Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

CHURCH-PARAGUAY: Growing Concern over Political Instability

Carlos Montero

ASUNCION, Nov 18 1997 (IPS) - The Roman Catholic Church in Paraguay is becoming increasingly concerned over the current political instability and the possibility of an institutional rupture.

Religious authorities, meanwhile, are calling on the Church to assume the leadership role it abandoned after the end of the dictatorship of General Alfredo Stroessner (1954-89).

Catholic governors, mayors, government ministers, business representatives, workers, and members of the military and police forces expressed their worries in an assembly – “Builders of Society” – convoked by Archbishop of Asuncion Felipe Benitez.

The assembly’s proposals will be sent to the Nov. 30 archdiochesan pre-synod, which will address today’s “increasing technicalisation, and the impoverishment of the large majorities who are excluded from productive life,” said Benitez.

Paraguay’s top Catholic authority said that it was not up to him to propose alternative models, but added that he would denounce wrongs “in an evangelical sense” in order for church- goers to reflect on the current situation.

The Paraguayan political scene has been in a shaky situation since more than a month ago, after the ruling Colorado Party refused to recognise retired General Lino Oviedo’s triumph in internal party elections in which he was chosen presidential candidate for next May’s elections.

Party authorities have challenged the results of the internal party poll before the electoral courts, and are seeking to expell him from the party. The government, meanwhile, has taken legal action against him on charges of rebellion – he led a failed coup attempt in 1996 – and ordered his arrest.

But the former army commander has been at large since Oct. 3, and his lawyers accuse President Juan Carlos Wasmosy of trying to remove him from the electoral campaign by killing him or staging a “self-coup”.

“Builders of Society”, which opened Nov. 14 and will continue this Friday, concluded that the Catholic Church in Paraguay has taken a passive role in the post-dictatorship years.

In the last stage of the Stroessner regime, the churches served as meeting places and refuges for and defenders of opponents of the dictatorship and human rights activists.

Senator Secundino Nunez of the political opposition said that since the 1989 military coup which overthrew Stroessner, irregularities had practically stopped being denounced due to a lack of “priests with more convincing positions and with bite.”

But he said “there are signs of a resurgence of the pastors of the dictatorship era, who through their conduct presented the Church as a brave and even bold fighter.”

Bishop Claudio Gimenez, from the neighbouring department of Cordillera, took advantage of his Sunday mass on Nov. 16 to urge church-goers to avoid “the penury of submission to a totalitarian government.”

In the “national sanctuary” of Caacupe, where the image of Paraguay’s patron saint is worshipped, he called on the people to avoid a confrontation with bloodshed at any cost.

“God save us from what could happen if we fail now to make an effort to build a fraternal society with solidarity,” said the bishop, alluding to the current political instability.

A letter from Paraguay’s bishops – “A Path of Hope in the Face of the Latest Events at the Country’s Social and Political Level” – was issued in April in preparation for the synod of bishops from the Americas, which began this week in the Vatican.

The letter was aimed at averting “a repetition of the painful experiences of 50 years ago – or of only nine years ago,” said Gimenez, in a reference to the 1954 and 1989 coups staged by generals Alfredo Stroessner and Andres Rodriguez.

The director of Paraguay’s National Anti-Drugs Secretariat (SENAD), General Carlos Ayala, said outside the government house that he would stage “a beautiful revolution” in 1998 if Oviedo became president.

The statement earned him a “rap on the knuckles” from the president according to Ayala, who insisted that his comment had been only “a joke.”

Oviedo’s spokesman, Alejandro Velazquez, said that if “this country’s institutions worked properly, Ayala would be behind bars.”

Alluding to the conflict between Wasmosy and Oviedo, Bishop Gimenez warned that desperation sets in “when there is no mercy between brothers.”

The new assistant bishop of Asuncion, Adalberto Martinez, said “there are wounds and division, deep sores that require healing efforts.”

After being ordained in his post earlier this month, Martinez added that the discord “holds a threat over all citizens” due to the lack of a “peaceful reconciliation in political spheres.”

And on Nov. 7, the 150th ordinary full assembly of the Paraguayan Episcopal Conference (CEP) committed itself “to defending the democratic state,” and called for peace within the governing party.

CEP secretary Pastor Cuquejo added that his task would include preaching “very clear criteria for electing candidates,” on which “the progress or backwardness of the people themselves” depends.

Lay movements that work in local parishes held an assembly the next day, and signed a document that warned of the threat of an institutional rupture.

Political analyst Carlos Martini, who addressed the meeting, described the current sociopolitical situation as “a social failure with economic stagnation, where impunity reigns.” People “believe in the church in search of moral security and in the press because it denounces corruption,” he added.

“The best thing Wasmosy could do would be to hand over the presidential sash peacefully to his successor, whether a member of the Colorado party or the opposition,” he stressed.

His listeners rejected “the messianic ideas of Oviedo’s demagogic discourse…and any short cut that overturns institutions,” such as a government proposal to extend Wasmosy’s presidency beyond Aug. 15.

The laypersons committed themselves to working in favour of the dispossessed, “in the face of the government’s lack of health, security, education and agrarian reform programmes.”

Peasant farmers who held protest marches in the past two years have received food and organisational support from the Asuncion Seminary.

Heated debates have been unleashed among Christian business leaders on the concept of private property and justifications put forth by bishops in impoverished rural areas of occupations of idle land.

“The business community has indeed merited its bad fame of exploiters,” Pedro Fadul, the president of the Association of Christian Entrepreneurs (ADEC), admitted to IPS.

The financier, named “businessman of the year” in 1994, said that “earning money is our talent and obligation, to create wealth that is distributed,” a concept he developed in his thesis on an Economy of Solidarity.

Recent ADEC seminars have sought to promote that idea based on “ethical principles of solidarity and technical principles of the market economy” – without confusing “solidarity with communism.”

However, Fadul criticised the bishops’ justification of invasions of land in poor rural areas – where 70 percent of Paraguay’s poor are concentrated – land that had been abandoned after the trees were cut down and sold.

In the eighth meeting between Paraguay’s bishops and business community in late August, Fadul – speaking in the name of the powerful business association – said that “the taking of other people’s property should be prohibited,” except in the case of legal expropriation by the state itself.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags