Saturday, November 21, 2026
Analysis - Mushahid Hussain
- Seeking to reward Pakistan for its support to the U.S.-led war against terrorism, the United States has lifted sanctions imposed in May 1998 against India and Pakistan after both conducted nuclear tests.
What is significant is that while sanctions were to be lifted against India anyway, Pakistan is getting the even-handed treatment with its neighbour and arch-rival as a result of Islamabad’s support for the United States, including providing air space and sharing intelligence after the crisis sparked by the September 11 carnage.
Pakistan is suddenly being showered with goodies, with the lifting of American sanctions only the first step.
The New York Times reported on Sep. 22 that the Bush administration “was also discussing a large American aid package for Pakistan” and it quoted a senior official as saying: “We’re looking at a large number. How much in cash and how much in debt relief is still being debated.”
Ten per cent of Pakistan’s external debt of 30 billion U.S. dollars is owed to the United States.
Other initiatives are reported to include doubling of IMF assistance for poverty alleviation to 5 billion U.S. dollars as well as aid from Japan. A ministerial delegation from the European Union is also scheduled to arrive in Islamabad on Sep. 25.
Meanwhile, President General Pervez Musharraf has received “thank you” calls from President George W Bush and Secretary of State Colin Powell. It’s a sea change in status since a virtual “pariah” has been transformed into a “friend” within days, and the reasons are apparent.
First, the United States is rewarding Pakistan for its support.
Second, politically, by simultaneously lifting sanctions against both India and Pakistan, Washington’s message is that of even- handedness in its South Asia policy: Pakistan is being treated at par with a much larger India, and is not being discriminated against, a long-standing Pakistani criticism of U.S. policy towards South Asia.
Third, Washington is conveying that it has long-term stakes in Pakistan’s economic and political stability, and it’s not just a one-off gesture of support. Rather this support is strategic, aimed at allaying Pakistani concerns that “once the United States has used Pakistan, it ditches friends”.
This sentiment surfaced in 1990 after the U.S. stopped military assistance to Pakistan over its suspected possession of nuclear weapons, despite Islamabad’s key role as a “frontline state” in Washington’s campaign against Soviet expansionism in Afghanistan.
Going by Bush’s declaration of war in his address to Congress, and other indications, including the military buildup close to Afghanistan, the government has apparently taken a decision to “punish” the Taliban for providing refuge to Osama bin Laden. But it is not sure as to how and when to do it or what the fallout would be on the United States and its allies..
The biggest problem Washington faces is on the public opinion front in the Muslim world, most of which is yet to be convinced about the linkage between the September 11 crime and Afghanistan, or the rationale for going to war where the enemy, target or evidence remains undisclosed.
Hence, Powell did well to tell the media on Sunday that the United States would share the evidence it has regarding bin Laden’s involvement in the September 11 crime with its allies.
In the absence of hard evidence linking bin Laden with the criminal acts of Sep 11, U.S. actions that may be in the offing are being seen more as being guided by politics than the principle of combating terrorism.
Most Muslims perceive that the Bush administration is being pushed to action to assuage the appetite for revenge, retribution and retaliation that is deeply felt by its own people given the scale and enormity of the carnage, in which thousands of innocent people were killed. And poverty- stricken Afghanistan, lacking in any infrastructure, is an easy, convenient and ready target.
However, given the stakes involved, Pakistan together with Muslim countries like Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Jordan and Uzbekistan, need to pressure the United States to avoid a policy that Washington or its Muslim allies will neither be able to control nor cope with.
They are likely to feel the maximum and immediate fallout of any American military action that would, in turn, evoke further anti-Americanism in the Muslim World. Such fears are well founded, and have already been voiced.
In his statement on Saturday, Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak advised the Americans: “If you launch an attack on Afghanistan, you will kill many innocent people just as terrorists killed many of your innocent people. Don’t play the game of your enemy,” he warned. He said a U.S. military action would spawn “a new generation of militants who will cry for revenge from the US.”
The Arab League Secretary General Amr Moussa said on Sunday that “military action against any Arab state would be unacceptable,” a clear reference to Iraq or Sudan. And the Gulf Cooperation Council, which groups the six Muslim Gulf kingdoms of Saudi Arabia, Oman, Qatar, United Arab Emirates, Kuwait and Bahrain, after a meeting of foreign ministers in Riyadh, condemned the attacks on America but also denounced Israeli actions against Palestinians.
Terrorism is very much the premier internal security problem for Muslim countries like Pakistan, Egypt, Algeria and Saudi Arabia, but however the United States may define it, the coming “war against terrorism” carries with it germs of a conflict that could be veering to a “clash of civilisations” if Washington were to follow up with its declaration of war by bombing Afghanistan.
Instead of waiting for the Americans to act in Afghanistan, and with an eye on the fallout of that action, Pakistan should urge dialogue to resolve the crisis, treating the Taliban’s flexibility on Osama bin Laden as an opening to pursue the political option.
Cooperation with the United States on terrorism plus preventing war should be Pakistan’s twin priorities in the current crisis.