Saturday, November 21, 2026
Gustavo González
- Chilean President Ricardo Lagos said he hoped his country would finally have a divorce law before year- end, although he underlined that he would not seek urgent treatment for the bill under discussion, to avoid throwing a wrench into the plan to update a 117-year-old law.
The president’s “cautious haste” reflects the heavy influence on politicians and society at large of the Roman Catholic Church’s fierce opposition to passage of a divorce law in this Southern Cone country, the only one of the so-called “Western democracies” to lack such legislation.
Lagos expressed his hope that a bill which would reform the Civil Marriage law and make divorce legal would be debated and passed in the current legislative session, which opened May 21.
The initiative, sponsored by parliamentarians of the governing centre-left coalition, was approved by the lower house of Congress, the Chamber of Deputies, in September 1997, but has not yet made it through the Senate.
“This is not the time for urgency,” said the president Sunday, referring to the bill in statements to the Chilevisión TV channel.
“If I press [for passage of the divorce law], bills that are in the door of the oven could be pushed aside,” argued Lagos, a moderate socialist.
Chile’s constitution, which was approved by referendum in 1980 under the 1973-90 dictatorship of General Augusto Pinochet, is heavily presidential, and grants the executive branch the exclusive power to set time-limits and deadlines for debating and voting bills in Congress.
Requests that Lagos turn on the heat to get the divorce law passed have come from several of his cabinet ministers, as well as ruling coalition lawmakers like Deputy Isabel Allende, vice- president of the Socialist Party (PS) and daughter of the late former president Salvador Allende (1970-1973).
Since the Republic of Ireland enacted a divorce law in 1996, by means of a plebiscite, Chile is the only Western-style representative democracy lacking legislation allowing the legal dissolution of marriage.
According to the Civil Marriage law, which dates back 117 years and has undergone no major amendments, the only way a married couple can be legally separated is through a controversial system of annulments.
Criticised as “legal hypocrisy,” annulment is achieved after the couple “proves” in court, generally through false witnesses, that there were flaws in the civil procedures followed when the couple was originally married.
The arguments on which annulments are based are often as trivial as a declaration by one of the spouses that the address marked on the marriage certificate was erroneous, which meant the justice of the peace who married them did not actually have jurisdiction.
Until recently, when a marriage was annulled, the spouses became single once again, and their sons and daughters were re- assigned to the categories “natural” (recognised by both parents) or “illegitimate” (not recognised by the father).
However, in 1999 a new law was passed that put an end to those discriminatory categories and granted all children equal rights.
Experts believe passage of the new law was one of the reasons for the increase in the number of annulments, from 5.27 to 10.72 percent of marriages, between 1998 and 2000.
In that same period, the marriage rate dropped from eight to 4.2 per 1,000 inhabitants, indicating a rise in the number of couples living together outside of marriage – and, according to many analysts, reflecting the crisis facing the institution of matrimony in Chile.
A glance at Chile’s public figures gives a good idea of just how solid marriages are in Chile, starting with Lagos himself and his wife Luisa Durán, both of whom are in their second marriage, after annulling their first.
The minister of the National Women’s Service Adriana Delpiano, of the co-governing Party for Democracy (PPD), triggered the latest round of controversy over divorce by announcing in late May that the president would give urgent treatment to the bill that has been pending since 1997.
Critics immediately spoke up among the right-wing opposition as well as the ruling alliance, which is made up of the PS, the PPD, and the Christian Democrat (PDC) and Radical Social Democratic (PRSD) parties.
PS Senator José Antonio Viera-Gallo and PDC legislators argued that before the divorce law was approved, it was necessary to pass a bill that would create family courts.
Interior Minister José Miguel Insulza of the PS, who also lives with his second wife after having his first marriage annulled, initially refuted Delpiano’s announcement before stating last week that the government would simultaneously press for the divorce and family court laws.
In statements published Monday in the daily ‘El Mercurio’, Jorge Morales, a PDC lawyer and adviser to the Episcopal Conference, argued, as does the Catholic Church, that legislation on the break- up of marriages is necessary, but without instituting divorce.
The Catholic hierarchy, as well as some conservative politicians, say the annulment system should be perfected by outlining grounds for annulment that would give the system legal transparency, but that there should be no dissolution of the matrimonial bond, which according to Morales “is a contract that is social as well as personal and individual” in nature.
In the case of marriage, “society is represented by the other spouse, by the children if there are any, and by society at large,” argued the lawyer.
For the Catholic Church, making marriage something that can be dissolved would bring about a negative “human and cultural change of great magnitude, because we would move from a family-based to a couple-based culture.
“In the United States, half of all children do not know their father or have no relationship with him, or merely an erratic one,” said Morales.
But Deputy Allende, arguing for the need to “update a law that dates back over a century,” pointed out that in this country of 15 million, there were one million people whose marriages had been annulled, or who were simply living separate lives in practice, and who in many cases had formed new families but were unable to normalise their lives or their relationships with their children.
“We’re talking about civil marriage, not religious marriage, in regards to which believers and the Church have a full right to express their views. We respect those views, but the reality in Chile is that eight percent of men and 11 percent of women are affected by the rupture of the ties of marriage,” said Allende.
The newly heated debate on the bill has highlighted the fact that divorce is an issue that cuts across party loyalties and escapes the categories of “government” and “opposition”, and even falls outside the division between Catholic believers and non- believers.
One of the most outspoken supporters of the divorce law is Iván Moreira, a parliamentary deputy of the conservative Independent Democratic Union, and a supporter of Pinochet. A year ago, Moreira got married for the third time, after his first two marriages were annulled.