Europe, Headlines

IRELAND-RELIGION: Catholic and Protestants Reassess Their Roles

Sarah O'Hara

DUBLIN, Jul 6 1995 (IPS) - The fragile peace in Northern Ireland has opened the door for Catholic and Protestant clergy to reassess their roles in society — recognising that the 25-year conflict has tarnished the region’s image and by extension that of the church.

“All over the world the Irish have a reputation for violence,” writes a Catholic priest in a new book, ‘After the Ceasefires: Catholics and the Future of Northern Ireland’. “Most of this, in the past twenty-five years, comes from the conflict in the north.”

“It is a major block to opening up non-Christian areas of the world to the riches of Christianity, because their image of Ireland is one of violence. Irish churches have a mammoth task to change this image,” writes Father Brian Lennon, a Jesuit priest.

Lennon’s concern about the image of Christianity is echoed by a Church of Ireland rector, Timothy Kinahan, in a book from the same publisher.

Reverend Kinahan writes: “I recently heard of a Japanese Buddhist, interested in converting to Christianity, who drew back because of the effect that Northern Irish ‘Christians’ had on him. If Buddhist sects in Japan could live together, he reckoned that Buddhism was preferable to Christianity.”

In ‘Where Do We Go From Here?: Protestants and the Future of Northern Ireland’, Kinahan sticks to basic principles in arguing the link between religion and justice.

Northern Irish Protestants have been “conditioned to regard all questions of justice as little more than a half truth, a political ploy used by the nationalist minority to massage discontent”, he says.

He criticises the dominant ideology of his community as “a conservative one, an attitude of mind that would prefer things not to change, that would cling to an irretrievable past”.

Since the paramilitary ceasefires of last year, Northern Ireland seems finally to be on the brink of a lasting peace.

All-party talks aimed at reaching a political settlement still seem to be a distant prospect. It is timely that these two Christians are looking at what needs to changed in their own religious community, rather than focusing on the other.

In August 1994, the Irish Republican Army (IRA), which was fighting for a united Ireland, announced the end of their armed campaign. This was followed in October by a ceasefire from the pro- British loyalist paramilitaries.

Kinahan’s book is an attempt to relate the bible’s views on the status quo to Northern Irish society.

“I believe that, for too long, Northern Irish Protestant Christians like myself have let their politics rule their religion, rather than the other way around. Our so-called Protestantism has become so intimately bound up with our ‘loyalism’, our ‘Britishness’, that the two have become inseparable.”

In response to the anti-Catholic tendency of the more fundamentalist Protestant churches, Kinahan is also at pains to argue for the value of being open-minded.

“Each of our churches has a different gift: the Presbyterians a gift of Scriptural knowledge; the Baptists the gift of regenerative preaching; the Roman Catholics the gift of contemplative prayer and sacramental worship; the Church of Ireland the gift of liturgical worship and pastoral care; the Methodists the gift of hymn singing; the Salvation Army the gift of good works; the Quakers the gift of peacemaking, and so on,” he writes.

The way forward, Kinahan says, is to recognise that we are all “different parts of the same body and not competing bodies”.

Liberation theology is used by Lennon to analyse Northern Irish society, but he says that it’s not enough to make a radical critique of society and link it to the scriptures. The idea of liberation must also be linked with “a theology of reconciliation”.

Lennon argues that the need for justice — which requires new political structures and a police force that is representative, accountable and subject to an independent complaint mechanism — goes hand in hand with the need for reconciliation, involving repentance and forgiveness.

He recognises that from the point of view of liberation theology, reconciliation is “a soft approach which avoids conflict and in the end maintains the status quo…the poor stay poor.”

However, in Northern Ireland, despite high rates of unemployment, the constitutional issue — of who has dominion over Northern Ireland — dominates political discourse, rather than poverty.

“What dominates the minds of most people is not unemployment, or how people can work together to overcome it, but the political situation and the violence caused by it.” Hence, all attempts to formulate a class-based politics have foundered on “the national question”.

Both communities feel under threat, and for communities under threat nothing is as important as survival, Lennon says.

The reason for the mutual sense of threat is that while Catholics are a majority on the island as a whole, they are a minority within Northern Ireland. And Protestants are a minority on the island. “The source of the threat is always defined as the other community and this applies to rich and poor within that community,” writes Lennon.

His solution is “a theology of reconciliation”.

He asks Christians: “How far are we willing to go to be with people who have offended us? Are we willing to stand alongside them as Christ was?”

Kinahan asks Christians to make a return to God, and to allow for differing interpretations of what that means. God, rather than an image of God made up of a rulebook taken from a particular reading of the Bible.

Feeling under threat — feeling fearful — means that a Christian community has forgotten its God, he writes.

Speaking of his own Protestant people, who are descended from “colonial” stock, Kinahan writes: “Deep down we have feared the Gaelic people (the native Irish) whom our ancestors dispossessed.

“We have feared their church and their political representatives. And since partition we have feared Dublin. Had we been fully focused on God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, I am sure that all of those other fears would long ago have evaporated, and that we could by now be calling ourselves a Christian nation, living in the excitement of God’s shalom (peace).”

Words which hold true for Catholics, in their own way, as well as Protestants.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags