Sunday, November 22, 2026
Anil Netto
- Malaysia’s state-of-the-art Kuala Lumpur International Airport formally opens this Saturday, but one fact will not receive much publicity amid the expected fanfare: the 3.5 billion-dollar airport was partly financed by a cheap loan from a state-run workers’ retirement fund.
The 1.5 billion-ringgit (about 375 million dollars) loan has a lower-than-market interest of eight percent per annum, which has rankled critics of the lender, the Employees Provident Fund (EPF).
But they say the airport loan is only the latest in a series of questionable investments and loans made by the EPF that have led to the lowest dividend in 21 years for Malaysian workers.
The EPF is no ordinary agency. Its 129 billion ringgit (32.25 billion dollars) in investment assets probably makes it the richest Malaysian state agency. Many say it also makes EPF a tempting cash cow for officials on the look-out for cheap sources of funds to tide the country through what is turning out to be a crippling recession.
The EPF’s substantial capital comes from a law that obliges Malaysian employers to deduct 11 percent from each worker’s salary as the employee’s contribution to his or her EPF account, while employers have to contribute an additional 12 percent (of the salary) into the worker’s EPF account.
These forced retirement savings are also largely responsible for Malaysia having one of the highest savings rates in the world, along with countries like Singapore, which operates a similar pension scheme.
But when the EPF Board announced a dividend of only 6.7 percent last year, it triggered widespread dissatisfaction among the fund’s eight million contributors. Many are now also grumbling over giving a chunk of their salary each month to the EPF at a time when banks are offering 11 percent interest for fixed or term deposits.
It was not always like this. Since 1977, the EPF had credited each worker’s account with an annual dividend ranging from seven to 8.5 percent.
Ironically, during the last major recession in the mid-1980s, the EPF Board declared a dividend of 8.5 percent for five straight years, the highest dividend rate in the last two decades. Those dividend rates had compared favourably with bank fixed deposit interest rates then.
It was no surprise then that workers’ representatives howled in protest when the 6.7 percent dividend for 1997 was announced. After all, they pointed out, the economy expanded by almost eight percent last year, so why such a low dividend?
“This makes the EPF an investment fund with the lowest rate in comparison to other savings schemes or trust funds,” said a statement endorsed by seven trade unions. The low dividend, they added, “implies that something has gone wrong with the way the EPF manages its investments”.
The root cause for last year’s low dividend lies probably in the EPF’s heavy exposure in the stock market, where it had sunk about 19 percent of its assets or 25 billion ringgit (6.25 billion dollars).
Corporate earnings tumbled in the wake of the Asian financial crisis, leading to a measly four percent yield for EPF’s stock investments.
As parliamentary opposition leader Lim Kit Siang observes, “The EPF suffered losses as a result of its forays into the Kuala Lumpur stock market during the financial turmoil in the second half of 1997.”
Last September, Premier Mahathir Mohamad announced the setting up of a 60 billion-ringgit rescue fund, using money from various state agencies including the EPF, to prop up the local bourse. The attempt proved unsuccessful as share prices continued to slide. But no one knows how much EPF and the other agencies lost in the process.
No one can say for sure either how much of the EPF’s 25 billion ringgit invested in shares has been wiped out as the Kuala Lumpur Stock Exchange continues to plunge.
EPF critics also note that the Fund had handed out an even bigger sum in cheap loans in recent years.
These loans, which reached a total of 34 billion ringgit, earned an average of only 6.5 percent last year. This rate of return is lower that what the EPF earned from its 38 billion ringgit invested in safer Malaysian Government securities, which attracted a return of 7.7 percent in 1997.
Some of these loans are known to have been for expensive infrastructure projects, or “mega projects” as they are called by Malaysians. But not much else has been divulged regarding the loan recipients and if the loans are recoverable.
The silence of the EPF Board on the matter has only bred suspicion. Said the seven unions: “It appears to many workers that the EPF has been used to bail out certain companies affected by the economic downturn.”
But the EPF may yet have worse news in store for its already upset contributors as share prices plunge deeper and company earnings take a direct hit from the economic slowdown. As a result, the dividend for this year is likely to be even lower than last year’s.
Critics feel most of the EPF’s woes could have been avoided had it taken a more cautious approach.
Echoing the sentiments of disgruntled EPF contributors, Lim wonders, “Could the EPF have done better with a prudent investment policy to safeguard the interest of the subscribers rather than by bailing out troubled companies or individuals?”