Saturday, November 21, 2026
Analysis - John Roberts
- Poor relations between Greece and Turkey are a constant worry to their partners in NATO and the latest clash in the Aegean over a couple of routinely uninhabited rocks have duly prompted fresh concern in the Western security organisation.
The NATO view — fuelled by a concern that small conflicts in the Balkans have a way of dragging large countries into their disputes — is that Greece and Turkey should try to find a way to resolve issues away from the glare of publicity.
“Both governments need to lead public opinion on this issue and not be led by it,” commented Tom Richardson, Assistant Under Secretary for Western Europe at the British Foreign Office, in a recent comment on tensions in the Aegean Sea.
“The signs are not good,” Richardson told a one-day seminar on Turkey held at London’s Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) on Tuesday. Meanwhile he urged both sides to refrain from military manoeuvres.
The latest dispute took western officials by surprise. Few could even name the principal rock in dispute. The Greeks call it Imia, while the Turks call it Kardak. The rocks have little or no commercial value.
In the past, they have been used for seasonal pasture, but they now constitute a major test for Greek-Turkish relations — and for the patience of the two rivals’ international partners in NATO.
The United States, in an unexpected show of political force, ordered the two sides apart during the night of Tuesday, Jan 30 and Wednesday Jan. 31 by dispatching ships to the area and demanding that both sides take their military forces off the island.
U.S. President Bill Clinton made telephone calls to the leaders of the two countries.
And U.S. Assistant Secretary of State Richard Holbrooke, fresh from his triumph in negotiating the recent Bosnian peace accords at Dayton, Ohio, publicly slammed the two supposed NATO allies for squabbling over “two rocks used for grazing goats.”
A senior Turkish official, Deputy Foreign Affairs Under Secretary Gunduz Aktan, commented in London that the islands’ issue was part of Greek-Turkish rivalry over their continental shelf. Turkey fears that Greece may use the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea to impose 12-mile territorial limits around the Greek islands of the Aegean.
Although Greece has not, in fact, extended its limits so far, the very possibility that it might do so worries Turkey because Ankara fears this would block Turkish access to the Aegean.
“Turkey is in favour of international negotiations,” on the issue of the continental shelf, Aktan told the RUSI seminar. “Greece is seemingly in favour of international arbitration. But they have never done so.”
Aktan said that the two countries’ 1930 Treaty of Friendship, which only last October was extended for a further five years, provides for compulsory arbitration over bilateral disputes, yet Greece had never sought to use the provisions of the Treaty in this manner.
For the Greeks, the issue is seen as a sign of Turkish aggression, since they believed the status of the rocks was not disputed as they were specifically covered by the Italian handover of the Dodecanese islands group to Greece in 1947.
The actual confrontation was sparked by an expedition by journalists from Turkey’s Hurriyet newspaper who replaced a Greek flag flying over the main rock with a Turkish flag following reports that the Greek navy was seeking to make islets such as Imia inhabitable.
Whatever the causes for the dispute, it rapidly escalated into near military conflict, with Turkish commandos breaching a Greek naval ring around the rocks immediately before the U.S intervention. They are at odds over Cyprus and the status of Moslems in north-eastern Greece, as well as over the Continental shelf.
Aktan said Turkey was particularly concerned over the European Union’s commitment to open full-scale negotiations on the entry of Cyprus into the European Union within six months of the forthcoming EU inter-governmental conference.
“Before there is a settlement in Cyprus, Cyprus should not become a full member of the European Union,” he told senior European Government officials and policy planners attending the RUSI meeting.
Yet Aktan remained optimistic that a way could be found to improve relations with Greece. “How can we solve these disputes except through dialogue?” he said. But the disputes did need to be resolved. “The southern flank of NATO has suffered” as a result of Greek-Turkish tensions, he acknowledged.
One of the ironies of the situation is that, in effect, both countries currently have only caretaker governments. In Athens, Mr Costas Simitis and his new left-of-centre government are due to face a vote of confidence on Friday required to confirm him in office following the recent retirement of Andreas Papandreou as premier.
Simitis was anyway expected to win the vote with ease, but his actions over Imia/Kardak will no doubt prove a major focus for Friday’s debate.
In Ankara, the question is whether the Kardak/Imia incident will improve or damage the prospects for Mme. Tansu Ciller and her True Path party.
Since the December 24 Turkish general elections — in which True Path came second (in terms of seats) or third (in terms of votes) — Mme. Çiller has remained in office on a caretaker basis whilst seeking to forge a new coalition that would ensure she, too, could win a vote of confidence as premier leading a new full government.
One point that was repeatedly made at the RUSI meeting was that Turkey may be losing an opportunity to create a new relationship with Greece now that Papandreou, who epitomised Greek antipathy to Turkey, has finally handed over to Simitis.
EU officials consider that new Greek government’s comments on both Greek-Turkish and Greek-European relations had been very encouraging, whereas in 1987 Papandreou took Greece to the brink of war with Turkey in another Aegean Sea dispute: the exploitation of mineral resources in waters close to Greek islands.