respected newscasts.

He mentions former Presidents and generals who protest having been cited “out of context,” not only by reporters but by the President’s press office. And Catholic Church leaders have filed filed damage suits over accusations of ties with the drug trade.

Demands that the media correct false versions come from all sides: the President’s office, the public prosecutor’s office, the business community, legislators – on duty or under arrest – and scores of witnesses involved in the case. Without exaggerting, it could be said that nearly all media reports referring to Case 8,000 are followed by a demand for clarification or rectification.

Sources at the National Television Commission, in charge of regulating that media, say if all available personnel were assigned to the task of responding to such demands, they still would be unable to cope with the flood.

Restrepo points out that surveys show a significant increase of TV viewers and radio listeners in recent months, “similar to that which is seen following a catastrophe, because a society in danger immediately seeks signs of hope.”

But Restrepo argues that in spite of the heap of contradictions reported by the media, the press has become the only instrument that sheds some light on the crisis: “If reporters don’t investigate, who will? If journalists don’t report and inform, who will?”

If the press fails to respond to expectations of a disoriented society for which it has become “the last reference point, the only thing left to Colombia will be desperation,” he stresses.

But there are other less fatalistic opinions, such as that of columnist Arturo Guerrero.

Guerrero told IPS that in spite of the fact that the media are accomplices “in the great discrediting of the truth and the word,” the country could be “on the threshold of a major change, with unpredictable and surprising results.”

With the rumour “as a channel for the circulation of varying non-published truths,” a great change – comparable to the mass movement that without parties or ideologies knocked down the Berlin Wall – is brewing underground, “in the broad-based and informal meetings where hints of a rupture with the past can be perceived.”

According to Guerrero, journalists – not the media nor their owners, who always have truths that accomodate themselves to their own interests – will eventually be able to break with self- censorship, and little by little allow people to put together

their puzzle and reach the truth.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags