Saturday, November 21, 2026
David Hecht
- Many in this West African country have reacted angrily to claims that the international slave trade did not take place here to the extent that had been supposed.
The furore is over an article that appeared in late December in the French newspaper le Monde, suggesting that Senegal’s notorious island of Goree, near Dakar, was not what it is said to have been — one of Africa’s major slave trading posts and the last stop for the millions of Africans forcibly taken to the Americas.
“This is like those who deny the Jewish holocaust ever existed,” commented Mohammed Faye, a secondary school teacher in Dakar. Many others say it is an attack on their cultural heritage.
The UN Cultural, Educational and Scientific Organisation (UNESCO) lists Goree as a ‘world historical site’ and every year thousands of tourists make pilgrimages there, many of them the descendants of slaves from the United States.
Pope John Paul II came in 1992 and was the first pope to have set foot in what are said to have been slave dungeons, in the ‘Maison des Esclaves’ or house of slaves. It is one of the many elegant merchant’s homes that line the cobblestone streets on the tiny island, most of which are now homes of Senegal’s elite.
While it is no larger than the other buildings, up to 40 million slaves passed through it, at least 5 million of them having gone to the United States, according to its curator, Joseph N’Diaye.
The highlight of a tour through the building is a small doorway facing the sea where rowboats are said to have picked up the slaves and taken them to nearby sailing ships for the mid-Atlantic voyage. Above the doorway a curatorial sign reads ‘Voyage with No Return’.
The problem is, the story is a fiction, says the le Monde article. Its author, Emmanuel de Roux, quotes the curator of the nearby History Museum of Goree, Abdoulaye Camara, as well as Pere de Beniost, a French historian and catholic priest at Dakar’s cathedral, as saying that the ‘house of slaves,’ is “a myth”.
The so-called dungeons were mostly for the produce of the merchant owner, and perhaps some rooms were used for “domestic slaves but certainly not slaves for trading”, according to the article.
Roux further claims the building was only built in 1783, toward the end of the slave trade. Some slaves were traded elsewhere on the island, he says, but at most 500 a year.
Indeed, historians have expressed doubts about Goree’s importance in the slave trade since at least the 1950’s, with some claiming that over hundreds of years, no more than 10,000 slaves were traded there. Philip Curtin, a professor of history at John Hopkins University in the United States who has written numerous books on the slave trade, says he has long believed Goree is a “hoax”.
“A lot of people have been taken in by the Goree scam…. Meanwhile, the “house of slaves” has become an emotional shrine to the slave trade, rather than a serious museum,” he said.
Yet, it is only with the article appearing in the French media that many people in Senegal, a former French colony, have become aware of the claim.
N’Diaye, however, continues to insist his history is accurate, and characterises Roux as a “revisionist” with a hidden agenda. Senegalese state television is supporting N’Diaye, recently re- airing an old documentary in which he details Goree’s role in the slave trade. And most other Senegalese seem to support him also.
“Three out of four people here know that Goree is where most of the slaves left from,” explained a taxi driver. “And the one in four are just trying to deny their past because they are ashamed.”
Yet those who question the history do not seem ashamed at all. They say that the island is just too small to have coped with a massive volume, and that Europeans families would not have been comfortable living so close to the violence commonly meted out to freshly captured Africans. They point instead to more factory-like settings like Elima castle in Ghana with its vast dungeons and convenient location.
Senegalese officials seem concerned that the findings will risk millions of tourist dollars. One of Roux’s sources, Abdoulaye Camara, denies that he ever called the house of slaves a myth.
The Minister for the Environment, Abdoulaye Bathily, who is also a history professor at Dakar university, is unequivocal: “the house of slaves existed. From there, slaves were sent to the Americas. I am positive about it,” he says.
Professor Achille Mbembe, the recently appointed head of the Council for the Development of Social Research in Africa (CODESRIA), recognises that N’Diaye’s assertion “may not be a matter of historical record”. But he points out that “it isn’t possible to comprehend the significance [of slavery] … if one considers it only a matter of numbers”.
“One can never truly know how many people suffered in this deadly commerce, nor if one could, would it be useful in trying to comprehend the magnitude of human exploitation,” said Mbembe.