Saturday, November 21, 2026
Analysis - Niccolo' Sarno
- Recriminations continue to fly around Brussels in the wake of the damning report that forced the resignation of all 20 members of the European Unions’s executive commission.
While Jacques Santer, the president of the European Commission (EC) says the independent report’s findings of mismanagement, fraud, and nepotism are “wholly unjustified in tone” elsewhere in Brussels other Eurocrats want Santer out of the picture – and fast.
The President of the European Parliament, Jose Maria Gil-Robles, making the most of the most tumultuous day in the EU’s 42 year-old history, says ~all 20 commissioners must leave their posts immediately.
‘A new Commission which will enjoy the Parliament’s confidence must be appointed,’ says Gil-Robles who believes a new Commission shouild be in place in May.
Germany, current holder of the rotating DU presidency, however has told the Commission to continue working, in a caretaker capacity. The EC’s four-year mandate ends in December and the duration of the ‘caretaking’ period will depend on the 15 EU member states, which already have expressed divergent views.
Santer says that the commissioners will continue to be in charge “until our replacement is provided for under the relevant procedures.”
Santer also said that there will be “no blockage of the institutions or the matters they are dealing with” and that the EC will continue to do its work.
Nevertheless, sources at the European Commission told IPS that some procedures for approval of future humanitarian projects as well as for staff recruitment are expected to be slowed considerably.
The report mentions no evidence of fraud on the part of commissioners themselves. But the experts found cases where “commissioners or the commission as a whole bear responsibility for instances of fraud, irregularities or mismanagement.”
The document says that “the responsibility of individual Commissioners, or of the Commission as a body, cannot be a vague idea, a concept which in practice proves unrealistic.”
“Each individual must feel accountable for the measures he or she manages,” warns the report.
Paradoxically, the word ‘accountability’ is one of those on which the EU is putting a strong emphasis while negotiating a new agreement with the 71 countries of the Africa, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) group, with which it has a giant trade and aid pact, the Lome Convention, which is due to expire in February 2000.
Accountability is one of four elements (the others are openness, popular participation and efficiency) that together should bring “good governance,” a concept that the Europeans are trying to include among the so-called “essential elements” of the Lome Convention.
Failure by an ACP state to meet these conditions can result in the Convention being suspended unilaterally by the EC.
The ACP nations fear that including good governance among the essential elements is an attempt to impose new conditions to the pact. Most believe that the EU request will mean Lome benefits will depend on the application the European social and political standards.
Again this week, the Commission told Cuba, which has applied to become a full member of the Lome Convention, that it has to accept the basic principles of the Convention, including its Article V, which states that “development aid shall be linked to the recognition and application of democratic principles, the consolidation of the rule of law and good governance.”
In order for Cuba to become a member, said EU chief negotiator Philip Lowe on March 15, it must accept “the basic principles” of the Convention.
But now the is the question of the accountability of the European Commission. “For the time being, Parliament does not trust (the Commission),” says Gil-Robles.
French Prime Minister Lionel Jospin echoes these sentiments in calling for democratic changes to be made within the entire European Union structure.
“This crisis must, in our view, at least be a starting point for obtaining more transparency and democracy in the workings of Europe,” he told his national assembly on Tuesday.
In the United Kingdom, ‘The Independent’ newspaper suggests that Europe is “institutionally corrupt”. The paper calls for a written constitution, and democratically accountable structures.
Non-governmental organisations (NGOs) have seized the moment to voice their criticism about the lack of coordination among commissioners who are in charge of the EU’s relations with poor countries.
Out of 20 Commissioners, five are in charge of the relations with countries in the South and the East for either trade or aid.
The liaison committee of European Non-Governmental Organisations – which represents more than 900 European NGOs– wants political leaders to “think about a better distribution of commissioners’ portfolios.”
The committee considers that the way in which duties are shared within the present Commission is not satisfactory, and that the current distribution “is incoherent in its development and humanitarian aid policies.
Another criticism voiced by NGOs, and by Europe’s major trading partners such as the United States, is the negative impact of some EU ‘internal policies’ – for instance its huge common agricultural policy – on other countries’ economies, especially those of developing nations.
EU policies aimed at helping European agricultural and fisheries sectors, both of which rely heavily on subsidies, give a comparative advantage to EU farmers and industry.
This often is in conflict with the EU’s policy on development aid, which is geared towards helping developing nations improve their own economies.
The European Union is the single largest donor of development and humanitarian aid, and roughly half of the EU money is distributed through the European Commission. The other half is disbursed by EU countries directly to beneficiary countries as bilateral aid.
The present crisis, the worst ever in the EU history, has come few days before its leaders meet to try to overhaul the bloc’s budget, a necessary step to pave the way for its Eastward expansion into former Communist countries.