Friday, November 20, 2026
Isagani de Castro
- The United States is seeking the support of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum for an initiative to bring free trade into cyberspace — by creating a tariff-free environment for commerce done through the Internet.
But so far, the American campaign has drawn mostly cautious reactions, especially from APEC’s developing country members, many of which are not as well wired to the Internet as industrialised countries.
But because the U.S. government keen on pushing the issue in bodies like the World Trade Organisation and other fora, a declaration by APEC ministers issued over the weekend did say that “electronic commerce is an important technological breakthough” and a “tool for economic and social growth”.
Beyond that, however, officials from a number of developing countries did not quite know how to react to a proposal that as yet had little practical application to them.
As one senior official from the Philippines said, some developing economies found the issue “too advanced” for them. As a result, they did not want to make any premature commitments without studying conditions in their own countries and assessing its relevance to them.
In the end, APEC ministers merely called for a “workplan to study a wide range of issues on electronic commerce with a view to developing a predictable and consistent environment that enables all APEC economies to reap the benefits and foster growth of electronic commerce”. The plan will be reviewed in June 1998.
Developing countries said they wanted to study the implications of the U.S. proposal. “They (economies) did not want to make a precipitate decision,” a Filipino official said. “How could they when they did not know what the situation is?”
Others viewed the U.S. effort as another sign that highlights the breadth of criss-crossing interests that APEC’s 18 member economies — which groups economies as diverse as the U.S. and Indonesia and Papua New Guinea — bring to the forum. What is urgent to one group of countries may not necessarily be so to another.
The U.S. hopes that getting endorsement from as many countries as possible would hasten the chances of getting global acceptance of its “electronic commerce initiative”.
The model it has in mind may well be the International Technology Agreement, which Washington began lobbying for at the APEC meetings in the Philippines last year, then successfully pushed at the WTO in March 1997.
“Electronic commerce” would cover business done through the Internet on databases, graphical images, purchase orders, payments, price lists exchanged through cyberspace. It would involve purchases of products like books, songs, video through the Internet, for which payment would be done electronically and bypass official channels that impose tariffs or taxes.
In a recent speech on ‘A Framework for Global Electronic Commerce’, U.S. President Bill Clinton said the Internet would revolutionise retail and direct marketing and should not be subjected to “new and unnecessary regulations, bureaucratic procedures or taxes and taiffs on commercial activities”.
Having governments intervene with “unnecessary regulations” would raise the cost of products and services for consumers, he said. The Internet should be a “tariff-free environment whenever it is used to deliver products and sevices”, he said, adding that no new taxes should be imposed on Internet commerce.
American officials have presented the plan as one that would allow even small enterpreneurs in developing countries to become globally competitive from the start, get customers all over the world, and cut costs for both businesses and consumers.
The U.S. would be among the biggest winners from its Internet commerce proposal, simply because it is way ahead of other countries in the field. At the same time, American officials say they want to ensure that copyright protection is maintained for products and works disseminated electronically.
A study on electronic commerce activities by the American Electronic Association and American University says sales done through the Internet reached 200 million dollars in 1995. This should reach billions of dollars by the turn of the century.
In Asia, Internet hosts have grown five times in the last two years, according to U.S. Commerce Secretary William Daley who spoke of the emergence of a “global electronic marketplace”.
The U.S. also dominates the information technology industry and services. Its commerce department estimates that U.S. exports of electronic products like computer software, motion pictures, video and sound recordings, on-line newspapers, financial services and legal advice totalled 40 billion dollars in 1995.
After securing acceptance of the Information Technology Agreement, which would reduce tariffs on information technology and benefit hardware and software exporters, the U.S. is now eyeing a second accord to remove other remaining tariffs.
Among APEC’s Asian economies, the leading users of the Internet are Japan, Taiwan, South Korea, Hong Kong, Malaysia and Singapore. By one estimate, Internet use in Malaysia is growing at 500 percent yearly and by 173 percent in Japan. In comparison, there are limited but growing users in the Philippines, Thailand and Indonesia.